EU Demands Apple Pay Ireland up to 13 bln Euros in Tax

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?*P8(R`(`qH)ANN 4\杚hpKLBN(1Xp)Gp(Ӆ6@XQKޒi,;(g4)EP449QEéZ)GJ\QLӨii( /zS@M R@-5;45!AJ))EfXS4kQC[UT/ڞܮ٨ڦuMz0ꀀz[,CH)M`cצ):SZ(LRR60zS b#%2,m+y1J);S )?5cNM+ AֺɇJ>--6! 4ө*%(iN 4Ɠi>)1@ "SHA.c SHBT8ZZLEK@IKEb JZCLqN?!4Na 01 )R!{Ӆ Z1]F ٝh.eVmU 栝c0 櫱4 2kx$uӥ#j /o*3VG"1q]G[MZ&WGXh7J׿ԭShhڐ" fuKF-ko_WI*s2ޮg*=ϟ{3YD{Ѳ4P"bj*,h%c8%{hr2q\ys2WIڵe\ڛ,)?yRZuJ4s7f5ZԵ/&VaAD·4f*XӱF=j1E4zRE4^du !{AKLKH)ޝ-8{Si‹N)í R>Z.ҊJP))--- ( E (PzEQERRhERE( BRwm4ގc1tRɰRf@e Ea1F(g*2̇EJAI= 44hi7%©cZ"@֡Z*H|A [pE1nuc]> W7f?cKm9vTzamnM65`aU)]Xڬ ZȠV$Gҩ9$)"Cg,FT:/P7N+][:%EuckM8& )Gխ_dkM$K+W#ũǥsP>᭯LylyCغ:^Buiڽw3sjcm$W,+YJYb C.) fijλz6*lVu9rsOy{FcfIdoEyK!l7Q} բg ZZJ7՟ ]`ӏ8ع/*8"< g.TM^+ӱU;`"r3,hr1E:*̚UFriokZRBm(j-~Ekq&Ssg*G4V rʵ[ꓕGo]=<4 ϖ(vxXobi.-![ ONk(gu/E,KYVHV'q$cA <kbayըʓNM Jm?BPh0.!IJ(wBޭ17GVL:e[y#70ƚez3/ct^[[!oBI8 'R.u) oC]UJ2:SS.$5czd&ԚLbУM$uug7fjЯ@s8i1Z; PKk4Su+'BWWPt[t>O&PtQ갼`H5% pSZZ! #>㚏0Qm*8U8VD:q5n1"UjYQzTgޤ=)sH> Z SZpcӰJ*[S8 qTEԂMj#qF)l[QDZZ97/Zab $Kqp)أqCر +Tj3櫕 1g-$ IQ!,NѶPӦM3b+SEƑI~)1sF)"ƁF)HĤI.0Ӆ4SyRJQL QH(iɧҚ:&- NvNvb J4--- KI@bGwP(E^,ŠSnӬ`RYӽFX"Q_Y}U a# 9<ES;4T-ΡO'ɽW}>Ak*-ʹTz棾O4yC1-ύ3C8fQIC?|Joo#R9-6x΅r'Nn,q4ZmnťtP!hG@ќ2(!)i3@f)撐 8AK4qhEg-FRSړ]7t iO4VISILh)1E! iJ_% SH)EBkX-4Z QG 0AŠ(hE RR!:J^8>`k#[pC R` Ȼ i٨ i3nh&°h`3FhaZ̹O.VQWEljW;OzRrьrhLsFké) 4riќ0AfI3Ҝ F)­AҔmIJ4J*H8Q֟KE4Sn Z`Fhw .iQ`pamKf})sG"n0QsFi48~iAsI,Qncx)b[~?sk2Lz~C]$@^AW+a3GUm]OS:dV,U;xTÏJ-b򻥱`;`qok@$֊z*A’sY׈L9}ĺM.<=IK Fݒ-YS p.xebU6`w(jw<|Ɲc4&h5 sZz}VY5YdMOMVj7ZķO6eOZ:fƊ|h}?o 4^lV~)ԊW0p} (kY}ܮjF^ғ9;jU([ÿJϨb?b1Z?I&ć˧+O@iv7]Uk)ъzvG-iGt `UW.փ[p-aֈ!fR*}'ګ{SLMC݌c֭nZjq\Z)i[H8BSUI.X:Dpg_i-".8|K?\VSU{ܙ)AֆtHɯB⤎>esS)SU-():( Z@)hiE r(hC@;9iTE:P@@(QދKo4}iҎbXRE;F9;j;,1(V sq%y{c˯\~ K8pG/סGD  H$cDW]CIK%CAq|/:p(jg/9Qs[&zǛ^wREd.$dV5uu$Z=aASڷm7X׷˗NR3cxJ1tM)+Bʎ=U+kß\: '7_A\QVvm+旹ǚ+v ١kk&hqT6kj Uqt2?2V,෶$ 0V3sB;@ޫ+9jcI7-RtŨ6Q&FM )np|ѺڵW1d&&sSt@y_d++Ӷ&Β9 zha\#k}ҹ[I$UlX܇S1ߦdW._t/G*5jyaW+Ki5ԙ55Gzrz55|'֧:-WA\u:\3 3GM~`lS̿4Jn難L+Q"ϗf,r5v qWx v )r*AVVbpְp]m͵T"fa 1ԣF+e{Wyݑ#wNwn%a嫉jܛfM[?e:4[~& X#\N޵,x? !=RAqT %4rwM=iZWQxq/MkiHXN6ӱ3{J\Ku`o\J^Z+<::ɩ=zUMGUv@:W/=70FE޵XNui\t5,*Vd&ǜ1XyWMt۞סQgU(8(v+Ca 1J4ޖ)8S8R pъp`RbR`))@B\P(KJ:)Q-%/ZR)GZ)J1Jz> RSL鲼v^;OVu fl';·qUUpCg*32wW}Ҕ&Sv_(<T-[R?&c7/b}qU :zq~Z+0+ZYùkGs0sd$}YdIx@FHո3]֢]15S=O\nEiƞkv`Lg 8]R`l;Y2w:pOszƞPzJ309ߨ޶2^/uЄy*eKnXwbzq_Q`"zBxY!M.C%8Wޤ|[~:߆Q32_Z)L:WeKfŢ+}p{W4`a_í* *H\]4C9 TM_vjOc|n%㠀~Ѥd=_`39c]VMJe@@@ekbYY1.n޷Pİ6"6iW4)lzV5- ;$&+^R"XڂҐMSQE00ӛ9޹]e "sڅssF&s^_s ֺY+M: (u]3 isiֺ'uFqE[dci} [Jsۇc]=^ڄr3ի] Hn &[s8?ϵeT>6Nբ,=q\Z$O8fمQR7)OJčw-t+.xb>6Tݒ9&i%i[@GjТ,QjO TҮ,p+S[4N(qqtK~Bjcⶼ;Ź5<6BVTɥr9j6KʐUh6XlUoh?UZ1 1R{ze%-zW ҙfIOqc x~ʔ"H$rwy3ڢgp6]O9#֜oX6Q+X}?d8OQKxH=OU<)J$znfzM>y/rڕ32mVHb!u'YRZ5߻3*= <7r ѯi+ 筮PMtVsU_R_kKRҔg /\I+WBu|pjηVUq *CJ1SSri$fImږB):(Rb8SN 1@ 8QP(ih)h-)ئ!)h(:-Eĥ )4SIހZӯ;(y&**ӍX8M]=P7 ZYfdG?1IªZ Y# AǨ85:{+{_^Jvd#;O A{=k9POsBWuyٱ o 9slw6yךD|Ƨ} \)|aIqu? ajdjޟhJֳngJ4JMhcNd&FF[=[MA#!})AȵzW6b)M=Q',L⬬ފ^LZ)QKE1CKҊi9N4 NV 8P(!E8 @)b( @)P)qQLB>SP(IJ(h Z)@ QE/J))hڐю(bP Ѫ[{7cZti$ 9&N5 =Qm;$c]Tms].4+.;%B5BKmT 1J8Ƌo:Tb=0[G(*;:Br7ָK2\\ \~*@Uq,s- Mam\}{\3ޜ,j'URV)8>U„ uǥuB#2Rz yms#&C)Ev:&sjLiT9RLiSS: 3T1w8ۭREJ(VvS)RSRbLQKE7qA.6S &))Szq@!RS8 )E`f( pE;(E8P)zRR )E%8P)EP-.1L@ KZ(RE (w^q"V准.KsR=Xt !5㎻jy،Aٻ-K93HF ǠQkJC+˲f5&lَ(ߧ k;V(Ӹژ y5ڒҔmh.`ceHI>CcVrgrώq}09fOuz%J0H̭hH3R Nmo&MԓkT0obyB9Ԛԭ[4q)-9~:+DE 8ʾz2h.D>JU R^([X@'ڻS9L,rXա߽Gok/"j~D!8lqW乘mR1lpyj$WAkSXXMxfN$ϱ+K4u'+o.Sh8T@we%QVM3M:pVtqhDXr3.: jլyw0OzxdPnOYscֶom5X }ь0Z\>wVeuߩҠqV桠K2X1+aҾ*"Xz8߰"⺖/Y=Ie|`x K{iF I<+PXď;=d@͓ޝTyF)C | ]Q| bSמrON 7 5.j`'ZfVIz+&ǹ¡w ƹsGL޿LMZו !~ŹU ܧ:4NJU~3֭>@Ftiׇ57s{OJisK(VCwtvv v1X,`܊id?cvy-G p}Z 8q^h~tHްe!3!ҒGh+䦹 (딕pI$ߧ[Z7`{Vʼn򌌂4A9NVZ(d!_c +i#0zY]\7*\Bct6q&`PMm'RH%ـBh~e[(@eQtjr{α7bREs<8Q(T'3{T]T#5K:P(PQ˙3q TQl>L%̑Eg"I;><~9c;ݕ\[sAJsKg܂qۥEҹ#98h_-=IjK4 aqVDvTԑunrj+<B0gg<^¨|zJ&~}$89>?Z|1q7Ρ c|KoOH AW|}W̹ý@:V=:2guzDlaScRO B` Tk{9#tSϧ,u>ƭs}Oe"5hc5JN5c89SN(9_Y7us˸bR ĤbTw4RbPE LqJ!n̤@&]q9( NKblm!)1UC)أVRm6SF) LzSȣnWΌv␊ӘTmS?BkXhl6^b1K\S  .!Ph4S'z.1 '%;Qq 4LQqLSy)OM(1q8p;1@xH=D"qHԧqN w1sOӞOZ)qڐ䚐qZ z8T=[Jۮ M4Lg4.;Ηiptzƙvr3Oxbd5.E"~[X `(=*v║wbjd"7Z[Hqj%q@\Fl/Jtڿ;$$C֫]dlP`U[ T8xձɨg?XLTp) Z W\ܤs~U[֗$[vP',ԣ7N]BeiUcg~N<ϭOs7٭^Vkk6D8*kwD}{_2jZvfma߻1&2ö:ۙ$d #"R3!X >A 1׃?iݕ5 F0xH:r?bk?jݱ7 ʺxnyt٬0@Fk7sҚǔxZ9Q%Rs c]Qm`^Ll/ltliY}?.*+;AlșVG_eB|&KJ)=ɸqNIJq1F)Qa!1I(r bBbRb;Z7bh,+HE:)Xc1ACT3bhz/A ǥ!HjOjm 2 1~)s[smQ|lm1G0 "u&)UĤ;a ERHE;q!'Jv(;1A !RRR v3@™9F;/Z. RҨ11OR`N#Us/(&)1T;PiTRҎ`ȥa(S pZxZrn`+)D6T8-|ACӷMrt^d'P w(a8֫tEXldD8`MICV#>ur;DL~%k|*+hv=*Rg!ЏP$=Z<DaK;SO$TnrG<*Wb:R $+I 3dî>V[0@rz#8\<zAWo;4c ٯ.R8.@qϮ1TJ/B;VgB&M?qrHzҡk"i4;& 5NaG cY_ۂ'v=-BD̢sNzQ^u6ϯy m#Jˏ\ǽvZX$$seF nr3^UXad^޵f+zM\UKd&Jw+S> *_[J2y)XC!vZ9m1ۚr'|l׶V;Emn:L19'۽t}>wDm+")H斻L=i)(–IJXjP *,IKE(Z(UQHEBKEJQIKEi)M cjT]m()pkEPӘ!b&)sKv(5!f(I1|rqi)h+1\Jm}RZ;s4\Rw bsNZLzpԽ.(.8 SpS.(8Qp pEJrъ1E *RiBE9|M_gM"30GNj?5s%zԫ} |޼|T]eh!ݭPkqe6GO#DVfe4=MUX30G{Z5*W8o]s.iXtSXRHi HcG5b:5ïUfw);ASwc23mwVmd>ኇ"ĘӍ/jd)@=0H A@N%n&X<7M`zScE2A'*á1Ԅb\ob):B4MCnd=7Pb9ZF˓ZYmqקxwXK50Ȫz}1^#-ߟ{KןKԌN$Q?;,;@ZH71ZyՕslҚ1^a))ԔEQKE+HbaF)i3E 6Z QKIN°( E)PJZC֔T60#)Ԕc1KK.1LsO&)DijB5jE'b^~TnF,uoE/R❊1VH)3B葳rp34R\,g2 6s:"Z(d(Gp3g4ԪWFFHJi[A^0"-V-lIH ;>W!9f# qֆ493,ޕ=ײ`yT>|(8z85I🉯t \,xUutl9CB#ŹY8#7nTvOZ]LDcڽ»2^d"ʣjit˵YC/qyʬ9\JmvoJڕZyunfjs.fi crpv~|U[#bU9@pwBN-It8hE*;Y|X~B+b)1:Ӱ:E(HbQKF)4! QN)jdf E-%!&)Ԕ*d)xV'owfD=pLU_,* HۻVbIf9穯p.x\by{/Ƿ0+ mCU0BA9w9RgN&ii>4. SG,bVdHLd֫Iq'Br+T r*eRPnz*٭IוHye$]L9d Sˎ"XZ)}Goʱ..Xq*+>OFyʴQ|#뛹]vg+eu-ȡ(JW-@ϥdfH~C@:~b/9Lu;4h1&Hf5:FY6q3{V{BFHLWIdfdG|J0.)omeHPr toҳW2l٤6|.3UtJ+B E+Vss" =[R2dk;O021$~j^c.gʟ³..5npqYwC "N{Z|- Y*p9#&C*JbH(x.#'/ #T3]w1Iw¦ˢUva3[ |}@}:W9Z2^DS؎OEoݮ$ujWOqg% @}+s$9˞vI ֎YH 9QG#MXI $S^}ErQ[+tm-;n#W/FU㳷?4c}O^*xy=ZΪ`Tg^{SU- G#~v'دa{jVBRbI]1F)M-QE%- 3ER%a %81EcRъW @0IN"((.)q@XojANRk6QKҊK@BRS((LZ6qM!IN%%%)3JQH)E1tPH)8RRJuQ@ J&*ŭ춆I[NJ*&ݒ!/_ifΐz?(Mz;5ϗks!V?-M5}sSA7 1x K]mXuy{* H#yU5Xx?SLoWsŝl8vEj +q%IiF6՞֬Smo'wpvYݶmOdŋ~5-Kk&I>k&M֥i .0V/JM jڸ+qOQRD^Hzx+"T淤9E3Ǯ V Gjq<\-ܒFB=j4o]KW Kf=Ze^j1xnF߇; 5d؏8\?zWiX!v[Vm:MxZmVts^&%cӓ'p*eP}&C"um8ҜJ;z'=?MX[p5M̘'yJ0ITՊ2!cZxʄ`>Rҕ)lgȬQZ]y=k.b1-d. L֤$R6P>2jdRqQÆHRˋ1w#>?@5. νrOx\a-*>ƹK#8[?+__;},ߌXck_Q~[3kCQv$7T*6e>k4q[^5(5 $ j #=1[3w `T@;Yw{WϫV^G#OY四M#W;?&VeLn?1h<%[ng (,ֵ;Xo*S.:/q8I1rwzfXM/)3:x9dA$#8T\x'jUWRZē~R"ICدJqj+VTgMƐەuƗeͷ; BԊsl˱GJj7u "-%#ԟH p  <}M|˻` )l;FOLTsz ۛ \.el}L.5o9&jrc8j&xx>{-y0کv=A ?Y a .?~XkpֵS̫rSmJq>li!KJ@CIZZmPQK(( NQKE%PQKE%QA`%-%(L,Ph!p4\4RCE))h4!4())M%%%:9AOߵQ?j?Ƽ Z_U_h=N$Q~D$_+CAT{?_L VNso짏J*vHw ~wV֘#ٝD/5W}W'm4mj9E.*i6)MC<5T ?gOǮ{MH]4N?h]Hg?ƼR)>O"9x%-YC&?Qi6=G_?LO}s!]b3U#}WOjֲk2I4~[ qKZ, goS}Oa???u^?GZ]vy'_>?uk4p?ƼW}/LO @#? 5ZƾJ>ה v(\=<ݾ9WY0rc؀ckzx^%ox y=Euʨk9b'Wφ_lixdt:_!h0 (=  [me̻'1 RtK4?ݺ3^J(S|ғKhg^$s"xÃƨކ?^CJ9ȣ_cƾ=e Snj<4y3ޏwUy n)7$o08~1|W2oc5i Ki?[3 &;X6ԐqU?5@f"~UYidSgJK?<*Y?R:dž50xq+%P5Kʠ?Y==\r?E%*ŃglMs/QEr77N=D¡NvV?Q}~H߁:Ɖu0`nU^v_ Yrԭelh7@y+ș)845( }r1! mezj7f1Y_,(TP{jXc/)ߑRAղ\WTthEI5k&>'zx^SNV[HV;, duڷq^)cXߢ=J~'mrҽŮ ToC^*)ikR/Iy aS6 .(\ъZ\Qp1KSEm.)1JE(qIy&("(\␊~)TR▦7NE-!q@.! %-\\ii1N%4\i)i ;JW|8}sGv1\ψ^—jAsuah(:XJ~vpJ}NTQ (b 3J:QE;ޛD_IͳyDlrwC (&wՎZmfAO;G'*jzմrZ1 #8=3E)?j@ܐ@(LE;9h!:gfҬ'kh޳; g5Es%)ReMZZ+ J( +x!4VNJi_?EeᗫͫpRQ^QE0*Xa*FD U(ED-@QS# 6+-F0Қ(V]BE h=(“PwQ@ 'һo:YxY&9QECv=7WI!(1F(@QL4b)bEQ@(((%QLaA QYQ@#J(0Qq.Iފ(4)(q IE\)QE
Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/2016-08-30T102821Z_1231925852_D1BETYKASBAA_RTRMADP_3_EU-APPLE-TAXAVOIDANCE-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

European Commissioner Margrethe Vestager gestures during a news conference on Ireland's tax dealings with Apple Inc at the European Commission in Brussels, Belgium August 30, 2016. REUTERS/Eric Vidal

By Foo Yun Chee

BRUSSELS, Aug 30 – EU antitrust regulators ordered Apple on Tuesday to pay up to 13 billion euros ($14.5 billion) in taxes plus interest to the Irish government after ruling that a special scheme to route profits through Ireland was illegal state aid.

The massive sum, 40 times bigger than the previous known demand by the European Commission to a company in such a case, could be reduced, the EU executive said in a statement, if other countries sought more tax themselves from the U.S. tech giant.

Apple, which with Ireland said it will appeal the decision, paid tax rates on European profits on sales of its iPhone and other devices and services of between just 0.005 percent in 2014 and 1 percent in 2003, the Commission said.

“Ireland granted illegal tax benefits to Apple, which enabled it to pay substantially less tax than other businesses over many years,” said Competition Commission Margrethe Vestager, whose crackdown on mainly U.S. multinationals has angered Washington which accuses Brussels of protectionism.

Online retailer Amazon.com Inc and hamburger group McDonald’s Corp face probes over taxes in Luxembourg, while coffee chain Starbucks Corp has been ordered to pay up to 30 million euros ($33 million) to the Dutch state.

A bill of 300 million euros this year for Swedish engineer Atlas Copco AB to pay Belgian tax is the current known record. Other companies ordered to pay back taxes in Belgium, many of them European, have not disclosed figures.

For Apple, whose earnings of $18 billion last year were the biggest ever reported by a corporation, finding several billion dollars should not be an insurmountable problem. The 13 billion euros represents about 6 percent of the firm’s cash pile.

As of June, Apple reported it had cash, cash equivalents and marketable securities of $231.5 billion, of which 92.8 percent, or $214.9 billion, were held in foreign subsidiaries. It paid $2.67 billion in taxes during its latest quarter at an effective tax rate of 25.5 percent, leaving it with net income of $7.8 billion according to company filings.

The European Commission in 2014 accused Ireland of dodging international tax rules by lettingApple shelter profits worth tens of billions of dollars from tax collectors in return for maintaining jobs. Apple and Ireland rejected the accusation.

“I disagree profoundly with the Commission,” Irish Finance Minister Michael Noonan said in a statement. “The decision leaves me with no choice but to seek cabinet approval to appeal.

“This is necessary to defend the integrity of our tax system; to provide tax certainty to business; and to challenge the encroachment of EU state aid rules into the sovereign member state competence of taxation.”

Ireland also said the disputed tax system used in the Apple case no longer applied and that the decision had no effect on Ireland’s 12.5 percent corporate tax rate or on any other company with operations in the country.

Apple said in a statement it was confident of winning an appeal.

“The European Commission has launched an effort to rewrite Apple‘s history in Europe, ignore Ireland’s tax laws and upend the international tax system in the process. The Commission’s case is not about how much Apple pays in taxes, it’s about which government collects the money. It will have a profound and harmful effect on investment and job creation in Europe.”

“REVERSE ENGINEERING”

When it opened the Apple investigation in 2014, the Commission told the Irish government that tax rulings it agreed in 1991 and 2007 with the company amounted to state aid and might have broken EU laws.

The Commission said the rulings were “reverse engineered” to ensure Apple had a minimal Irish bill and that minutes of meetings between Apple representatives and Irish tax officials showed the company’s tax treatment had been “motivated by employment considerations.”

Apple employs 5,500, or about a quarter of its Europe-based staff, in the Irish city of Cork, where it is the largest private sector employer. It has said it paid Ireland’s 12.5 percent rate on all the income that it generates in the country.

Ireland’s low corporate tax rate has been a cornerstone of economic policy for 20 years, drawing investors from multinational companies whose staff account for almost one in 10 workers in Ireland.

Some opposition Irish lawmakers have urged Dublin to collect whatever tax the Commission orders it to. But the main opposition party Fianna Fail, whose support the minority administration relies on to pass laws, said it would support an appeal based on reassurances it had been given by the government.

The U.S. Treasury Department published a white paper last week that said the EU executive’s tax investigations departed from international taxation norms and would have an outsized impact on U.S. companies. The Commission said it treated all companies equally.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment