Border Fences Will Not Stop Migrants Heading to Europe Says Think-Tank

Migrants and refugees wait to continue their train journey to western Europe at a refugee transit camp in Slavonski Brod, Croatia. A leading think-tank has said that border fences will not deter migrants from attempting to get into Europe. REUTERS/Darrin Zammit Lupi

By Emma Batha

LONDON, Feb 10 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) – Efforts by European countries to deter migrants with border fences, teargas and asset seizures will not stem the flow of people into the continent, and European leaders should make their journeys safer, a think-tank said on Wednesday.

The Overseas Development Institute (ODI) said Europe must act now to reduce migrant deaths in the Mediterranean, where nearly 4,000 people died last year trying to reach Greece and Italy, and more than 400 have died so far this year.

European governments could open consular outposts in countries like Turkey and Libya which could grant humanitarian visas to people with a plausible asylum claim, the think-tank said.

Allowing people to fly directly to Europe would be safer and cheaper than for them to pay people smugglers, and would help cripple the smuggling networks that feed off the migrant crisis, the London-based ODI said.

More than 1.1 million people fleeing poverty, war and repression in the Middle East, Asia and Africa reached Europe’s shores last year, prompting many European leaders to take steps to put people off traveling.

But the ODI said new research showed such attempts either fail to alter people’s thinking or merely divert flows to neighboring states.

Researchers interviewed 52 migrants from Syria, Eritrea and Senegal who had recently arrived in Germany, Britain and Spain. Their journeys had cost an average 2,680 pounds ($3,880) each.

More than one third had been victims of extortion, and almost half the Eritreans had been kidnapped for ransom during their journey.


Researchers said that, contrary to popular perception, many migrants left home without a clear destination in mind. Their experiences along the way and the people they met informed where they would go next.

Information from European governments was unlikely drastically to alter migrants’ behavior, the ODI said.

“Our research suggests that while individual EU member states may be able to shift the flow of migration on to their neighbors through deterrent measures such as putting up fences, using teargas and seizing assets, it does little to change the overall number … coming to Europe,” said report co-author Jessica Hagen-Zanker.

“As one of the people we interviewed put it ‘When one door shuts, another opens’.”

Hungary erected fences along its southern border last year to stop migrants crossing it en route to western Europe. Switzerland is seizing migrants’ and refugees’ assets to help pay for their upkeep. Denmark has approved similar seizures.

But Hagen-Zanker said route closures were counter-productive because they made migrants’ journeys more expensive, reducing their ability to support themselves when they arrived.

The study showed migrants’ decisions were influenced less by restrictive policies and more by job opportunities, safety and access to education.

The ODI called for a fairer EU-wide asylum processing system and reforms to share responsibilities more evenly between EU countries.

Search and rescue missions in the Mediterranean should also be scaled up, it said.

Researchers said politicians and the wider public must start seeing refugees as a resource rather than a problem.

They called for greater efforts to provide migrants with language lessons and skills training which would increase their ability to support themselves and help fill job gaps in European economies.

“The migration debate, at least in the UK, is remarkably fact-free,” the report said.

($1 = 0.6911 pounds)

Social Streams

Facebook Comments

Post a comment