U.S. Tech Companies Unite Behind Apple Ahead of iPhone Encryption Ruling

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?{)=H O41qP@Ҏ @ 9<{(4;Hz1&zKޓ@ R@P((P,Eԑ[\sL`ҚhMGڥ~|PsN_jh)Î'N2p8󩓞sVdb<RZL*n=(֓SFi < LR"9 i2iH“ǥ<1⁌9Oj qQCZkW{U^5x )\5H!nzTZESRsS,Jb/yD֞$XhKښS~捾b)P6K.?€#pZy^="-moRm@jPXɤ#(^mHd zRy",q~u!\ BdzRc#!^=;P1b)Pv=FhHN@4Ozfi uDǚB)E`cj"HOZisPOzl*&^cRc21Rcd!.?*NT/S nc4oҘ`\cҔ!G1.ԡxޜ%BуShKHTO @Î)EQxԩ/48UĿJz;Pqixaށ Ӳ8&ihZ֝GOBW8!JI?`BRm62UhM1\d(\qҘ*7N)Xe2p{զN@O4XrE^&ƼB9[qHFy<~ޣ>fҘB-LǃPޠ RNRP1ݩ;(F2ߥOn9 ^3//3e2r `]Eu\wHenԻsޕjFvEz i1Gz1sA@Mk@ⴴ)6^QJ ԌΝ+Jݹk Қ9QފBI\P!cYS`xXSjn2jbjP9c֦8*&Z^*?Zcި?PFE(Js@iL5^xSҐ(xi=1/~HO4uSQQ=v尴GP]v$frMVW.ñ9FM EG_ƀ))qA'ڔ/r=" ϵ~Js}pi uD Tx6ҁ#<&.&)^W֓Rҗ̪[}b蓌җH9Nq@:]©8JY.EV}K@ 擽Cr9:2aHj/3##4IZ8QQF>5\ OwP"cf.:T]1V,NiӊE҃HN<"j"ydDhJJ@9jE8B)Ma@SVmޕ<'ƍ(GJA7Jܭd3Go#;=kfg'3ڴcmN⯤_-KeSHW*}Md2!sHGR4Njl2rh=i!ȀLD pzThۮ>n)4Ϻ< š9@A.=^jRUSiOy4(TqVɪɢv *R!HSaO0@:jA#^y($\qjah.G7mNGzn> 1H)M}h9)Ls:̟CMnjHqCy T/Ű]R3J:GzpYcځ}*)iTM`@;9M)ϵV4`U6MPdP[m恆o<=w<!4͸=1@:8r;PNq֐㚏l֚iB_0JaSX~t\g9M?ʅ$a=?_3T qZ"Y: ր)}1Z@3=;ށԣqڷ>謁#gN*$M'SOQJ #aQ*'@Hxiށ8Jk>k\uP2Yrr٭)e$4F8qJ=1֜cN^3SgR/4+j7=U~WQZpArp? nZ.^xYi NQ\ S E q޶3ʂ=1һ [JM+&S}tyXzt3^JA&5-6~_ҵ>)_F>=KG$. bMnǭg܄gKҐ(@Gz1qF=(1J1AbҊNuOj^b ڗc4iOjJCHc"ҔRc'z)c)OcGoz! )O5j'dUژ"sS-Rîj"}jTL(`3R)# 'S:Uu"_z2S)WN:wI >xg#$a5)ScݨA |S#pAVuU,*e5) Q9"XMR2}+<i-~{ C !$w_XQfzk "[PMIU!5{';Z?\-z3FwVjxqL+;{4d]YW*k4lgeRnd uRQ8j7s@ @5C.hPҜnR"^iؠ MޝL.f Q(=)qSHCI~2:11PI ׭Bґ4'4 bvj8$!K)20}(7j<ާ~Xi8SҥZ*ejE֥^M!N4 @EVJ2FDS:tǚh¸ڲdxZO/".b__WK,i.b{JaOLiFq^⏇Z~Gd<N}QWz6\}Rc[?= k)Ռ/,H#̾ k,TR$ b8]GH?-rږA$. z"9{06~ZB)XdqP\֒jiӹZ#ج Rʊi{OҶf_T:R0mAD R>/h{9rFI!knJ4 Yʵ=Fvt& i]eE>M}*`x:lñd<%0eq*Kó5<LMzs?J y|Z~r~tT{rrh.?w[}{(KTMgZ,j˹kzY0yu=}FNdk:bA_Ḵ@]FB 2W|7ݮt <P\VƝ9^h%DqfBP{֟5su/ C`kդ[4`.8ڕy_DUvcE{^=in|5M5Fxu 1\m_sфHjlnʭ:H58{N*)|@9lT{6?j{Vl&\ ?z'ڣ}G#m\Yղ>A&>=;?o /7Zop͎hvΰj >n*7djݳӷq9QF\dT[XU$Խ,Q皷tCI>HCB̧g4F*01R;qQ$^FSP1‚iqMf3TLJQTM'Q{D_ޢN%g T25i*&PV&'Z%F_'EsCN#t]g2-U5IF- jmVJ-ej4;ҵ%q@dOj4Y*'%x:mſtÞF{psZ Ͷse][ ˋoj̸Zc {T5TkՈTG)2P8LcO'B8^@)ǭ&8#s@RAM8Wb3֫!V#=2g*bzTdNcQjDsQ/'ߥMhUsSw`楔c j?OzKy][Qkc\|Mxq_N-VDq$?A_[ĥzZ( (QEΖ4f= [zo.`? ė$z ~?{ӵ4J[e*&?"5܈` l+<S˼1>KW.A @ڃsoׁ/޸[[7{rqzVN?YVp>u=ujgZI}J Tz/t̗PJƼPG'V :/HwwX9k񟖥ӱ*FJR1T&tP]kf\eO&f.@LY65ξbl7>a$It3j"$%l[.*JҁޡiEbG28pZw8c+H<6Ȭn>z h 4J1U@AR8Π 'IZi(I j6+IL/w= 5@A+P*qU])ez#HJ@{&Nz#TQS["ҵNUdj]FѺUڬ#{ԴUˈՈHjX˨jU5QSHXSNԫH"VcPI=Z9qXǞVeͯ%Rh2 Rd4r76d\`vWVN+߯de('kc5uoN?*pF}ktF*hLOj"Bx9cߊ{~s@)O>s@g0R0 !O <½"@Vt9=1-"#lpqZ3[<{2Es=NBP)$嬆 ʚWOH@BxO kR2xqS/J*ݼ2KqU{QJ9L}*͔֬DGJcqk8Lq.M\02Nn<]-&*61H4m/NEkm46F<*5+ضꚚ9zzhhQ@ (E-PQ@ EPX>--mwGbo~^YX* ,ĞZI&KL|O*-=BcQ]E[TU->j+QF(l:QE%Q@f)4+!R@<ZfQe㋘{8/_W?,{ x K+t#ҢqrUFFk:%H#g%93y56zбpV(T8CֱnMdIiɧ^y_P U5I\+523Y275^$w[~+ZY"/r1+Nm^V @J"LmLsZUY⤳2Sɦ9Hh9MT.5 \Uy$M#[j!jvz cKErٔTO7SiPIqMD92ϊ$U=˚ZZJHɚJfV%6U$cjtnEuJTCJ-TQXԪԁ2?5b7皡UjE=XGzԴ4h#UnxXG4^VQmӚ[Ҥʚztom}<KLg=' ymՏsTs]XW'%s7=yRHT nǞEg7ڝ 1jOjP8ӂO t%8E]/GiK[moV3ưsnor+Ң f$6*(g$VRfGi6# UO[jD0 (Rj(v:SVgvCק| O%+I#ݥiM>GŸ>޸6}C[[k8*IGÏ A Z7$y2A+/C̒96@)(KA"IA ZΠf%̋nqkz9EOx[6:Up~E:jgag{`.uc$5iZ L~ա^Icʄ+ =E(&=lQMahZ3J׵82k>b(b0MGZDcQ;RzybTLS:IZD6ZyU2WVCPQ[ J] PlEākg >'BrqrnR2He5̹7gBS%U$URJV9#ٝ}8/w@F+Bf5xSLiZVnȽE} r^IȁHKpëoç^NMV,`k 5 GWdU\^QT@3-T"gOC+ J{LzKzngPD}k;Te@ϧ;2C{{V:UX8<xGB+WmM'=;Kc&v9R֒ H]XiEueM )C(#V QE!8G[׶M_Gw_P(hֺ-qÙ݋oc.[*êE+(v3Q\JQbǰ 7w-ݾWėDvN,Jn)d5 u9S1?SO-B]KU6JD0)h,Z+Vt֓6 O%.O-c8yAK۱YE*8g h! (((p3@ mM"PG] S~8/5KB;%=A^R2xcNjCݲ͎MLШj~I>Ձsu%sơc4ӑjR-ɽzV\za+s_)?oDm'O\O Mr㻑:WR) $4VQJ)(sKIFhP!Ef-hťi͒|:{\i+v&os{I]o^Fscb߃3]&mA#TDn_"*SP`SJ (?k$: ysW!Wv,k{2lhw$Rz4Օm}z[]b3~UՋKinc.p4iu=gM[nڭVvb~ ]A'Э)h/)žb vBsWW+Q¨5_xahJF᛻T\Ǚ}dͩ^]ݹg.{\ݩz ^pUIt'sYs8PVwT+FHlnʏA]] uzvXTʭMvq~$W[xddnP+HŠԁx%QuM"њ"HQUX6=˽gPp $yeu #QW_(h&o8 ;hA9Gj+I!5N`aqtrpjӰ35`Ue|/&N035}sך5jY8[BZA5L ӱr}Tc])X~GJ:U6.9旰W@S&okRzҷGZW|lr{Օ|ǿ5!50(OHjȏښPk ߈M2IfnȽ}ivg.{hV=&7*7z [61R~ Z\A-64IE- <]=ԏ.@9Hbi$ "\k:me?zX4&oq %W=X'ܚ M*n#Ah BZAhP?,1z0?B1+Jk%&i`ӀMG Ȥ شjx#HE&R5LY)ȫ .1P;T=Jސj"T Hj)x|R4^)MT2T?4X/Bp٩KU=i63u5Xչ9Wa1Vcj85,f>4SE喸f5,7zְ 4Y Vh/ }v85-Y.ory5^ym'sU=Lf Pw]:֖! GެyHڣ5Ďy )1\7՟rL qT-=b RPzR}(sJ@R@  HzT@sJ3.\Ix5*IRI"cۚQb*SW*Y/K-$oNcD?9OJvD1T,3sLjb a֔)8:=Z8Z$ 4jxjԂN)Xw,}C=黩 $W}Xd{N1y9 @jvI}#FECأ_OgpJ̽Wx -ՁK]|yt(}GoQ=eMax{Z~j1ʬ35zVc褢(hڸnc[4G6vM/?mxUm>Gm{p|WП>sYV;y,zI>]fޕm ֨@Re!M@(QGJ-3EQE d $vk~U#[A!5# AME6w *{SCvyG_ .nHicA꛶I[դԤWlwo`^eZN+mx OjXYJjwMh+[rQNJ) \hPiIK@IK@)uJ #Kp…>񟌵R'6#S(: O~|2\?׈It7js($.u; :*ڳN A2 rzπ1jSZקοQOVJN;QR~(uXc0 o_ Zޡ]ƛr<~V1v-8[Os Sq=[/"o"CVjE%Z)3@FD>f=+E܀2I>2xM7݉%Dʋyyt2Y)\LzT]IYL֗#5D()i4iq^sޜ:;Z;sKϱQSA(3iڞ{j9;_Υ~z x殡+>si犐:sL# )XgI@cҎZ;1ÁJ)?*Qځ ێq^rSLը LjpmzkZ+Hp+:ǭe^>4&f]>zTҜ4c>@◽%?(8uQLG^iZb Q@ t֓44sS"'ސwJ!8R1 ׊R9H$8dgX.yhzzRfXK|N J `g.H>>ctiՔx5WOOIxՇmE޾𷋴Ywۻgo)ls.;%LAKIUumB/ME$_)@^h~xrp_a\&g.fvS*.D޴Rt#mA)Sٺ-gjitB!-T0\}֫,;EQvf%dju^ȹ_a{ =(V29#/l93LB*QI@#)=L-N2ix ֌`zR4SsOjBqP0}cƚ}0^jMH&4|mZnj~Q/A<sR'##:U@G4ui3ړ=zcIΗ><҃7USEҝیP<*X=^F'TVq֬e)Zƾn֥%B*unh4i@4F)sG'aJ4qGL@4ƐuzU@$SsLP(OZQi=i}C:JC.3J;n(8 B2(&)ǥ'zJ;JE/Z(qT㊛hK:i6ߦyR3%.hRA dHP{Ki9EjG>JùAv޹r4Ft4ֹO$ #Rw5^Ɯ\Jr6j׺EiC <<7I^:MN3|evG?j3UԠYmfIA5S]_]xzZ9ɉTk|Fr}O}ht"4+Tň/4pPQpʗq 9UWX/|Vk$Ghfh^_䐇?N՘\bIfJĽ@c^Rz$i~{iOM=OZ`?84֛J(sGNh 4"u杚@ j=UiJ9ZN8)q`4*R8sL"/ZԀc'* *$' >*CUb>dt :XS86}E!&h(@< O&5~N+Z1n̜V|V,4!/|RM1-%Ҍ@?QB@wi{8?&h>!iÜS~Z*j"6Բ$mz ÎjpMu IGj=1LQG(T @){)?p3A@ 4g# FiFqJ(ZOJ:րqj7n5O=a޶W5qYXW.OZ(#"|};f&8 VG!Jv=WJhY~o}?Vk4zH6GK LΨV[3ܑ7^ /H>'D'$ֵZJR?&x1Z~_z:!h)xqbThsKZ~޴q@ ҕWJP0ϵ)_Z(֝ ( ZmZ ҥ Fƀ^ؠ=LsHAzi8=*\`S4FOfoZJ@BF ֕Z`Hef̷>fD8 j,8!i=y}(hO@gbӁ@zUZ fhڭTұe~wqWoH?Zީw=i{3:h4(R~ Ӏ=h(is!ASH/9ƕ8_ʝ8H HxqiAM/'zs:JiOn Rǥ(u(t4GZ^) P!F1(44;x^);J.);qJz_أhlM J8SGN)x/ch9<=r93<=isS@ѺHM%3H͎#<^i S(4i J>y)n)94Hb )=i/ZnFESfSH:STP#J5d\HiqN49t8Q!$_xTBZ@iAڮjWұeN(z^3ECSAcj(hAN(iq(/ZxaSSސQEztm@QE7 P=}S$c4&@ z(bI3Vf)U4QIhQEHJx^ QENhh l~tgS#EwEZ;ފ(}hEAQ@:qNR8 Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/2016-01-26T154338Z_2049898807_GF20000107390_RTRMADP_3_APPLE-CHINA-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

A U.S. court has ordered Apple to unlock the phone of one of the San Bernardino shooters, sparking a massive backlash from tech companies who have filed legal briefs in support of Apple's decision to resist the decision. REUTERS/Damir Sagolj

By Jim Finkle and Dustin Volz

March 3 – Tech industry leaders including Alphabet Inc’s Google, Facebook Inc, Microsoft Corp , AT&T and more than two dozen other Internet and technology companies filed legal briefs on Thursday asking a judge to support Apple Inc in its encryption battle with the U.S. government.

The rare display of unity and support from Apple’s sometime-rivals showed the breadth of Silicon Valley’s opposition to the government’s anti-encryption effort.

Apple’s battle became public last month when the Federal Bureau of Investigation obtained a court order requiring the company to write new software and take other measures to disable passcode protection and allow access to an iPhone used by one of the shooters in the December killings in San Bernardino, California.

Apple pushed back, arguing that such a move would set a dangerous precedent and threaten customer security, and asked that the order be vacated. The clash has intensified a long-running debate over how much law enforcement and intelligence officials should be able to monitor digital communications.

Apple’s industry allies, along with several privacy advocates, filed amicus briefs – a form of comment from outside groups common in complex cases – to U.S. District Judge Sheri Pym, in Riverside, California, who had set a Thursday deadline.

Six relatives of San Bernardino attack victims on Thursday weighed in with their own amicus brief opposing Apple. Three California law enforcement groups, three federal law enforcement groups and the San Bernardino district attorney also filed in favor of the government.

The companies backing Apple largely echo the iPhone maker’s main argument, that the 1789 All Writs Act at the heart of the government’s case cannot be used to force companies to create new technology.

One amicus filing, from a group of 17 Internet companies including Twitter Inc and LinkedIn Corp, asserted that Congress has already passed laws that establish what companies could be obliged to do for the government, and that the court case amounted to an “end run” around those laws.

Apple, and some of the other briefs, did not go quite that far, but also asserted that Congress, not the courts, needed to address the issue. Congress has struggled without success for years to address law-enforcement concerns about encryption.

The victims’ families argued that Apple’s arguments were misplaced because the government had a valid warrant, and “one does not enjoy the privacy to commit a crime.” The families also asserted that Apple “routinely modifies its systems” to comply with Chinese government directives.

Apple has also advanced a free speech argument, on the grounds that computer code is a form of expression and cannot be coerced. The families pushed back against that defense: “This is the electronic equivalent of unlocking a door – no expression is involved at all,” they said.

TWO BIG COALITIONS

The tech and Internet industries largely coalesced around two filings. One includes market leaders Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Amazon.com and Cisco Systems, along with smaller, younger companies such as Mozilla, Snapchat, Slack and Dropbox.

That group noted that Congress passed the All Writs Act more than 200 years ago, and said the Justice Department’s effort to use the law to force engineers to disable security protections relies on a “boundless” interpretation of the law that is not supported by any precedent.

The brief also advanced constitutional arguments, saying the order violated free speech, the separation of power and due process.

The second industry coalition, which includes Twitter, eBay Inc and LinkedIn, contended in its filing that the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA) of 1994, along with other statutes, has already made it clear what the companies could or could not be forced to do.

CALEA requires telephone companies to allow interception of communications, but notably excludes “information service” companies from such mandates. Apple said it was rightly considered an information company in this context.

AT&T’s filing, by contrast, called for a “new legislation solution” that “applies equally to all holders of personal information,” an apparent reference to the exemption for information providers in CALEA.

Semiconductor maker Intel Corp filed a brief of its own in support of Apple.

“We believe that tech companies need to have the ability to build and design their products as needed, and that means that we can’t have the government mandating how we build and design our products,” Chris Young, senior vice president and general manager for the company’s Intel Security Group, said in an interview.

The Stanford Law School Center for Internet and Society filed a separate brief on Thursday on behalf of a group of well-known experts on iPhone security and encryption, including Charlie Miller, Dino Dai Zovi, Bruce Schneier and Jonathan Zdziarski.

Privacy advocacy groups the American Civil Liberties Union, Access Now and the Wickr Foundation filed briefs on Wednesday in support of Apple.

Salihin Kondoker, whose wife, Anies Kondoker, was injured in the San Bernardino attack, also wrote on Apple’s behalf, saying he shared the company’s fear that the software the government wants Apple to create to unlock the phone could be used to break into millions of other phones.

Law enforcement officials have said that Rizwan Farook and his wife, Tashfeen Malik, were inspired by Islamist militants when they shot and killed 14 people and wounded 22 others on Dec. 2 at a holiday party in San Bernardino. Farook and Malik were later killed in a shootout with police, and the FBI said it wants to read the data on Farook’s work phone to investigate any links with militant groups.

Earlier this week, a federal judge in Brooklyn ruled that the government had overstepped its authority by seeking similar assistance from Apple in a drug case.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment