The Pursuit of Justice

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?J)QI-% !IKE%)(EPIKI@Q@ E-% (4PIKE%Q@ E-Q@%-RQEQERPE-R :Upm/ʿsTNii!.NZ'u=iclTR>~/}8Aei*FT` ZRW:oY>ZV9+XVh(R׏[Rθ0(NM~(2?ԴKHn!9U؊NJ*Mh̛5yǏ]z-0ǶxT>ۣKÓ_ʺ0N*Ovv}vhÏU_髫hvde OfYz>d y GPyֻt*1\ThdpC) zeu$knG^JEV kNҹOZޭbd&DN7` ia*TD*o|W˹/%] H'2?xķnmQ;xSќ!SUK7O-R; F.>ohfHS*.[}kUH# |o|\KY*m]%G]JShݸ9\^SA]9=hOyQOXoj}6xh9Y` ={m$wZѓ˝AQ3|݇5חV*wc2Wh3λ$:l{X\g>MvRVw^g +7ƾgHdTc_'cXQGe0I߾AflɄ~uVvY1ǯԞ_ 4cjPҴ &/O܁jZ5'lWܧ-ugFj)IH^K9c~(ӵl]r;^MB\!Yb¡?*l:zWf*p2ejzdx+Mٵl.c ~ s2um,KnhevEl:<7 73PqU@2m3rCJƞy&o#\oOzN%8u? 'oxT=Ӝh>2\?5KGK̞piBzֽ׆&xgPYcIb&2ğ~գ@>yTmo(QXQEmD>Kӊz z /e_z5蝗 Ɓ#UD^TP;2ZE<5>lQW?[DRW_Vu”awP''-/hڒXy$.USߊƝ)|WeJ*h,M(j|Ft>_.\luf^*{KB}~ (8U4xh;Un''$^#p51,<.׹RSBSRGTdL>-Yyս HZ=Ycoyeڄ03p=&^ui.;W*O XjE79cA7f vR'+wnFnD*PԮ${iVX^g¶:`i%e9G+W kݑi=G9JJcWFb*=1޺0@!5:'sTtC3HM#J(-PIA)Pj6Z-f 4WH VE*kjN nG_FWZҼumzy]nJ&uE-%} Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@PQK@PER@QL@QEQE&)h%Q@Q@%PEPIE-0((((h(F#K15>յ-\ _GUkB݊%-8+wC𮭬mma?Oz΃m#JڮtT(@tZR_6uC td$kG;ʃmmab"z*.z؊uFn)0)Ը\['A3?3H63s4麓P[J*G\[m[SW:u%ttmӮY-%}9~ȏ Ԛ_܏I_:2)d1WZ~opK|O> lf' dFVՊn4̏2 [E]w֦ܬb9t|t?ZoxJ r=دps:É\5yk<9'iBqU'J[{BN>&bJ%G uZUPpQP=\%O{?p~4曨ae F29*hZ\栮-ăW=g&R[8AYp73W$5iv5Ka,okۻvf$ݎS4P [Zj" nt AES=qo;c؆տJ53hs>SMNj&[Dxj4-CŽOs_wL aڹ5 ^ũijW\V9b}Mz J%ha:լ٢/Vz^MwRI;WuF)kϭU՗3V5yU⦗-.\ ^A_Hj6yc4 d0QJtCQcJZ((((Z(((ZJZ(EPEPEQ@Q@Q@QEQE (PEPEPEPIEQE-%Q@PEPnůIpJ0AT`GQ}%܋"篛 7@93 GL+ {s+K>Υ5E; ;m!afNĻ^4s~/ ɹ3UJN7/2Gq#]<9{,fFbKZc*^$׭T$0EA{V?|].\ pǾ%' ox%lw!S ux^*rpS?+6׼D5m!V"%O5$c!X~[pv3-irڔhZ TA?HԮԺd# B+5W S9˒3=&!G}q IoaR@kxl 6yػ#޻NAO9Ț }5ԝ(M- yBm8''f0Mepr"G@4SԦ·vJ+"+!O2C8Ϲ[>hJ /t'4%AS(7cF+*Zaݙ -ݜm"ee@J %MUolUxv㌟j)^v4#Dƪ:0/z~ xm$ ]\u?Z<=:o% 2Mta]4sO'UQ)k?y kԕ,*t>%[k+qל=[Lm A]τG & TH=lEƒt㦎rjOrA[O:]宣$x(!ڧqYyk}<\NJ i/l`.A`\*uhٻYbQ%O%oFܧ#rI/Pt2{iQݘ s߀ʶY~3+_Fm[+XTת%OZ2׋4<#]Œ0*p'?cP͆_Τ|ۅwI@Sc'hk&=J7w$JDr1WM-!W&4Ri NbWĩAgьfհڌ1G4֎MRE6T8$c5WLaWYYjk=71)5(.WƬ†CKE@?EsZJ#r᫷zc/J@RBx_P(ā^*S1'IDˢhZ(1KEQEQEQEREQK@ E-QE-%-PE-bZ1@ E-QEJ(Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@R@ R-¢ }5/"M39oWfx^%kM~x_zE7BRyτW:֠btQʻklmtx!B7K39IV55{?n&lj#c+Ӡv'Vqά JW39eMѱ=IQy#l 1䝹?L[[4F$x.{7"ݐG\25^G2GOqOǭpUܑLW'+R9*9)?#ꬃEa$&ZiCVѺQ`2\x=A xޙy>GbC_QV|̛_3o3о#kڎ-e9fLe~ujz y0Y*zXdVn?`tH\a]8AҋJO j?7oʼg?^{3ibV.#]\ ;$?d|+,%3#ǯjO%N?e*FĥZ.2AӴi /|a`"LH x[|onCVG{9/еs.O$i,o7XW>ig>O}+iNJWvn[A *4UGaRQEc{PRPEPE2f) ֹ x}JxMW<֑)lrIٝUr5 )EiҺ^+ģ>XyF5"M7cHIcj~+1X[nF0M+\'nQ҇Jcb,ԩНF^DJj+SFk̺.`efp1\\4_j3Xs08 Vm,$_:уw]IrkCw:=Ơtbd9\ށXK&o6-iǜU x1i@8Wp 1Rߦ3U!niz2Y+-LT"ۧէFj9O:._F8Bro'MD&+^S9chEXUNM5C-&h LfiR*, *nԪחq.fHwcʴ?+3rJ*ds^[kƵ|2&CЎCݹwe:S= u =3m S{y#nzyV)2qr^:W%;U^}EktJ`_"\S\$:MƝqoi,à^{fȪ S3[ dTzs"i+:ZZ4nԬF}j+Jƈƅ6-ya}%b[M5Zbǵ_[UU+$HqHF2xWE{N'HC.V*:qD"?f9'.bȋjźծ&-*Br;i`jGIs}on>woZB"p;|X']tBz65^^ WfQxIs2ktwod U# ٤iJ[#{wU 9[s|?9T{ na5mXb Fs\5%&NIZ]YBS}qu&}ta1XeBYWֲ՗dlcئdy&sXwpaCkId$JJ=剧CTUgW(L<{Y'>HODX ;ylDZv%8^Zũ;ĺ*A0e*A1O'MYCI ըy)ЏFk?[v);8c~i w5N>V|{݇9&5 m gԎZ6S?~q ?>%YYOBςd7\n6^ƮVuF$?B]~OdiNlO!WhWq-Ŝаȑ WƱ Ӵc-M3׬GΥe(7q:(4Վ#s}Fy{+G Df6ni5s=Ŭ[fw'$JLO]Xu"KfL9cwhbHlH=bN)Z6h[`hPKUo-2JF;d;i4K |F2kHӔHNI~1Ӵh5"jXT8 =eOO"A9*G]p?#|:GU[Kq pk?&%֭&F,q\jP\H>8|G mp\S=Et{?c^ Fj\jEOڀ.p>uULĎ޴؍7UFxV߉O(a5|ѧUWqĚl&Zm k ]}{Ȑp+<i$eyt1\O 3ө3𗄟GTaJԠf2kiU45TU\ԁ3MȊ?k"{AGJ)QU )(*Rլ<9%vHCJb V.I'5QL:;I0Zμy$&ZDU څz%%*6dz#hxĒX¾;ȻR7p=k?RmFT$Gt6{E2ZBjn]Fp*pWRh5-X-X5,l7Cú W\ix_1hik}p55 \3ԕ}#N*6֖_D\U{IE!/ZJ{|$kE"55澷UXp ƼηtIuQMtPN#9P='Y׬4l#*Jt5Ybw11B+Hn..G2)VጜWHR0k|- '2 R鮚Z3Rd7z^ZxY(#l+oWi?OeĥA֯5MF+y,};pں -OE8N{ڮ" rivDiRt7T$aollcz'm5wDa5a QGeJٽ!cI-ʶvq"][[H23"(5ۓkTbr޹=WVVَ6~MCzCIx5jՊ=Qt5O*95'!OFn\ ,ē]*9}8k-Xs7{HZGbxɧri½HEY%:Ww ]bϫˣu*ͽ%(ܳ x>}+*ϩ`U5mmddwr|z S *;f^}봇vJZ饇Etsԯ;$cR l:󷱯=xdu!QV|FC47m[xQ]ZJZ* ( (je7jeWIxE95˦$vZL3ZA5k k'Al!p073SVNOZcVIcU|P3у O r:[5JEt$2*՘$3{гbDcpQkM4Ȥhzқ%3%%OAMwa1mW~=ޔd@d>zSsZ%Y#T.imA( <9[u Rm ,4Gi^s]edjOR;W@NoZ-zq\iJ95g4b^D)f)٬^j(xSлc5KZD}F% ckqZӔInIjhnnj%?x~{1N#*çK֝4evCٌh:=#0j6vN_M8b,zdJ魴n!ݴ1#KUsRdD 3ꧯ({F+;;_os&Ttʙ^<aI8藚Lh1Ri]6ypGY6igjqr^-蚻Q5Mimm^Y^[xy, "rTg'_ :LvJ%e${VE32"c@\Ƅzi_A= OyO9رb2rkRtʦf&0 pRz pEPՖyX嚻c{7dA5L4نR63%Kn3 oOVc Htk#?K+]ցyX}ЧvtGVlCZs\pl摤#v=*Q;WB̪RFh!Wqr"#5S ZHObQ0I`RXH3ܣUN SEYҚegnrKEzVb{ ֈ˕*q9MJArJ9V^yh%Ck̈+K-R#ӏqXpP֕V?)` Sي |ߗ=2@DžM{>`Fw:m z*t"э{Sui{Zh(*B1A+g5VTqyT`say͛%VqV5_i8y ?`Kc;,w1Xէh3X2O[ӡgz׃&l;Hc5:ֽj\'ZtݖTmBYL.p۟WOV'H,5go{r"}qB\\Z?ݶR*5K"hU1S᡹wcm^i`3!5I7zԼ&"zZюtXg5ҾsǞYn"*FTݤJ3Wx"(qzz ;#ۂ[8*;׵wM,?fs'_ʽ,...tpWõ+8s7|Ocpk_WVXu@L-fF86xx(;9's^ ]mdzpkGJRcQErQ@ E-%0 (&W[}>C8^y?oأb?)^crFzA9W_4`fqR1DCuCslR*Q!"Qn-W֯Rs]Tݢp)r4mJ`9!ּ[Ξ>JrGb=F?Di܉˕I4aKhko-ܰ )bjMOhc].J|5zf ` נi@HʽEMj\UʺU y"XR,`r8իj,hMXQ)c:G9xNfxGG4[q\1:S5?-hyuo,.2sFִ =^8º1DI4Bz\f\NiV^W =[#}5UMrR+YJ*Ȍ <HI见=D:i7 vje(_j)`)CYjF m/h=+X0v1Zڢ{/j()X4P\槴*kסnt1e\g_E's]OBIU?QӞ8Ac i+2dbZF|z8T֝ mqZh;I3Jצ^)"QPA˅~b>+lW-˶:ʹnMj8 »Qc*ݕnjjI&9ɨ feB!aa@ELHsI3juOe x?[I7(WLx#5e"̀WcQWUAxzd*=%K /a[Sr3-l76F2HwNbz5(qkc}=qf6]j^=Eww0NwU TA^)WU.2l*VV6~mB( ,q@$Cɯ;+72yjj~ՅmGX;IKEnr EP [=p*t~~3S9rŲ&zn5KuSrls5nRhե2L^lUstBƜL81,@Q1G(\d4P I~SR'}MXY2:ScV=j8Hg$7ZjM$( sv)%:+j97dSD2KOjQ39椸]֑J_R\Hw:RAHo[ߩ4ve4׭ivzƿʼGzo4+Uŏ^f6e.k4%SITF.##g"`(˷*=zKCȲs8Z;sȤ暀uuzcc<5jV;_Y9P>L@Wሖ2++yˇݓK+䚁ێ$sr&<҃05&QAMIր6">|?hAD Q=آ2*K4Trȧ̋9EDN3wle\ѿCȺo7yҙN}Ժmٍ&NzWϩօ*RHYeV ƺ(gtBwXgy WC@Z{6Vb"Z"jAWQCS$'ҋ\6 ;SC^~!#gN= V}k]ѫUMhqbp)۴ajlY@{kpM"A:Or3+ܓ[I1OJǻj_m*OG&S+ӌW][2gPY YtiHm'/9D<j# gڱT J$֬\c_j7w2q!zRZɃRjl5N&wI8E䲞)r ~8lK{ڲ݃DVtϮ\G֪Q3*:fmŚ&Ÿl}j{rq,GֵFKݝW/Pbl=ʚդ%j۴shHiS4I#zJ\Q94Rb E-% urq b]7EAW;Jrӹg4.P $R;Kd&S)wn IOkivlVYDeڼ0cTbZ$ [>5H֧lb$j\Ren i.)rTUfr{I!#8S 1]BmS9ɪ3?,hOPkCfUlULI"؂侐Ǵث+,Oݓ?"bzJ?nc`Ֆ-sRb;rhyM{׊jI&^k>]JaòsW+Mc=ɪd=*5j I$膷Ⲃ63ybvfv2ӹ¬H8\zN)e<=:{#7&Șb:EIJ D[@74٦@fv$jWzawLwd-WysPI-Bd"v2㡨J&\BITV8e8Gދh:UEC9ФՋŽ}yI;Zz+ EYzҺݚnuUZFQU"LBnHSdъ&kKrVv5qzAPt5Eq~ֳ݁%3A#<Тk,o=ޅk&ٲpM-ꝧ*+hO65ց*oz8˃֪Z2t5PSGsagVir$Rs^1 μҌn=z=Kɫ Ga c*V SDo&H%0V$BqZPJ[icKjn5gwv%-e ixn#]~E)#бZ$@(84,Ѥ}iN2{9n|;m9EH9,CO;i&|T,3HOy j9T\vh'Ng=;qwW(FZ~ BjOm& eִ-5"ѥQtVdT3y5bUws+BJa.p9CSrl9@X*OCSz2If&sP{P]õg@q=tG9&jOB=O4ƙn3,n3dMLA%fh7?d}zdI]\ə$c=? l/S4i(epȴ9`9M J~M:71n% F`(e<ԞkҼg{kHlUOɶ5qn+i|1ʻZ ?ȬhW)nTsj%bT|sMQ,diWӤ7()eּ"JPw7ԕaq֞[@S3@XVRT*[*+ҚV"ZH8w`T{y`qHR)U= CktUH ZYAo,\aѩ2ym Uf+;UEҪq%Tq:=ZVh 2>';, Z# Ћ[~aˮ[EqI5M;5rS*}SsOXbjQj*hv"0cZ V*[LSDv;OQV;Oj\H@VKqRViUXW+`+}z4MnBa_^85^ i7fH]|ZKf8d˂'JΠz kBCWG_xZQPm=^NudzxkBF>HfY^ B[1};1A?(|Wn.|=}P$ھm-zb){ǣ#nq*A](Ib)$݇/0sSRP4.z _['$}+Ю-XSh p3ҵsm"oY EK-$bå.J1* WAy2'1XcT6UgT^EW;{~ڲuFr@t5T{kj}*e`tl{K$P0g!⯔G+ңxVF*tњ"`{Y,sRJ! 8}cԱ5~e\ŻPAq$Obq<+TDnzӥ_=R.(2ˑT@>*M"n)Qs֐rkB&zGU 00+ ;W 8uf 3_PY0kt+Њp{-:=QZڸ+Z.mfjq>~ɒ iXxR*NYG@pGè5i4`:Еqv\σ`XsꮝC&LOQ@Ԋi6 2j(}(MhJbP^ZQMD"JڦivӰvҁDsU҃Z!\7L{Xڍpi6CDz<7y~d'evsYێk ;h˞Mjiy*E؉&INoV?vZ[NZ62rUX/$L+I\.G.éG$nkN#ޠIXg{=J'5aE-̪j Z-OՙWYs\λҽ5(yWt5mL IAWlg5p0hB+<"}μ)JiaVWR6RXZqQס\/gNʜVZ.,@qT4|Xq]LֵgȬJ3$Q\"* Sd՝XϿ`3w;BM٬5Q24ԌhQZX\Ác"n)A-0ɤi^j+jǓW b`$!v%2]QMѵk VFyrD單JJ\,ueR-+R8Fh-[mU,cfݠHBg%C_I#Z]:c| qڭi:Ɨ}ݜќ {9kj|s+̼  j5T[0Ϩ>6d:^Q繥6YFX\$ X1i8kuUsW*^Wz؞wrzYiyJ?Eyu]skri0=0yc h4VR t&ÚWmo|9HN']wsJxLTi@l1JеPHF֍+9D5Rӟ 4ȭ<>Jpz EeIcVބt ʫ{"7ZS],@v%#Qy 70 jA~d@}k~uq^GȢPWhQsq wW ʀ{WjBKhuF}ϩ4] o5іPk.~,rGּ2\hNUI`ڸ N]剩fyⳮtpj 5_Znι&."W 朮sXu8fS}+h9o[*ţ1,'Kym[b[8AjRbc;>+]v+W˅o%G\sa^-{ە f[ZD(u|']]w_&'chp95%gmɨWrht҅ٹS-;S,XW%Γ;Ԣլ@"aEcA^]d^d[)`'t"g [ E\t|Eh@+;ͣ P;@͓RhgT6 i5 \brin_bD+)=ih9ѦXvɬvSR-=cETc`L9"׃VpZʖ'CU%j $tOt:H3\^;@\~ے_cdv2GkrK (5Aq8,? Υa^MF.o!VlֺpJr0`*bvKs!MJ[k0uʷb+2Z21C!>~*գҬS!j%VrJjG~e85=AYzRJ,XKI6t}\jJ)'-F 6RnThy q*%blE^+7^ʎLX\7L Uh“MyzvGpvbzћYwz ^ufL]Z =xdv<5-Ӱja{ysሬI&"g̊d5;7{[(i.}+ h,TTQ7rk/jMjpcpk ຶYCZa6׿1\;[ߛcBƺcBTu$ ^?ŴM*a+1{UԒ]m͢<"VCZfwfyasV퓒߰ i4\d^ӦXRDDbɪ [3Q=*2e}kK|rElzS#,e8U)Ӧ;8VH&Ak6Xp :Oz$D켓\ψ4]w|#F5QWFF QpA5fț Xϭ& w?J h:bY&+JB~U )T5:-jyZ+- 1V4QzΥ G~j: nHKHkx]t'='t!{]^Hwtdp7m:w SQiM?z Սk#Mj݊娵: ~*PT#5GLYvԳ4ˉ7T[SKd^:Vt9tbXUKF8;he x۷By$B{TxVMfA,=iZB{U&PRqhlį5+U{z泖"-W/0FP+T3-ӁZ;&ʃH߳A[s+5\ `MntEE+ج- ۓ*zא^KA-77V# n?%mQׅƕ{$*lWx\_M)r9'5#hU]O\I5TK(/Jҫg-֦շ2GJqV3jV*Zs@gDxZz콱YN:J~GZ5Se+S5cRб92jx#yCS2c5k*-S|ǭj+-cLNpUObSugNi8nu =z/&˚w3䜒{Զ`ւY^7'vLbڭAO58UXA"lֽ i:8USmc&Z8"sڢЉ:fH [t>ny"ZVcZ45kQJFqI]d=q,PGEr"DUJO|[z+50( eY5ylQF0+ԄTCq4 6HED"L0rjϕJ#[: t]Z 44]V/jwASK@Xb2dSCWL*Иbxp 11$SP4V5x5+2޻ k,C#iNԽxJ+h͙q۴K` ={SVfMmVfkU*Tnt)tS jv񕹗r85iPE!\"'RsMI#\91Zַ뿭s6O>3P]ܝ2S 2O&E'sQny+_6lrW(6Vs|;׉I:qҦE%p ֫* xլW4УVJFe.FzgQQf"/Ikg'|VYZ:09=E+;uZÁh7QRqU-633)̉=8"p+J3ɀ VsEe ANV{J̒>qBjEܦYW55v TdL2[;:jkf 1术N+j!|ⷛw͚죵cxFH)RYX/ *vݧN8CO)=VyZjXT\|lVVR׎yT{SŠ7SYr"Jȼxjڣ)&Mk`@2)/Pg &Jmk P Z΂Jo}EV1sY]QE$ ߱W E2z`FhCF@b\QX[֢?QW$[dSd_ (!DŽ&AHe.2k+SJy5jtsE͌PР*AEab\(YV`q֊)9*~QM ж^rQS3H5QX3Q(PvqxXEi)FJ:xLއfd0q(HDi>ef+E4tvGO/]18H#y(\j% yŠ+h=*-&yUZkzkzʌcZ(֡<# FY6U{3۬^,3B^rYe EcM qSdEClLԊQI$x#q}HV%34FV!!YQZD^o䢊Σ.^>HTn"*`ͦ`p(ҁk'J($oҀ]V[(dEW 8dfU/V=QE;qMj3zsJ(j'c(EŠ*$rfZ(?
Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/BDS-1-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

A pro-Palestinian supporter holds a protest leaflet which reads, "Israel criminal - No to France's Complicity - Boycott Israel" as he takes part in a demonstration in Paris. REUTERS/Christian Hartmann

Will boycotting Israel change it from within?

BY BEN WHITE

Israel’s ongoing military occupation of the West Bank and enforced siege on Gaza Strip, with its illegal policies from land colonization and settlements to blockade and collective punishment, has led to mounting frustration with the country’s conduct in political circles internationally. At the level of civil society in particular, this anger has found expression in a growing boycott.

The Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) campaign has been taken up globally and attracts new sympathizers every day. A key sticking point, however, between the movement’s supporters, and those among its opponents who acknowledge Israel’s human rights abuses, concerns BDS’ impact. According to critics, isolation strengthens the Israeli right and alienates an embattled Israeli left.

In that context, the main questions that arise are: Is BDS making a difference? How much possibility is there for ‘change from within?’ And, is BDS hindering, or aiding that change in Israel?

In recent years, the Israeli government’s stance on Palestinian statehood has ranged between unconvincing ambivalence and explicit opposition. Within the current ruling coalition, there is no meaningful opposition to that position.

More disturbingly still, there is no political force for peace waiting in the wings for the collapse of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition, which rules with a tiny majority.

Israel’s official opposition uniting the Labor party headed by Isaac Herzog and Hatnuah headed by Tzipi Livni, officially known as the Zionist Camp, says it supports a diplomatic process that leads to the creation of a Palestinian state.

In its manifesto, however, the Zionist Camp insists that in a “final status agreement” Israel would retain “settlement blocs in Judea and Samaria [the West Bank]” and Jerusalem would be Israel’s “eternal capital.”

The latter point alone is a deal-breaker, with the Palestinians demanding that the current Israeli-occupied East Jerusalem be the capital of an independent state. In addition, Palestinian refugees would not return “within Israel.”

During the most recent election campaign, Herzog specified that under the Zionist Camp’s leadership, Israel would hold on to the Gush Etzion, Ma’aleh Adumim, and Ariel settlement blocs, thus cutting big chunks out of the West Bank, in addition to maintaining a presence in the Jordan Valley.

Just in the last few weeks, Herzog—who is seen abroad as the ‘moderate’ leader of a centrist Labor party—has praised the outlawing of the Islamic Movement northern branch (using British Mandate-era Emergency Regulations) as “a first step in protecting Israeli democracy.” He further declared European Union guidelines for labeling settlement goods as a “prize for terrorism” and called for a total closure of the West Bank.

Israel’s so-called centrists only look ‘moderate’ in comparison to the likes of Jewish Home’s Naftali Bennett or Likud’s Tzipi Hotovely, representatives of the hard-right within the cabinet. The Kulanu Party, for example, headed by former Likud politician Moshe Kahlon, pledged in its election campaign to “keep a united Jerusalem as the capital of Israel along with the main blocks of settlement [in the West Bank], and not allow the return of Palestinian refugees to Israel.”

For the likes of Herzog, who has stated that with “regard to security,” he is “more extreme than Netanyahu,” a peace deal is not about recognizing the Palestinian people’s rights but protecting Israel’s ‘Jewish majority.’ As member of the Knesset, Ayman Odeh put it, “With a left like this, who needs a right?”

Palestinian MKs, meanwhile, are marginalized and harassed, regardless of the Joint Arab List’s decent showing in the last election (when they secured almost 11 percent of the popular vote). Since 1948, no Arab party has ever been part of a ruling coalition in Israel and there has only ever been two non-Jewish ministers (from more than 600 to date).

But what about Israel’s judiciary? If there is one institution viewed internationally as a reliable defender of human rights and curb on political excesses, it is the Israeli legal system and in particular, the Supreme Court.

The reputation of the Court is even used for propaganda purposes: the Ministry of Foreign Affairs boasts that the Court “upholds the rule of law and strengthens human rights,” while Israel advocacy groups speak proudly of the role of Israeli courts “in countering incidents of unfair discrimination when they do arise.”

Yet this year alone, the Court has rejected a petition against the Anti-Boycott Law; defended the expropriation of Palestinian land; given the green light for punitive home demolitions; approved the deportation of a Palestinian family from Jerusalem; accepted government plans to demolish Palestinian villages in the Negev and West Bank; and dismissed a petition to restore planning rights to Palestinian communities in 60 percent (‘Area C’) of the West Bank.

In other words, the enlightened Supreme Court—yes, that includes an “Arab judge,” the only one from 66 justices in the Court’s history— routinely rubber-stamps grave violations of international law, including collective punishment, forced evictions, and systematic discrimination.

Then there is the Israeli military, which lauds its own ability to conduct credible, internal investigations. The evidence, however, suggests otherwise.

On Aug. 1, 2014, during ‘Operation Protective Edge,’ Israel launched a devastating assault on Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. A densely populated civilian area was pounded by airstrikes and shelling; according to Amnesty International, at least 135 Palestinian civilians were killed. To date, no one has been held accountable.

In their Rafah report, Amnesty concluded, “No official body capable of conducting such [independent and impartial] investigations currently exists in Israel.” The global NGO highlighted the existence of a “pervasive climate of impunity” in the Israeli military “that has existed for decades.”

Israeli human rights groups B’Tselem, explaining its refusal to cooperate with the “existing whitewashing mechanism” last September, pointed to the track record of an Israeli “military law enforcement system” the NGO described as “a complete failure.”

After ‘Operation Cast Lead’ (2008/2009), the Israeli military examined 400 incidents of suspected breaches of the law, producing 52 investigation and three indictments. The harshest sentence was given to a soldier “who stole a credit card.”
‘Operation Pillar of Defense’ in 2012, meanwhile, has not produced a single criminal investigation.

Last but not least, what about Israel’s civil society?

There is, unfortunately, no Israeli mass movement in solidarity with the Palestinians struggle. Citizens who challenge the regime are targeted by Israeli security.

Even those Israelis lauded abroad as ‘dissidents’ express views that elsewhere would put them firmly on the right. Musician Idan Raichel, for example, praised internationally for embodying “diversity and coexistence,” believes the role of artists “is to be recruited into Israeli hasbara” and defended a former army interrogator accused of torture.

Author Etgar Keret, presented as a prominent liberal leftwing Israeli, will not even boycott settlements.

“Israel’s existence or destruction was never a life-and-death question” for its Arab neighbors, Amos Oz, acclaimed Israeli author and ‘peacenik’, once said. “Maybe it has been for the Palestinians—but fortunately for us, they are too small to overcome us.”

The mainstream Israeli ‘left,’ whether in the Knesset or cultural halls of Tel Aviv, sees the Palestinians as a ‘problem’ to be managed; not colonized humans deserving of equality. Yossi Beilin, architect of the Oslo Accords, made an instructive confession in 2012. “My interest is not necessarily the Palestinian State,” he said. “I want a Jewish majority in [Israel] forever.”
To oppose BDS on the basis that it prejudices the possibility of ‘change from within’ is already a weak argument. It ignores the case for accountability for war crimes, the importance of Western companies and institutions ending their complicity in human rights abuses and the fact that a huge swathe of Palestinian groups are calling for BDS.

But the appeal to an Israeli ‘left,’ or ‘moderates,’ who will be damaged by a boycott is simply not based on the evidence. The politicians, judiciary and generals ensure impunity, and protect a status quo where there is, literally, one rule for Jewish Israelis, and another for Palestinians (be they citizens or under military rule). It is a status quo supported by the vast majority of Jewish Israelis.

Those hoping to obstruct the BDS campaign with concerns it will only strengthen the Israeli right should be asked when exactly Israel will be held to account: when there’s another massacre in Gaza? When the colonization of the West Bank expands that bit further?

As seen with the recent EU labeling furore, external pressure can, in the short-term, reinforce a right-wing, siege mentality. But that is why a step like labeling settlement goods is inadequate; it angers Israelis without actually exacting a cost for continued occupation and colonization.

It is only through international accountability, the kind of substantive, material pressure—through boycotts, arms embargoes and ultimately, state-level sanctions—that makes the status quo unsustainable, that there will be an incentive for change. Palestinians, in Gaza and the West Bank, the Galilee and Negev, in Jordan and Lebanon, cannot afford to wait.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Website Comments

  1. George Roussopoulos
    Reply

    Thank you Ben for what is a very objective and comprehensive outline of the situation. It is clear Israel’s solution is maintaining the Palestinians in increasingly restricted concentration camps which will resemble Gaza. The opposition to this policy from principled Jewish people is unfortunately totally impotent in the face of the army indoctrination through military service and of the US support guaranteed by its wealthy local lobby. Just as in South Africa, effective boycotts with cultural and financial impacts and sanctions too are necessary to change this balance and force Israel to recognize the human rights of Palestinians within what now has to be a unitary state. It will take a long time, but there is no alternative.

Post a comment