Business Outlook: In Defense of (Some) Experts

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?isN?w\J&Dh>ZZ&L6~U5t]kcHZG@vCB~h1Viqkg](!9qYEi(%2MW9n>eN(q6m4<ԨWDZ83?P_ 1=wMp^$j(vRŒ9ێJ Pl|K}e!)N2xϨ ̥g9{j+ K&Ds8@мꑖ4+[tIoo7+=k쪿).Nq;նp_ƷO?{U۷9''5Kn/PqQcـ3޲VUiA.̊6/H2$vc}6$Rqg eFN ʟKZd_,gf$Q>f,$HtKpN?#SִiH3gf0)M%HRu!1ՅT1 PZRE1 #ՃPJ`-4&HMF)##5LECީNơqHZN9PI֘F5&iMRfթgڳޭK#Ҥf?tSeKܤT#6o⮞nƎ7RƨUGIW/?nrF!_W^S֙"D:RkdōkFgh?t).ڥ_6~-.Bƽk%E2xz֕AY+nM+oi[}実N(MqM(n8fPjU*pg5נj#5'V!5>gocZ#?oeEZ!(":SDՈ\fM4Cؤ Q9LaJ(Hȍ5!P)@/5TiT+Iԃbԃ4*OJhEESKҩ:֑fz`(o>!JVNjΜ ^D<{! -a]~(FHagQ9zDާN7Z$eGzٵgҹM6v~OmrUsJ,NG,P ĄmZ[1 ӷքDc#17s{\nES 9o®dWQBمr(0:+Q$ĽqڪP `w Le+'!N:337)`Rw+O D8zUkIUgӐkGG#c*0·GCnzuUHבцj^k2HJVE!;R$TQF8QGz)Q0oZ P) jJ¢zH5>jySsLc֡sޤjc @Bj >Xn]1)٦p 1>“+R>aZ# 6I/zt#M6롮cV[_j@qTj2U:Hh}q1\4kL.F-\'WC]`ݦ,v<ɦOzhzS1iǟEɺ4=@OucJڷio@XCua Uy2ye#HdFw7ݨF᠇Npjni?v]?@rZtH,pÊԵ DqR8M"sNA9 3/kPv蚟5^)zh}k>_ϭQZ"IKgJ}*ИMcFiCI'ޚNh+34RH(84 uNQ 9!qOZJU*%ZTkO`j)5ԆzUJ*RZVAn))i`S]խ(Bu~ B f8=^~8IVxcO;K(u4U Ÿ,e#znm%J9A(Gm{pj#a;Tj;Ym ` g"5}o+mS49ʎg⤲v"(L"[ҥU0gU5D*2֧ymVOʚG2,}8yx"FFnB&XPԑ.̮ڞKLBЎ+C+u9ybo\]lg$@g8<)?6X ֠W9$sZNnJjiVV^S 9qs#Aٵg3?Wji7{ 5)LFV) g!VG5`>n})Xeh^a- ,j1WԾF{P"=">j0gBm qNU(S"aZFڣ{ojI t=f>:sojd:UeJ,H *)U{ez5j &4q2V)#D~>3URVdQ(Ҵ@cc\ " rگct<66`f=+Wh6cғҴȤ"3~jzŎtLnF*ƭHz9R'J6)jc5>*zmHgOM]{>[F>k_o+V CGZ^*Dx48T@4wJB)w^2qO^4;R-8mE˜bE%EY;Ij*U@ejhU?L5&q]2 =NqUq^k?cm쭘E71FU |诟ESD4 GW?L_Yc ȬAisAe]pq뤋KM*k2+` YTSQY%NZ3mp>C`W7&DY>wly絼Q0>D NgR-gmjIuM MﭭD6$j?Uu_Zf']hl Խ]n6>{38v=GfB`~&mߕWßds)|^rxy?Дz9TQ 'r#D8-3 $2X!G|tm:Yv,'b @NkGh|@--jspq%-Rog<3Ny8Q`iWvY&F>һ=*)f'NvKE.$By@E̕Ό3Pe[~\3Ǐ_]/Bl3MUןS}ڴ13M)ejF@mO}cd|=A= 5i0 ?#w!~ğPE[L X#i~-8Tik$$Gr;TBw$b4V@ΰ`^BkWźglMd|;iqSupR>k>nEnwiu;bN>ke|xŒTIv Bڳ[n"5K GX1ë^%KGG)#YK{r$G`#v=š0r;n[̣@-D"$^Q<`>ODR0(5iw QRL \ L S izgMFCSր=*6AqqHXS@3``)E1Jڔ:P0sUZrtΆ-@kՆwWU~FMsS! c˚O'ڢ'ޢzҋ\O/Ols/xo֔_ZG=k @pǭ`NQ s֔]Z/=k ]Z_ZGhQt}iހ6I_rkQ{ *|t^yW::_ão$$uvH(?}pN2;ٴ {#ukTm+3X0CV}$2Gkn˩٤Wq ,{sCW>0۝T_|LhG_:v %+(޳/hīȭ)Iiw |]^yQlaڢćj,z :xHo1ߟZl[64^Bnyi "fxдIPo\ǧ[ڑ sɮwW>a#^&A<ʼnk7ijX;KqppK}˿*%|A$ ]zE1ϴ[fFS`zWQ%MN@%K꾣g4Gnz5m.`D*oRlaaFr=_xCP6ȧ>F[GqO^r$()Z8iA,RV٣uFM!>2PԡϭAޗw}֍֠Fi7r'ɓޛ抪dZmR/FVJ%[CӰGTo]2}I'N/ymSJo(~P?&W`'vⲵ 6υ&Z~`bsyf~O\nk@57-nƟQn*o;ޢBɘMT.+s=ipjS4\ԂCU#SS 9OV-n`ZO(QpƗ5Xf'4p0/,֤M=I zpi&}& z@ aSڜ4BU{`TVC@vj6& ]FŃ~)I\5TVCª& (O` N%sRjԉYqS((Vz *1j)*n +8栐U 6MJeؓo_o#-szIFv~HwaU~^e`Ƥ+E[{=7QPAwv [N֫W[(՝WJ2,;pEc. m?RtICDU?{^ ssZC(h]=WuWKiMo^Ivsy5bͷ׷g Y&;W*!4_:UkX^'''k(`? ڌn1>UԯewL~Tjְ$dz<~T^Pu>i~<  EJn ڕu% r~bmϝq6й 8Uq:p}hiAr )lp5T\-8\/0-VԫrtTT]-0. W{yFFZşu5{ךxu`|ܵUoS9lUQV}i;4֘ H %0($u cD)fr*=MaJ(n@ÊN* 9 9Z ,tnb[%5tNB}?f}Mu 48?޺jvV"mՍyFv^E*+dW\—]Ѣ36qꈠF%I;ĭp ԭn /=Ԡ8Ly:hlzegw^3SIo {"H嵿>q5DZk'sx֋~fmO\ 5M |5P=ʋ] ΥM7R\أt$dGdWZھseb~ D:qmKW!%:S^mSr Z'-&`ax5j@z4׺7䯣3GhnTԐ䃹 nxLf?j|Ça e3VֆNں{M=h7$R߲iE_D9ȼ5{T |~6epF@I5,*F@bNRv,tB!w k>3 |EhP[Yd)˓NդYĘj962z`A@+Gs &}0+"B6O 1{bȞy}ӮjҋQ}-jrZ;}^!#yJf\*u-Aȯn;'& q?O?d^PqV",pk)aХ&lz_zjvP|`][hS_sԠ஋Rziw&zv7߽4 3~\,t_kGڽ sk~\,oޏg`}~Wc4ݏZ7~n  z}ްM{M;p.E߽slG}XVޤgd^{zE=<5͐!BmI9&jL4BK4isLv>ޥ^Gۣ0=dk xy(tH?ց5م;aqyw$cf?~tX_ xW¼xw$:+גIM)9z—eGW+UW¼K /tZ_ x֗¼w_G۠cz5^; /iԫ/&NJ?@к~zPxZxW4hZ_ WTŗ?:#ΘjW_ g˞jro*2KxT!ƛKE08zQ@ MM&zdVWYNƉҸoM-bY2t" ![ڈV6О|[Y4ѸA^ws+HrO$ffu%ox^7΅>%YB;1G^AGFɖMz!ko_WVR07Zq08'P1_Zw/ heQDO\zWmXs>Fxb \h7 ;_=+'Qm$YX?Qj@i4VnfU;p?;T+Oe'61HCB'aDK;/aEy=Hy.˒q]PIކ2%F}a9 Uۇͫ,}+YibY' 0WڧÕ; M-=1uBAk6h`JuX\r t_ nUZ<^αzHw>6,410M#Ƿ6\2Bmc"Y ws7OxOI9c--摚k(s?|{R)IciY6y۰R}^B c/ǪZ\ȷ1sqøWٿ |SNb>ܞW֜b)ItU6q҄LTå~V!W'Kt0̘X+X=ʹT˚}gzc)wH AEIDoZP\Fs9-YAU++t:oJru<+ qQ[M6O_ ;T&+20bUS5QQ$GmѶvW7fFV)CSܕddPW+\\j4im C3RaqcM*)1EüicM&EüIZBm}i*}3+Xhcv!HMjSqJO,q?{gـ{֔bd[Ͽc@`U$oJr$G+ZYZzl5|o0!dT-Xjt4Ҿqnn.#АĎ=Z6m$PE|ֵۈ[*@+Y+|!E,vnӟB5WZ4`t p˷dd;Њ6 o,Z"I7e$ 8~>¾ Lt^>ٺS]īoo$">vK}RˑwVlo5[U[g2 A `ᮅ\ڶ𥟆6Fp??|چ|J[`~[+(ǹ,~UAoZ.E>Eut'<) P3F)i:ӛ i4 WM&i p2نOLv4Bv˶wqkSV1Mo|ư7b]Z[_m$u_z$b~Dd-c;sSc62[ɇD9Uk9]w@i('NՉbM4M%@!E:4 LQڊ:PH)h\5P5i b*.qY##5g:XΓO=Vm<pJ,$QVlWӄ~8ZpJvRJPZ+y~Y+M+@S U+ J#(ۊv=cBԊ` M)VqLeV OTBh TE? 4Qa)w~tG4f(Kޑis@RhN%Xs)3LZ}qL"w-&9(%ܱ*('yzrJxҺ]4ԅNfҸ95݅7s[PJ]{W43"pӳ)\gz6o$Ql8}* Dʘ9I?N?:M#V72>0W5?1M~Z Z4MbC 4rVqPԞ0NV*iᱽ:,7FLclȟUXN..;٤&h6hsILf4њ`:sF A+zTF*M!تRɃSLjքqkj s-RApG4Ӱw [*9?Y{kTpjP)BdAZ1Sm+@@!4xj@8C)iM"ي6R⍴BVVRM"#*)1Rcڔ zъx\0cB)ZP)PޜH(l`zRE(ԄP)˜3J<J)UVH ⣏LoQ#y?AYq1B%?,)s/V'idcFZyb}*؃4ԕev4 6قc"S'ÊD ##z9Q~5H͹865:aԄTNךVF£aozf9>uִBY.lmx'|>wAn,`>bTy{G#ᮖK_:ؓ,; oSU[YΜĴ_9oDJܵ ݭZIdJ$.1}M}]T\A+d;/hp1_*w35Lв#78R;Y(9D>5_d:X!5K[[K6Bo>L|8)f)@`)i!SHFf56=j+\*TV\gU LH:TniZCZC2;~C4dM^(hJ q6Ud`U+l HVΙked*̪3Ӎz m6ɒ2޸cS)5^`]IXtRvl) 458q !4R1*65IyInsGj`;4g74R iZz)+LOj< )S☬ CTcv:O\fP;V0mT\p*AzS4Їz(/CLC8 DvRHd%j'Vbzi4{RIr@((S% SAiX cj jZu-%  K:R+)q Vq "kyz-tjc.xT{ ?fPiZ9M-,d?0מj9,vN1M4ɩJ[*zT yZX]zа?(Jlzgڅ2 NU^} NRbH 0=tτ^!H..$\{GOm@SϚ?1]|^/:ajf4Ȍpܒ8z·D7tЛ\7x;n;wd׽~ʒ'|dO _]gCg9 {s,䶸J`yopsWx'N 8q4Eo6#Ҿ}| iv ᧾~#`W=.S>_)Lchj)yGT. A*%}֋,i0Ȫ/QSE ft 2*)~SS*!fՊ"ri++5!BmϺVxXWAs֬ Э <8t3}9B-]@ҮCF㊃Qԍ<`{Tw{brޡ1UjjÎ jL S\ !vE*SɦF 7Zä^J>XGonEmj>'M(ZVCrnNG֭`)e|W>2h PpjȰD@(4QpMZp\C җ'zSHnu5#7Rbi bRiJ)M'Ґ 1H=ݨMϭ9:1њhcQj(4޴4"zTKR Hi@40Iڐb(^g=Uҫ֧#d464`yT~OZ񢓢TZ)}[~ZiN47s))M!cNM!Fi *)TIR);j q=t8E9NjtEVL4DzUDԌ84N~ {OzQD ܟƼh- a]"`'#J06f=2/'r`aMn0T#Ue9MPM$:8Q@}Iq=ǃJT-n nE8b*6MPբ3e1ArYI8"JV(=(TtYFy@BU4ҢSRMSQPaiMԄIZJ94h84ifz e( F(i4i3@48t4AP5#qQ504iARjjU (4ތR) |bT[g1t.x#䑲j֟mn-˯˟QjPhRN=Fy~l=Y{?^Y JYN#BE5V#4֧r{R j؆w'Zӵl`{jZ/Rq@;lT.r5$NaݽfV5ô;}ִm i1UԙJǙVi$*h]t*JѥdmչՋoCmҬ[uqD^Z 8WJԜR if2>c G]uXî;M40V8Cu851nRt `nߚ2]$5X7;3\ц?-m'H?R=8$Vw$g}+>Ye ՜[!4| 27--ʽ+|wuJ"XHN1!rOh{HZQ]s+!?5k?RǺY?TĎtd=6QV!qqT'W gRIŠE>BuT )6+*SRMU?Y\ZCUGjԇΪ4n:ԖsZq fc6T$a9z+' tC"Dd0j*Ÿ߱Pvd{hSm+干#VU7~h5!ԉTXSY<Բg5]Sd2Vjr0k66SՄ<Нт\uL;R^+DB9: 51Vc 3OԖ1+Oպ7*98%%(%{'E7אvn QNiÓS Nj"RTj@VvT$뚵3dW`sȏ*ErZƻ@)Ҟh"cv 6sNSu1&O4R6( .)MjwZ18s@ J;SZ" ֦50Q@QJԪ8 )(Ɛ)ؠJPU1OJ>1#d2(-HǭHO^)a L] KJzSQIҩN*㚧pyf28 3Xuݫ?a]Q$S+bhϽA~6CU "r+E"F]F?.kO=NXR;&o eWy}+ߗ%.z{cH?{n<4+6Bf˃#9;wc,yl~{+>~>9mʽŻ23Ǩъ䑪"hj0)RbEH;STsO)0A4gC҄njɫrw 5MHkЅҳ~-m̲b߭E]hHjCPSR }ꟃK'ɁV>_+X%]wk鏂Q2'Hss8ֶ#mSA^ksw^\-Fpqӽ{U[veUw =з}_rs{ؓO2yW%1@;FO =y.n!iۧS 7vcGПʸy^;{hYge$vU˻k_jkU$[rǂIn3CZvaNϤlk+_]AnBj [yh_Ijrܚ YKH>T/^(C␌ `!S棘dL~Zg,1B :u$iC+85he %-:aWêFШuR8KU%Qr^5ZAhi#~"]{憔 `b 7sfῆ% jacu)~w&?[A&7FyVD/,1iPn=kEH̙˒õgY-QtݘNsU@P/Z GjV8E2CIȥj!榐g9ZɌcaS{,mZzSޖ8=j1 H.Оn*zxւ7EQINQKIPp4Իnk?`zG^^»O1yCg7oVrĭ.y!&VjXwf(B)V2ǚzF3WmR( |嫩ǧҧX+H=J)9S],֫^!ݱ׳fvf[Hs^3˓W>ah'ҝM4D桃TdqP桠$* Fcj)ݪ*n*i~ @wF  )cI<jаuPs^*@ xˌF׽|<HBv2dy;".<mьYJlD_>&tVW}=kGuk$N01B8<~ .r݇C23۾$Vӧ$Q\ cFAAr|/э;7}?}n涵h yNLl#h&$G*@zk{{xD漺~JυVq'ʲ n^2bFIlXj #JJns@JSS}*XNЋO )$*qG4Œ{fo : kF4incQ3WK6k%!HƥYHo9h $qlsQJ-s# 9`Au#&b]ϯ5"<$84_sj $3WZ2FW9$qYE r9)Y` nj' V@Sw٘+ѼZD ,S\\[usbr=*Һ cF+pG3ǥB+qڠt#Qݮұ/#۞+A1fGU7rq%05-P^,=X USթ\JNE/Zfh4>Z ,M6e}*b[g݇tnWihqRlgiԊ)Ȧ:ғ04֣f5 ⢓Gֵ+O\;DpyOCu!EE})OqD}m4`ugzd+|sZ*S-cm,҇3Qڵl`$>\GBbNqvcbd<?#߽i4g? uMkbXğ0^?Jqs,v+gT'$}G#"lҤ"#41܌'TMե]OA"+<1]dH5abf+YW\H&Sjhd+hdTқ \!]{0y5?6>yQ 4^v0?V7sΎxƪHy&H23d]U"5-kϺko!خ&G'JfqE׍D"[9̙85*yViicS063tFi#S;EHdi*qOSF"bz.*"ְTKq*JI\rz4hc1iP0Ip?dxYml+ 1Ttݼ 0m8|.v/ h@àCuxؒk4}&P[ȥpApA25Ftw.ْ@1jjUw998 p9Ybfy;P@= <ߋg{ڬ?Ϟg V{l|OzG {P8ug^tHqSב|H[ ߴGx?ʲMf*' LF$ڡYcӏP׫R53v3LeR7Zl#{VSFeCÃW-*pÊ04䖌 ABۨ9Js ]2|<\*I\M܊ɭ-Œz¤٤>W.gŒW22pX~ׂ_G.3L뮘jsNM[ ܚzBG9FL"5(px q\Omgu)i' 8FOn=.{yk_n>h`@,e+\:@Z61[?ۄ۲{>q] eH-$؀x5C>G, efh6RpswMwEC˗io]Rb<ɪkoRƍi$~6v=hf;N} id qBjޑ1L~Z̗!8#Z29{ dTci ISeȂAX=OunƼp׎odzFsPw~oiZ vJ?"Zo7^$\&#T:U[";cIޔ VD)jqjﲚ,*J*"X.VfrvXjV4XE2d֏à`K4ՃjAX98**JbyVgɤi i*ߑKQ`*P*ߑ@uTHT)ꂥT b3b'jֱ-2h[VƃkQw4LSCRbL4GlRRcp8G+ p_&9']k|a?rtaDކ4̄ JS4dSX@.=+[E*Ki Yt{3VXlW;.}0gp?Zn&kA3>4Vk`m3G%gybM2HJbG+M?Rvr~x' ~Њ|fv3mŸkB@+øIkXc5n@rӞ)d_\uuYJ@FWx,zrJMyֽ `ԽzՊG1}h2SisHiS3N:,Ҵ\,\کI\,]=*څiE1USp 1.aؒf5rp&Jjko?5ԔJpX(o2n=eEdxJ䐬gqLTUye6*9$5wxΓ˶ͤNY8\N8?CRϵ>8i MhMΜDhu?LU ]<[TZԬYRB~=|-.MXtiYGt=Mt|&Z>G41"=)jr5 35j؈߆Nr̲. !,y$Ɉi+jiDr S9>N jQP+Ո+U*O<; HmXG0x0¹x]1:*a 0aEj <-P95nw"9K"EHˊ@"*AQ"yZ=k׵M-,3(EJ~N1rO4)j7vv,M- IE8!^ߊȶ}) ivLVbjS5 xj71 Ji*0xis}1m}vtP//к5^]jOR̲uߡ>.Q]~KYn`jAS%$M#sZf8S܌߾6b^]dZ8LZK) B)eQK!f?WnB}7 x0"c#՝+RDb=Vufg\rђ3!ᇽy=5撊%sSWڄL`s4  ]XlvҼđ+]<4'q`N(I+b"n)}>jkcSbr9}+y߮gm}?u[co(#<5N q{#֮&\pj\'9uP/\:c w;TV{=jDR94i$#7P8_ҥAWN1c9r`Ҹ}mkWj[s2R3l I$l%z<=%;?1r^_Umc] zw+$:XQ#NiZn= OUP!QEzԋEQ@E(iŠ(hcP+UGZ(eqYQ@((J;QE!(( VQEHS"E ,F*uQEKEe"Jeyh41RLQE1J9(NS+f*kryh+&Z(NQ#\(!uPEQEQEVL^5>QM EP\`mE["~4QYMU'CfmoO%d{ ?Č(,LŚKhޭ9H ESflxPE&pn~Q^v1쎼:ݐCkoy[Yz5ƠR֊+̖;F-|-PeFG^?$ܐTݏSqMyڋ,IX)=8UksEÚnP@zQEk)3oeF!8ɭ4QSZIv,X)9ɒʼfoR94QW 6! Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2016-07-05T084933Z_2102042489_LR1EC750OIBWY_RTRMADP_3_BRITAIN-EU-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

TOO MUCH OF A GOOD THING: Former Cabinet Minister, Michael Gove, recently famously said that his nation had had “enough of experts” in the run up to the Brexit vote. /REUTERS

BY John D’Agostino 

It’s a bad time to know what you are talking about.

‘Experts’ are out of favor. Driven underground, pods of highly trained individuals are left to scavenge for anyone who will heed their clarion calls on Brexit, asset bubbles, vaccines, climate change, immigration, race relations—you know, the simple stuff. Doctoral candidates stand helpless as their Twitter followers plummet from low double digits to high single digits.

Things are so bad for experts that they leapfrogged neutrality and shifted directly from ‘respected’ to ‘whipping post.’ Politicians have amassed massive public support by pitting themselves against the expert consensus—tapping into populist frustration and resentment years in the making. Specifically, eight years in the making, since the economic elite largely missed the 2008 financial crisis (and some would argue, in fact caused it).

As such, this resentment is particularly acute in the world of finance, and more specifically, alternative investments, and there is a simple reason why. It is well deserved—in a sense.

First, a definition. Alternative investments (private equity funds, hedge funds, etc.) are simply investments that seek to produce returns uncorrelated to more traditional investments such as the stock market and the bond market. Private equity, or investing in private companies, and hedge (investing in public or listed securities) are just legal vehicles by which to do that. The strategies they employ can get quite complex—but the basic idea is not. You give them money, they invest it in a manner that hopefully does not track (and hopefully exceeds) something you could do yourself, and they give you back your profit (minus a fee). That’s it. They seek to generate a greater return than you can make, or a return that is more stable or otherwise unrelated to whatever you could practically invest in.

Producing a return that is greater than the market is particularly useful, as it’s starting to seem that long term returns generated for decades by global markets pre-2008 may not be the same going forward for several generations.

This hurts everyone; especially pension funds, which, like banks, don’t have all the money they technically owe to future pensioners. They rely on a return to generate the money they need to pay out to pension holders over time. Without alternative investments, it’s unlikely they will achieve this return.

So, if alternative investments help pension funds get the money they need to give pensioners a stable retirement, why are they maligned in the press on a daily basis?

For the same reason, economist arguments were counter-productive in the Brexit narrative and politicians’ immigration views have lost all credibility in the face of massive human suffering. Because, in aggregate, they deserve it. In aggregate, they have been wrong more often than they have been right. The key term, however, is “in aggregate.”

Expertise, or at least the pretense of, has never been easier to achieve. The optics of excellence—from a shiny website to infinitely scalable digital distribution of content and personal brands—are virtually free.

Whereas it used to be a unique honor afforded to the accomplished to speak on financial news shows, talking heads now fill the screen like the opening credits to the Brady Bunch.

For alternative asset managers, aggregation takes the form of various indices that cull proprietary databases of fund performance and present an average meant to represent the industry as Dow Jones Industrial Average represents the overall stock market. The problem is that stock market indices, in theory, represent a basket of stocks that the average retail investor would own in a broad based mutual fund. So the performance of the index should, directionally, match the performance of the investors’ holdings.

Indices of hedge and private equity funds serve no such purpose. They conflate skill levels to a point of meaninglessness. It’s as if you averaged out all the 100 yard dash times in the Olympics, collegiate and high school athletics and compared that result to expectations of excellence.

Expertise has become easy to fake, and inclusion into elite groups simple to achieve. The fetishizing of data leads to a belief that more data elements are always better than less. But when the goal is complex like forecasting (weather or stock prices) crowd-sourcing fails miserably and actually magnifies errors. The more difficult the task, the harder it is to be exceptional, and so it’s no surprise that the performance of the top alternative investment managers is significantly better than the mean return of the entire group.

We see the same mistake in grouping large numbers of scientists in order to shed false doubt on expert consensus—be it evolution or vaccine use.

The tyranny of the mean. Globally, retirements are in peril. Pension schemes around the world face obligations they cannot meet through passive investment. Without true, rare expertise, funding gaps will not close, and countries will be forced to decide whether pensioners lose out, money will be created to fill the gap (inflationary pressure) or taxes will be increased on the current generation to pay it forward.

There is no greater and nobler use of the torch and pitchfork than to unseat a false expert. But instead of pillorying the elite due to the obfuscation caused by the inclusion of the many, calmer heads need to prevail and assets allocated to the small universe of people and companies that have the scale and ability to manage it for the benefit of us all.

John D’Agostino works in finance but is absolutely not an expert so please put your pitchforks away. He was the subject of the NY Times bestselling book Rigged about the building of the first derivatives exchange in the Middle East—but that fact should not impress you.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment