U.S. Drops N.Y. Fight with Apple After Gaining Access to IPhone

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?J_JqHkg?U͸Y9?h >vJA* pG"*sR!y͎8zmN6o5>M=Jy#q֓.8xl28qV>1K XUR= 4D U6uqޑS5hάq[aM#@$\ie9$B[&:TsNn(Zz5yJ>LpXWOYdTM=&W`t{miCzTexSxS‸CsNSB}ډKFe5#*tJ& j)gݹHI =yW$8RJw43Ni깧{X\0nc"( j1$h $rWUy#$U#X$ig+XZ]AUmL:);3Qe;SRLEm?T`Oa}6Q|E[zX|gKilL{q\:nN(1v)@ơ܇5 +@ûb RmMqSR5 krXy5xmw?rz(ZϸbHlJQE-v8x@\֡yb8QݏҰ>}F;{XIFI5 aM< 2+2 Zҧ# GK]A]ġ{ #IWX2mZodzu+hHqNE:cVVs8V%e9cSFr y{c殅>SJDRQV`r*7\bsIrjyg:#EҶeVHOj.2-ET82K]ǑJZAWdtgV(NeVaq[& U{UQ^P1N*ǟRl NF*ۀO^H~^+[rH9&2HNsM!DM@}),M]dn<9FBi v76^y 5jnƼ6LF`-glfӘO1*7MR/k$͹%ʒ::VgFdh6pFFjH<)hYQ×|ǓOZxP{9rG[X}͜UDh1gOY YԻIl>vAFsE ׵Vy@ROyեk*kBPq Mpܜj!Eyv$VaAp)3kDaz8+&j彼Ry`215iYc^ =v8IȢɆ9֖WJԊI%V͚1p9r TV0SD1rJX` Evа 91]Q*:}xt#sOӀ[A*Z05J0̟R  *&VRElN>aMyCEB]LH4A].kǾ*8!;HnxC#EI8[v{jHcRy(OlL=HGD1P)8O;:d5HvH={QBW,=l5F\sz&k5AlWgs0U9z;-dÓY5][ݎ+͍ Q| mTm#x) rI݊ ?A)_8`\~#ȵYzCRWCHgzjȇ=SҰwGCN9'r>)}ږ)Z/..`$zn⽜<m5*J +lHu 'LXَ <<׎[\jRF|~$ | khn:Jm_?6b-L+7pU}~Q{œ-崴ף3vrP11@?|b~%뷛_@ůÜksz4o}b,t|c"U(tYQIRWSΉ2EZMa!̌#? FYg|H[G,5{$ặo}5{mƒXk/ù⫕q . ;JuD3Vk vJAJ)qQeF0;RԼTKNzӹwD ے)kB9HdpR*neHj A,?)yZ*ZhjFtQ,9^[ CV.57-ZDYH StsXJ˃YS5j~5+b\뢗SCNK1r,G#5jfgc,7%ZCԨ/)Y\|͞sJZ@͵5nXvBzXL?_y"M3I)]T?NWpXb +0uMY3qX6g[XH:dVq@Ha]<=\CqY[ðcr(qR,|tpʡ_8,yVvqz;Qq{FSh$9P' ATRA1[VvJgZGfjU SȩsM3Lal[ۊ=E22 9تb3).$ZJ4lLE!-jGj@eڲtkyIJ6c\.*&KLpZ!EX"YF LMCNQ֗u@0&G1"齪"USX桻 p*٬eƾ@s`Cu2E[5kWVUwYu9y,eUfj&xao׌.IzQyZ8:Ns1%&Hi3Qcr44S TsT+(Ƞ9U9P(b3FbFı-Yìx*y1*Ă!4tC{\ZoG,#Lͪ;Q2"Ȯ{N7$9+XJ5Hr0NSҷ1,y#"v`G5'iU+XzL~4TdC_5|kw]bI:׳|R߄"msPOUą$N.SȈBh%p%S J(Q@Q@Q@Q@-%S A֜)<*IK0KDF~#OZrvE%s[ýN\f`'癔 r{1T,"#U#@UFU0y$9iQMrY vR5K%TM`@#5m"F8V\_7Zh9lN0 ӉQY0|ƴp)36Tj`AZ /2P_֠1\EBRjr$']R!..Z<\@\;w o@F>X߹txj) ϘTjHגt Y&|STk=j7y#5ϬةS* P$p@ Z\ng@KFl4GZ@+ G4֧6Yo6AߥE0)ǽOfP,*nińsj^ҭ(85咛mA5pS֯DFve9i͵Z琚dHњ+FT)́j֖9=*%QJ+ 0@$GUٹ!wϽ8A!r*yg♟5?du˦=jǭR敆rs\?-tSG54Ag577f&+8ˈv^,@#%8Wf{/5! o޼jc,m4u$APk1yxUsGd4K<.5~ _5be9 ګWfWVle JjfzjcUQڤMztT]:+qOE隉>P95$|uvJ aEP ((((((|Y٧ q:@5 h@I?ه8+#xn}\C0HP0F䁚$&ֽ=QpF;F+>V^* \ڝ-LEck6X91lmQrkϼi4x.*z|**Sz1ͯyHG+)P<⟵'-LXYdҵW%}>*Pns$jP:Q,Azuu HҴlg@8 7C"ir+>vkJ&T7b,B榊-—xaXz-?q˩Tx=jIGj3CM%8PC(AEPEPEPEPEPEPKIK@F@Vi16?ZEIC2RfF>o nCUb)"hȬ 2HA1XYF>gbOj^-p:]Lje"шbX̑}kic22r9Sz -CxUd 3ܫ[u@Yz5\(P )\]qu) EaU-}g"xd',I85F]GGӊޚR3d)=x8fX0 Z6HQ/?(bMTysӥMlEU咙4AfrryTarK^iꀔzx٪l75}qIErwdvj-C,i(2U._nAYpI?19o MeKuF-!SҔcm'E^+crė <^M|OXׅķ#-<@56"-.}bM'dEXr E8Ui+4XrZdumƼY&?)]$̸Z*2>G3&lDH6Wcf)]{=8O#5Y& F-Sc+ |HWQObMͤ!524c#Ɇ$՛ W5XE)%Q@(((((((Z˼Nֲ*h$1HT慣4>v Յd!8PjDNz׍|TqK64d^tcgw]hz6nMb\JREh&uLF2zxkc+/`=?y}:Ӳ>,9&ʝqW*5Ahh%N :H*D]=bfCO45#Z%; ހoQ >E08whE+ǤҺj ;5n+Y<3#G"R0Gkrwڎ6Iy:~*Ak CV9MRw2QL(((((((J))&kiś>PY[ C]gDk; 75"l2\rO Wx“tyI뚓 Y0_;ɘB'5f!pֱ)26@|V h搚]S%4s@[7u4>+}JL҂1LHi朼R@KqI .()kM7u.h< fqFs@ӰdM/P‹ )Tnz,>t:hA:-PFi;"j:4iRfJÁ┑fi@$R.ၚ6p<ՀB>Hii}?%{bJ%88C3m80#$4D%'5:$ q(#YZGq޹黙$*溷;>cs>E eIfޟG>w#|})VXMU1>,'5Zu0!4$Vrh=j.E7-\^ӹg i&'+`Q7RS6",Q♸^niVQ9AMW-ȧ/mbv~i7[Iɣ^&FTDI4rkr}g5jRArd~lTAHIA^֢݃F\֗M 6&Uy:)|UO Jm 6j,DRѬ'rE$S00=)2EM+" OV-J R`p#CMS곀8Y84~/rTrZ8R#MVAzSM26 Hh2 HXJqҬ) jUK0QobCE Wv&_y GzOSy>+Sfl KTm, sӂԞRo񚄙*Kr ieNc4vc4r*4":y=J{H.Fi!sh:]Iwc5 H7uiy#MnHOph`SHcک#)B446\ti#U;FhY0jJx"Ѹ<inZĔ <0#5!w i 5^y55&b쐞 ^ kN׏Sм-a;qCmJ]zS<{QoN\Er*1pCS?Zoz/kBI jI4ﳊ_z~6zrg o(ս#IAp:$w4UŔgt #Ci'ьF9Toi9&8S|d⏳J-Cq*0!bMZ8+֪>ԞVSYJf34Ik(#4 xӄ'xiw4Rcq~ywċh@z|:ܹ3++ȗnkvH bf <C=zm:5tRv4̾Xm8#suѺ5]n՜D9!\IZTP1qzDrs4ǘ&tzDSXchbݥ͖r+^=TQgAf$z /q+{MJEjGvR#)ւX Vbю>u~N; c)v}V6ɡv3?qS'Y$W=L#[mUnkN^x]Bȡ\u0JgΑZh@O5~x6 x5{hv(Vu晷Ah\=LuJz)Cȼ3H'f(ʀ)HHK  ~#8f]3z:WK\i"P8xmD(ˌݢ@=+ڋ>^ ӧj` D*ȋ<Ϙڝ$5[H8♋)}ՁA}0B=? >y- Q1Pk(W?[NmC@qoξPִPPx.am}kϫIYIYĢ(QKr'QV^C諚&tFR( h 7RP Z)(Q^Zm*pGaϩrvFԩ"o> {MgSma}kolMX )h0 YRiMpѴO#-ZYml tArga+X"^ C/`Q7dW2gz+u535w3 RbM]~Tll8w#25ZlSoSBa(+X48杶sEWQPG P)M*.%ЍqR(vC":pi qN<p\S"d*J"cԏ51R=n[piq\Խ( !@mPM"HUm)3XLR▊Erޝ=Z@&ƑOSejz#GRD<ԻT75 <7Jcv. d .:U"1IݎeC8E8W.Ҫ jmc ȲYjf#Vp5g8no w  ֯Zi1}8#*;p#XՌ&5maf=*Vܙ[ /*3ENjGJŤ δ8dYiQW*iF{3/_#A؞&T,T _D+k5_X Ƹ]sX7V$q^V#hco9)wH犻q5W(])Bs4ЧxQM݅3@&-2zlhv=‘5nz=Nytiʜ0ۀG8?g1AA*qLAS*dZG9jhiĉ#޴|՟f1Zɂg ޣD}0*]԰H 9 SA"nVTW3h3wh1@ y}Ꮅׅ6FXUN`|}o%$YuYIQ^m,Ou*:W^:iɃ8-+}rLe1?SӴ/ {W ig\[A!EGe%rǚ-c;5_V Ef N/tnϛEŚ.m5`0Ep[JO"u 5g~-6->QqƼ_ƩʞʹN fKO9V}!e }O@>zMB´l6i#(^882дȱdLE[ۘl{  k&|PidNlkTS~3BO! ?o^iI=략^MHjL#$;y4rs֛\-.M9\(.EvkNX"6x \M<[ur+G@.ă5=M/޵jP13Xw}5\曓R's]4&EI7&1@]^&<)i9 Z6hkc x ~>`.Z` W$eR!HZ?:n?|ƺi˛L.c%f+ќbA(+8-nff Wq^gr6ݟ|>$')7%B!4db9¦$TvQ̜ҽsJ"otͻ 6c\kUV< LS(ev8^M(>awqoZQ'b)MoH")"hI1) U._c>ԬZ\%z̹"栺2tB)EcSS HrX`qXqkw1|+8`Sd9Yp o@1lu^t vY1q r+\W>{0,J榈5  WZ +Q>~s@b ӵ\qUsP MGR6pJ895gsZ6TF-W|my$I|h=I< ޱ=[sqjέNEJ՘Z3f95NO4I94[l(B ( ( ( ( ( ( vi m15 IJAF.\ŸKI .OQ]M5wjbn^Uᏽz*:םxY#3}Ov9 _#EB*NJۭKALi2qR;4ܲ);$yձ\3qkӼ6d +|; 5ZZ+-<NlN^GH)dkwQ7)mJHcʖ>Mݳ{6>^{j즂93s[0?blp`NJq8]W:sU&K2NiUY,r+7Ҩ,cqR+ab|YTyeH氮L -VX8rV9- kS0t!eR8E5y8;IgrؗC05TqQm5 rŵ.h j&&Z9ۧ,&5\̴hV?oe 0f7@ɖ" 4-YuZ)֦Pv."<ۚJr)AaN Ǒq-HMAZO;\׉>G5  9XX,2 kB؆5ZߖGkjɧ4m5)ڣ5Z@1vr* lp^NjIs/Z$Vk^|ogb R ϑMYnISjO#-$J㚼ʼE)t8sE+dTri.hh|A֫]t5u3֤33%\eޮkfL+3R#eZGL*٘ұo"Fxy@Y 00NTԕx]O!t oz}.u8JYdqGZF*}z挤0ёWCy$c,~=BEHīX5khYƾ+hyxjq9Km$z'ȫ +hT˅ V;WՁ +9.N&ix"$yc!&ַ&rXj4[lS4Ԇy*O>_|q!w&OKj3+i¯"hRQEbEPEPEPEPEPEPEPENS-?+Dɥ0WBt H+ LrzлF/Һ0ӳg~C kWIn6+^\)c)H5;֞d0ܧ7CɼmiZ@j`[fvF6#H21]XZ +ܡUϟfU&\,mTr>Ȩ.I#u܎QQ5yaD=#  _(6XC JKuaR =Қ*F=! Xf0՘5 "IJ7*KC7-gKRed8 faG} cCQQ-R3yf;ש\E"Oqzݗ@ɯ7As5cw7$j6o303TirHiƗ4{4KM.MdL~s.y֏<<2hDjE9Z;RsIFSFܟZ\Z\՘kSGG7}g'IqT8;V&Ij\|/4{4 #삋pkKZ49't>@$|mJ<6kJ⪤_ RZ6ejsO+ZLk#k{5&9 9>U3ҳ;Qs.@w $W#rֶq޽wžf$Rҹ-j1VR_;D-Z! W~WsɩIř[I6zbڹh\1#]䚐zScVNW !"e%jT7 is׏l׊b~sױ<HE,kjחCc .rIQO4 bQE((((((()@@.xs@28`k>\~G{+( JƵM~m;BH/XC[ﮭ=Gq1UM*ˎkmby=Vl FpZk WIoKl&!6 3R6 jnq ff  &Td`r78Pd[) }(4!8zp+=[&IœHrIҬȬ%V, b jWqB皑0H犫!ɤh0 nc(84ӱE Tl5:ؑxQܒMW9OC]bH.ryy^V + 4fQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQJ:֤ 4a@8.M|Gf[Sکx?xWO20_^x+ĪBq]Ti)j.*og[ĉ ep>y 5pe# ڬ`bޣrC2%B\mBE?xU◰r*5\lwx2tgN3UCm9SG1]ך6ScaJjtSƔTؖ.E₼ne*Rbc 9RbWC:18"^k<3rz:3qUnDTpMdvV=2O\ ^:,bct9gsR灐5/T *0e0zmJXZ,EjۅdtpeEEhecuHV!⤶ȩqF0E@ҤYbTo⺄Z߂DMb?{ n9B2usKH_'?P0FUyHb2sLvUhL9I%ުI76IrjÚ$Tb[=i% V[\=j+nB[Xk3f`ֶɷwXNB9F=RX0#9H5ѭN2AՒ @ҖsT]槵2j3O*4i1h,kqQ:2>F$7" UCIRh7bҭ Sሶ7 Jbp`KU^p+>,-)ֳ8qRX=b{h1Bclr"#W2s҇pW-F+'HULT2g麬Cd !:WenlTr"\ҫNp>tgJfT񓓊N*py55 dӃT#\[ɋגz$ץs+谵}ǪTvvKg[WOs􏖩a_"UPhhɒ|}jPsQfb.JiJ dc91IacM܅DA#4ݢ1s@ zj!ڴ5L@8:%5)rJ]zɴu3+MYfƫ]]DGzkk+9e:nGbkny?C^4F }?*E ek븼Oc^uWyhZ}Ji*9Q@)E%(R@QEJ( (SQI}I maPOh);Y,/!A|7GXG,m#޾Laעxݨv&#pGS5>:?c{ Rq\C}RW;V3B|)5}jG:Z[*5WgSuӫbڥq^g`ogL$;՛uĤWWQnA\ޢH+Szztk)j̼f5N::(y44V9>}_giD2ZiVWO/=,O15<@VQ/:XcXJ1LiGeMkB2V6<Ѷ$d O[z=bՈ`}X'5osyXu"Ik&;K=kMю=ZϗtH%Ps+EVzË:3ڽ\k3WSG8B@5z޹s(5WWveةQꣷ=iԚ9-SSh*LSZRi#f%}a fc^g7Lߚ赽D4̓rrMx|:UV)zTu<)+0)(((((((Zre(@'Ҳ(ȬR#r(L/fKBO*:+,/pa;I.uux,C!T`W]>R7Dg=(]T?5myR: ʚ jjKfu-QT1 M(Õ\5?, sz'u`{VXkNo=\cu`jY'<7f9&52ƬפA$-q|SXWn^{5W9W~i\#捏b '" $3ս: RysG8&@-wzUIJMřJh`(bqW%lTiw/ɫb]䬋[WIFWq\Y殛 E<}pN*16dpTg'5s-ˀj%"tɧƳIQTqb6-+,ք[+5>r QIW8[ҟFSf~@ji#̦]߁|&*6NZ/ 'h1-X`5b[qjEcr*Ռ+1~i- ٻʘFL; =Lٖ-Wvx+XTҶmslDS]KDddbxՀi;Us zF 9WBg< VcDA$ÚkXJƱw'E4k4U skkO3TWCsbPe})tL\ >ﳟZz2RWGn Кf>nfԏl(y8=EU╤M3W4 v^ s֥v6ңn7sJQ&Ϲ֙iǭRc@5^nqBNa߮)3HSՔ ǀe5Ak$%&p[QfTNP.y[#HOZRe,ƺoM7rC%xͳц$alZ?j )cs:.oGj ҈O/С ZF*oMT"X$- )сZJsAgDfKDe%?(qR2ff;T;U;ʩu cKdf\"bAYm!=Mt0'ku9"J3Zn"JApk; 'ۉR[:WV5+a[8u'8+*N7磗ԥV&X5"hE  YH漹c&>ڟeﭟhhSo"{<&ͽ)bg.u IDuAPY HzW4(E;=sRr)^DӣR5Y5V*9LkYEar1U- %PEtٞ-L?4ue!^*ɃZ)rõ]5KY Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/2016-02-26T170036Z_1326394514_GF10000324702_RTRMADP_3_APPLE-ENCRYPTION-TELECOMS-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

Apple has fought back orders for opening an encrypted iPhone arguing that it is an overreach by the government and would undermine computer security for everyone. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration

By Nate Raymond and Joseph Menn

NEW YORK, April 23 – The U.S. Justice Department on Friday dropped its effort to force Apple Inc to help unlock an iPhone in a drug case in New York after someone provided authorities the passcode to access the device.

In a letter filed in federal court in Brooklyn, New York, prosecutors said that investigators late on Thursday used that passcode to access the iPhone at issue, and as a result “no longer needs Apple’s assistance.”

The letter marked a sudden end to a closely watched case, in which the Justice Department had been appealing a ruling by a federal magistrate judge holding that he could not force Apple to assist authorities.

The case gained further significance after prosecutors in March dropped a similar effort to force Apple to help access an iPhone used by one of the shooters in December’s San Bernardino killings, after a third party provided a way to crack it.

Justice Department spokeswoman Emily Pierce said the cases have “never been about setting a court precedent; they are about law enforcement’s ability and need to access evidence on devices pursuant to lawful court orders and search warrants.”

An Apple spokesman declined comment. Previously, the company had argued in court that prosecutors had not provided any evidence to bolster their claim that they had exhausted other methods to get data from the phone. Apple said it was not even clear that they had asked the suspect and his associates.

Though officials said the passcode had just come to light, the development marks the second time the federal government has dropped a contentious fight over the extent of its power over private companies after Apple pressed it to say what methods it had tried.

Prosecutors had been challenging a Feb. 29 ruling by U.S. Magistrate Judge James Orenstein holding he did not have the authority to order Apple to disable the security of an iPhone seized in a drug probe.

The case predated the government effort to force Apple to help access the phone of Rizwan Farook, one of the two killers in the San Bernardino massacre, which left 14 people dead and 22 wounded.

While the Justice Department dropped that bid after a third party provided a way to access the San Bernardino phone – apparently for more than $1 million – it continued appealing Orenstein’s ruling.

FBI Director James Comey has said that the method used on the San Bernardino iPhone 5c would not work on other models, including the iPhone 5s, the type in the Brooklyn case.

The phone belonged to Jun Feng, who has pleaded guilty to participation in a methamphetamine distribution conspiracy, which prosecutors are continuing to investigate.

Unlike the phone used in San Bernardino, Feng’s phone had an older operating system, iOS 7, which is not protected under the same encryption technology, which is why Apple could access it.

Apple has some 70 times before the Brooklyn case emerged helped authorities access data on iPhones, according to court filings.

The company changed its stance last year after the New York magistrate invited them to argue whether the Justice Department was stretching the more than 200-year-old and very general All Writs Act, which compels help executing warrants, to include more active assistance.

Apple said prosecutors were going too far, especially since Congress had more recently limited what communications providers could be compelled to do.

Magistrate Orenstein agreed. Though prosecutors have continued to push for mandated cooperation, in many cases under seal, Apple has been objecting and appealing.

The New York case has drawn less attention than the one in California, but the fact that a ruling favorable to Apple has been allowed to stand gives it more significance going forward.

While the FBI is continuing to fight in other courts, more attention has turned to a draft bill by leaders of the Senate Intelligence Committee that would force all manner of companies to turn over unencrypted data when served with a court order.

The majority of the technology industry bitterly opposes the measure, arguing that requiring back doors would make all communication more vulnerable to hackers and that U.S. citizens and companies would simply get their encryption from providers in other countries.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment