Trump Adds New Twist to Immigration Proposals, but Legal Doubts Persist

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?WiPiW8-*Ӆ͔mP )–@QO4 KE6 Mx@PTS()␚`4()@PB BFi*qABӍ1 *((=iqҁ )vp7JB#JxҚ:ԃ0cJJa)QM(Tb@ fE4i9( 1E( \R ޗ4uh V((4Mhq#SEbSZ*LqQ @Ģ!å6% kS ab->ځ֕Q4 SҎԴbzҁ!i 5\恏Q@QKIڀM4HzPiqIޝ@ĢAC@"iؠ֊Z(&)f)9Rc7ZCHԴ5!jӨө((u5"/z֡h4 ڛޜiZP) 8SM(NZp#Zz(nґHũ(1ր@MQN@0iHNMj 9R( q@#4iå cOځ )) k m=>8R(P!P-(Thy}jh4-ޓ5V= ^yU BןG3ުEt[?5W4P_>4j}SPй _8zU,њBRERɥi݊eQ@(((((((((((((( (JZ( (PE-% (PE (@C)QERQERZC@0R(aIKA!(Q@RP1hJ)i(QEBZJZ((%-%-%-%-%-%Š Q@QH(QE((((((((((4(bRR 4QE JZJ)h’ )i)RwE((C((@ŠZ;;i)M%b(P@Q@ A4 JhQE-4(E ))hK@HJ(AQ@Q@ (4 ZJZb(RE!%-!LJ((((((( JZ()h ( J)EQE ZAEAP 4PhQE!h1 Hih6(4 Ev@@ EP1 4 SI@EbQKIH'z(&-1/j*DiDԅ$ (Oa K=7 f@ ) )( CKA& K@ (AEP(Q@ 4!4KH)hZ(!ES$(((()i)h()i)E%- (Q@Q@ J(IKE`)i)iv! QK@E6QF(E-ъJJ)qF( A, RKih.(CiiqF( 4 i)أa(v )qF aNI NhU.puZukaxbyy8屁^^Ck7w"ADsVsnRgxGW !+19ּ׻^ eY :vOS4GlN#)9⽪&@3\]&8"iH©R˞zX pÃ[BW2wG4wHgj~χB&}2H0[G5!,֌͸:ߡ)v㚾`L*3_ pSmG{.I#:Q@ $-8?Zik_Z\QQN&( E.(0Z\QH,6.(1XmE,%!bRRҁJE;!RP\QQKLPbYS譊1VU(Q`*Ůأh)D`,ÙqFڷ ҴB0E0([XB0Eb!ESmF ,ÙPq!SE66b(dQFڽ<,裶i'!b:36JbtP}(}*g=bZ, ivJ9C#;> iyC=)J,СڗoJHǥ9 =[Ҵ=)WZH1ҟ(_%H (=)r3|oJT&O^;zRVAQ:?hf֊( zSfp>}֚Arfp>V(Q{VfP-I=+M ʃڳ7jOjE=Tՙ kՠ⚃9C2I(qG*i#3ԫiWHvAJQkZh Kek[rO ]%i礄S: 9l|,`%̷7ь}}+tM/@5NJ1\(+#ZjRd]k-Y 8cLZÔcG\zk)*ԲBXJjU'vO̅H953]"ǒv%Hq_FCvjgu8@eLHg9c~˪Y?x({8-|?Z|p-;Up5 m9mMk0Lcd)ƺnXwҼLkdhMjr)VΥ(jW*-q۸wW)5Pa8SswRkUXmGG/1A N+iZ2n>־lӬ2’ gW05yURI(Cd?"kެ]}-}Ԫ+{"9Db쵡cqEsh4SvR0!j,Ũes&ژmk@,쪶—`Td ,mf⭰aiX9OԿe= vQklv=*?9LMV摇4r*p(#N.*$?5N:s@1Q+*55 O"QHԨiZiOSOZH djUTRuF8Jd})OީJ5NEqNjB8/ZDOJ5"dn0xG҇((AO<ҁ@ *eUgӚs88 ^(L:RS^3M~2i(85*JOzՂ85hPqANARPPG4ӈ\bsNFiccOZD5`(15+P"TI'Jr)@ QH)Ojp#O\ k\>r 9Zp*v"6lG.pd<ʶM(Fm9Feӂ:!`.P&4?ʫ^<,qerv: yϧDI5fׯ HmߎkOAUR{游$$Bz+ Ib 8ZcC̷)e *n|); 1TU>(B{`EE|ɪX\j\s½Z.YZF0RD:ֺLD7J9;/LRq1E8Pc֘jB)d`NZST@")@q0!n48043@ ) ;L ]tHWץ@>X^ t׭JzSv_S\|$qD})^)1:#p*1֥=*,@JL^hb JzPcxTDsS8Ҟ4RgjUQ:(6a9:Jhڮz%Җ>)9J1S@(LqN{U]̌ SQI&EhTk$i;k<<'@1rĭ2њx& ZW9.OLqz"֩ mFp3ߑ^yQqЎ}j=2tCetR"rr1E܌fIciqAfznZrByI`|p| s^?nysS=5_Naxk6ԬdΉx!R>j.v*Qc֥ZI#hdJ =Ez7J#r}(Q.9څn()t=)Hy@ #<Ղ*EKB8^)@┊^<N=(i魌ECzRJU:tahP6)`RQBj`8s@+GJ4I8PT?SB~LZ: dOJ^TҀJ)i]jb8SEޥ*>*!֞54LW<@ 5^AYP?4|}(zr GץKS"(PxtZqP2jX1JstaQ4 TljQLnSJE6q@ iOZku#PK֦jUP1)S @1<}Sp3;!B#{kqnљc)ze/KuoE# +!A$s?D梮)ҕGdx֙ *?܋} # -cfJJծhWWf$y"1 JKcӲq{ͤ_$=Kz* Si8⸽T hNu뎕 RSJ\cO>nVgJ SMuߍmlI$kǑָ{IdK} rkJᾗ [~PONt:_-f,t=c ꒋ݉SIs4xZm #˵i"r85AM4\ێ<k Z԰;rY^厇\|+mReh$8>f^$09h~_l$iQ#2{}|>Ku,~wa_(i-ćPǸW EhUDxR3Q^bN4U84RPH@4jLsHE4)*@8@Hå!NHbcczTئ8.iѸf98NV4ySZ E #4(LqJXzёMf 0,)JQҙ֍㹠,L>jvᎴFh ݤRC8=( 0c5)Q#O1@Y5/jpn_Z-6NւA9Xݪ )֋+G5*iV#uJau++Iy=h޹9XxN޴QpdbÚ<Ť޼EÕF88D(}hrSA2UNJ{gmC/EÑEH*/5i|ɏJyˊo\98aF'QAhr2UJ8n#%_ GeH{Ti^}h{6X4UEٲQT7cik?dƛjka&]5?tOڽLXp^`o}4xrnpQ.HHx'VnΜ- N[#ߦExN;D7&X=P[F! ;p*x]/v¤XzbJf$q5=uN4] 7%mv=IZj8 ?s!H+.u=ij;e9dtGYȪYֺkCIuGUܚх%6PyVχM>QZߊ660y!#"27(9881;XqJk&L0M6@3 "FOLuy8⼧HS }tb+frkMsTc4^ou[KЧhIva8n,u+"U+ mШ=3K#4[MjΣ*mN|笣 x("QN7Gx voOj-~6xJK+ dQٽZ!S"K҅duӥp-#7OJӒ϶VV,ϭdvùk%!^1N7G} Z ѳעo|H|5;*! aA&[ק .'zx7t<|΢Ր8<UMZOZnxɗ!k'zɗRjzOZ92KT>)>3֎`LR OG04(x=h`ɚ4gc'=4!_Z||tU>=he9QC֝G0{&]{U_Z Тl a話w$M(4iJj#IEro4暈Ero4暊7hMEڊrQ1CHhKK@&MKT&M_8@\4yW.O<)E7yP( yUӅ L4{gBiZ=ڡܟlujRP'ڗjR;y@jr7hj75@iEro5!QJ?޴vJ( GQR<2F(4K淭GKLI2FR@ v4Q%~/Mq ̡Y;W_x~I-ൌE `8H׮Ss)<\~uV " +/$z!h$e4 $k 4p?.>3gQ-ÕiMc?ٺd/4R>U'򨧬4x4kvz^K(I>~mp#uv+SԂI\-Ck['?(¹֕$-62fg#GVk6 #MFb #yz#p xZ)|2?,s9K5-,FekI&v`f?ʨit\o]ǖ5_zܶt%Rm5+>ZECy2oko0CzX ķaP\lUħuHi% >Px'玧>&ȴ6Xec uq^2Tt]P{ᏅN>&Kq?^N;lv<~uׄ]78m+UL͗o_ f. WYzij~{W|?;B$fz ~5&;N8H~S8X:uigAX{q:X2;dWEJ'{VWi[Yۖ1{0*{)㲿eO+ƭ {>Oio3l;f(%QZ|Kgp-2qֺIenF` Ͷ,2IFJQ4!rJvk ]Ⴀ>ELм?/|1z' TT><ۡM^{?|ce3jv'(:nDcRrG;\}<x0+ Ա3W 6 \~ZgK*hS4n-C qzT[h\3yku.~`-i'}. :TYXƪrGU/jzƞ֯GvT_!:7*c޵O |/9!5BTkM3YM7 Wp$vo_OC#6XW:_L- kDmLe}irS jZӵ-0`ׁkK8gOXWr=M.hjzLbZHxҹ-gΗp9m pGjԜns#j, BuӃj֗<Ğּ9qjvNNT?A?|G=ys3U9z_^ݵU;fǿ褮:VDE-`tF)i( Q@QEZJZJ0R ZfHm:! (u%APh)hm( i9 Ph SH)NC!KAHciԂCJ)) 7>BPhS-!A QKE 4HiV-4N4Ji(R Z4Zio`AK@)H t s2dl1#\χ/Fy&B8bzo\`Vunɮl> beсlm /Whn*}߻^L[=44-ГyDqTZF.#"@SKZakՄ0[+NFzeր"F>ZÊ~6qcSⴊs|"/zgsNnGӵ|/Lj5 {P\L8ߑSF:VyqrRÒk|_-#4>QrW;mvڮo Q$y<ҷf?EۏJ ʼn2@yhXb\9<WK(,odf<~cӸˈsμ&5RgCt4#֮aq;?zڴռ!-9XG5sj:̷N^YMH Wܤ9IjY:b&64c؝d ĹL[M^|EV$2:VՖ6#gNO \ң$yOIWথ>&C $gOKa( ^\~$~Yk77 :4S&8g=O+?ú4itzᛗ4^-F2G5o3F=֞o{hUJh=9S"IҢ\,3zZfE\ǀ)V%ԦL(5̏:fv,9=2jεs O:!o,L*:jdwΠ (QKI@))i(0RAKLJ^Ԕ Kڒi(EPҊ AKH)h4ӗ4ҭ[i)ƛ@آ@@Rm8t lPh4A֝@Қ(ZC@0AKAHiP(QhiHiE[@uH(`i)M^ԔREj擦^jbCzUSWQڳm2>I?@+/F-KYF3eVͫ­ee d:O|A#*cr'(qqk+)xMi|/GfEzw'?Җ2Q $,LD\u!LpA ܁1;vi!KYN1ٰ8/h *-TGNE.:dҰoW~YlF[ldm-ZxlnoUXcBrkZ-Ja½_b~n䴤  fl:`9V6Fȿ6GQLJB l:d'+2<)]WĶZ;|׮Rk6NdӁbH*OGּr3m#^I./[%  aڳ[KfĠ#{J޻{ZSw@0#+`4}vJoKx`>c7?Ҳb"xZW;pPƵc%Ο(䧙 r yACڢInkFNџVnD><Ҝj= أ?٧}4+h[>@hVACP= *ҏ4+EY6;RЮEUnԂ +F*ٛvzX;Qv,UnԿflP= QV>٧}@*ъf+P= R)>HZf@hT -[җFӹObFE{xxZ7(oJ,x(b+CmHl=( ǹC(zQfs?Z"ɱҏ7qE^=( Z?b8@>Ú=Rj}REsQ`})~})ه< b@4K 9X{XMOm :SŀBasvסecs[fޢ[T]޷N$ͭvm2f*Xr*z2ף|"3#+ 85W72ܢ)m  t%CZHRG,~}&1g^^Ykqݳv3W/JDFrtvn=̓Q"8N?e=̛9n]b>aCes\6vaL $V$[gxrڤWp- Y&pO<P#w%ghCz*<>gv[fF?'+9UeWM$*1͍V}xxk~+i1*ca@74U&gf)5uafzkw l(gA7Ss^/G BwYs-jſ ,l_\ܝ8]6/_EQ4:b"@o} \mCi&>oR0@\k2oPeKsm HĀ߈\8𶫵3{V]xz [IDz~ES}{ᆃviن?r_Ey?մ 'KhL1+Nn 4w21\a؎#MkB_*?iM'+Vo ;yLdsR.2qJO|8cxPC,&a'=zt efiɨmv6nnp 'U>}F* 7ldU[j͟\U;fQVOL@t11m7$j[Pd( Tt"`{֪+RCb*%A!IMMoKk;W6 s\!$?!5%7ʶ198STj/pb9JGtldRԭjFҹh+:mN7QhKUjϔo&ﲮiMQ=>ygҺj's3G}+6kM"={;!Fhm4r+T~&UQr) w6ڊ1 PUE֢@@'+(JX4?PҜzSJxdQDH CrjH׊:ڣU%s"x%;/#kU&f\'Yg8 ֻy$Vv,{դbQ֫N88@7;A T=jkCܤ{DӼGIK'Z'aR? &tҖCLR_V,Gמ+S @Glw?7NssZiK3Ued}K{ !kAFi`Z ~ڮ|7uZQ0rZY;lԆ=ӂEWכ* Y8?Jڏ^0=-= jyw'$6O+QK oc ` XV=zٿ(l=j;nnd->t~E`ľd_̛w» u+ ᶋ|ʌ։'{f%zE4?[qSH4AE-HaiۯZ~jc)Jb/4RE/5C5X`VUvp*ɠ Sd<ԑ ^MKi_)"Oa@Qj8) B2iM H j g?J9y5 ☃Ƙ ޑ9h5?5L:TڀAƁZ^ԧ7<ԃPW 8SRILddTrjaeIESB0bc4t 3NrjEL5G5#)$J:PE6)-(JQERH25İq2=CLX+ٯ⍼vxS8 '+j6CW*?Jf`>Fg]m\%ԧ`p ѰuSAN](Y&; v.|zjee#iz.%., /pj-.i2%WT0Z;Z| ;ME(O07A<~l,WCFimrZul O)ʴ*2:И`籪RM#h0jeGes@#Sطv졻^7]=_6"ƥe䪒wbpm+vt唬1![{6#LcqT,ni K 9NjS_6Sʷā{x>H ӋT3>@ 䟥;9EYy-zCw,Hn$GOkH[&jm?M ЋYffN#Iinu >a#{g8hNI*Mh'SZ10(NGPqRhD. < |:GڌsS| ]jGavƮ` Hc~m+];`v+ ְ&vqzsV|0t;g'ط9޵X(**QL}r;oSմy\\<QSSԆᚤIhG&LvkOy RWQCG*hNW[jm mY${~xTXzppjE,b\[ 6RN?U_oc[Ŝ)[Brn[ϡ[?tѨHB"5@ZMJV~9!U)#{Qpăq&9`{ NMA0p:Rp=䌞InY~OƮ9҈.<{.XZyFxZa=3ڝh;"FZV#=U3 2s ~<yy}cAql3׫s!' ,HSH%K.ʞm!ҳO2ۈ9QM䶇REb! %-?{o֤SQTT] TqN)tCvy@.iԠg4CP-- # JtpnDy5#( )1J)zsOn(u4/Z)4NZQKH4\Q@4P"67S>ݞ+qZ-9g4$'±V۲A95ebdFH늳D iKeft*:g* Y[~ԥ`r|TW9,0M&.qҁ֒RYb)ZVu¯f~e#VŶ"o9c5Vq "t]֕HE'QLT]/Wq2_)dA˂A dZ/:_lo.d+ dQ'9EJ 6u*ʎ&H+KOG,(Ý '!=NZ<Cisx\fI ?4qBd';kjm$9ڎ@b_DP2ǰVbK(d`>i[ (yZ^+u>Ia%?z^y_ʟ"xmGP6nD=drƓtΦ YTai py*;rMvzѸzԋzSMba޴sF}h`ZSrsFu&(k\/[֎a$oyGZQ@I}kl;ҋ= i|\֏?'@dR:}kGQ?bt>b}kkboo_Z]Xnj>s7.5`o_Z `s9u&Aj\A/(}Esnj>٢_Zz:ozsGI毭' pL\ٽz ?`Δzz7oi\tzi_Z}.?`\(Jss_iZod: Gֹ?'֋ӛ\i{Ҹ{;^+`GcӞgr{Ud20jgR :"MhSTDnE`yV.K~%@nEjdXX;I:=}2N2z X5RV#CڬSK?27AϒLi=Z]mG$Q`'dLsPxNJb"t?4)ʚDHsVv@<ޢvIiZ,=_ֺuW 46u5]^=-EFK_,čGwx&m%CQ+#pDyݨ!)AVR #ѩ?}ݏ=r݅yO?~[7Jt+?eSOo:m2RUQy"ƄF|ϠQרek }˗P aȈr.QreejϿWKQsTIF>ZX@?l FȬ0d>;$.dE4e\q L^&(4(=u$NCZ RR^7œb:gGS`h n s!e_[CU }y:|=Cujq*ls)<BK2eldg󨟑[KncĜy ۸3XSD`{E%ؒY`ւ6,RARW]ڧBGqV դC64]fk]fxL2n9hqelSZIkXͣ9AHܾׯn#,3/Bۗay&d. ew{)'?mbAػu'&xI\os[ (wM=hBdb@5g?@AKHii@N)iQޖulQA)ZC:R4A֔дݎH4RA֜hhOu qR(u4 P(4 +! P: 4u% z)MVM8R ^ .M6E")M%@4(PCAS`:A4H 4Қ@9'r ԑ _1LsÌ>=hYI}GZ`'*0?x~pt>!؎))*F%QHc4q<M)^4kTRz tnG"U8r\Sqhr).1C L*NCckgjiv0G?l_L1+𝬾5Z]EYt|E*bSOakξ} '1j"ispuB<4"4eh ^Z$n㬏oAIέ/ca%zVO};7{w:νmRBHtMrtMCZM#>i3E8A:~ӦTe韼|ח|U/m-|EJ @y2JimURW#LP˗M>'}__?a~(kä٪%P?ycܒj'شkXR\JUpD${MTcSgclҔg*wQp]m]O *}h7p&(C15PiN/'TNK-6"MFܺpqT"#X U ŗߘRU0MH^&o68()*翡3r4PvS7Zwd(:U$ݮzhS] ? xWnstzZ|m>xe~QN|b14'fqӵ&BqЏCR]7Q6r V$^+Iw*QEtX1L#(?
Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2016-06-15T032409Z_1318694635_S1AETJYZLHAB_RTRMADP_3_USA-ELECTION-TRUMP-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Greensboro, North Carolina on June 14, 2016. Legal scholars say Trump's proposal to impose a ban on immigrants from certain countries has some precedent and might pass muster. REUTERS/Jonathan Drake

By Matt Spetalnick and David Ingram

WASHINGTON, June 15 – Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump’s proposal for suspending immigration from parts of the world with a history of terrorism could have a legal basis, but his assertion that it be part of a broader ban on Muslim immigrants makes it constitutionally untenable, legal scholars say.

The new twist in Trump’s anti-Muslim rhetoric came in the aftermath of a weekend shooting massacre at a Florida nightclub by the American-born son of Afghan immigrants.

In a fiery speech on Monday, he expanded on his proposed temporary ban on Muslims entering the United States, vowing if elected to halt immigration from any area of the world where there is a “proven history of terrorism” against America or its allies.

He also accused the Muslim-American community of broad complicity in attacks such as the Orlando shooting, which was carried out by a gunman pledging allegiance to Daesh, and threatened “big consequences” for those who fail to inform on their neighbors.

Many legal experts said Trump’s proposal for a religion-based ban would be unlikely to pass the test of U.S. constitutional guarantees of religious freedom, due process and equal protection and would likely be struck down by the courts if he tried to implement them by presidential decree.

However, a ban on immigrants from certain countries has some precedent and might pass muster.

Some see that new proposal as reminiscent of the congressional Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which was used for years to halt the influx of Chinese laborers and has been widely considered a black mark on America’s immigration record.

But Trump’s overall immigration plan would go beyond that, targeting not just a country or a region of the world but also a religion, something that no modern U.S. president has done.

“This is an absurd proposal to build a Fortress America and pull up the drawbridges,” said John Bellinger, former legal adviser to the Bush administration.

President Barack Obama took a veiled swipe at Trump on Tuesday, saying such ideas represented a “dangerous” mindset.

But U.S. presidents have wide latitude on immigration matters, and some conservative scholars said that the fate of any proposed ban would hinge on how narrowly Trump framed it.

They note, for instance, that Democratic President Jimmy Carter barred Iranian nationals from entering the United States during the 1979 Iran hostage crisis.

“If a Trump administration cut off immigration from certain countries, rather than certain religions, it would not violate the Constitution,” said John Yoo, a law professor at the University of California Berkeley and former Justice Department official who advised the George W. Bush administration on interrogation methods used on terrorism suspects.

Herman Schwartz, a law professor at American University in Washington, said if Trump stuck to his proposal for a temporary prohibition on Muslim immigrants, that raises significant constitutional questions and “shows his shaky command of the legal facts.”

MUSLIM BAN

In Monday’s speech in New Hampshire, Trump showed little sign of scaling back his call to ban Muslims from entering the United States, which he first laid out in December after an Daesh-linked deadly mass shooting in San Bernardino, California.

Debate over the legality of Trump’s proposals was complicated by the vagueness of his pronouncement and questions on how broadly he would extend any immigration ban if elected.

While legal experts say presidents have the power to ban immigrants from specific countries, the United States does not currently ban immigration from any country. Officials do give extra scrutiny to people entering from countries such Syria and Iran.

Under the broadest interpretation of Trump’s pronouncement, immigration could be barred not only from the Muslim world but from U.S.-allied countries in Europe and Asia where militant attacks have taken place. This could include India, the source of many skilled engineers for the U.S. technology sector.

Critics say this would be impractical and counterproductive.

“Is Mr. Trump proposing to stop issuing visas even for business or tourism or education to nationals of certain countries?” said Bellinger. “Rather than increase economic growth, Mr. Trump’s plan could cost the U.S. economy billions of dollars.”

Republican Senator Jeff Sessions, a Trump foreign policy adviser, justified the candidate’s pronouncement, saying “it is perfectly appropriate for the country to refuse admission to those whose presence may be detrimental to the national interest.”

But Orrin Hatch, the longest-serving Republican in the Senate, when asked whether a president has the authority to ban immigrants based on religion, said: “I’m not sure he does.”

Legal experts also raised doubts about the legality of Trump’s demand that members of the American Muslim community “cooperate with law enforcement and turn in the people who they know are bad” or else they will be “brought to justice” themselves.” Critics have accused him of anti-Muslim fear-mongering to win votes.

“Generally, the idea that knowledge in and of itself comes with criminal liability is antithetical to the way we talk about criminal law in the United States,” said Daniel Richman, a Columbia University law professor and former federal prosecutor.

If Trump tried to implement such prosecutions as president, he said, potential defendants could simply invoke their constitutional right against self-incrimination and continue to remain silent.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment