Why the U.S. Voting System is Among the Worst

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 80 C   %# , #&')*)-0-(0%()(C   ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( " }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?-%\nԜ_Sx+ˣ;i7OМ /'KqfگAcǹ+Si+giͺ3@N^XDxۭ91RAҌc)wvϥMA9Y*1d㿯7=?gJp/q +ܫ \7U7vw}tQwAETQ@Q@Q@Q@V?|9@0J ?2(_u_mM1v{?+v./<Ś틳 =j)]܏ 9\1VFx犏oR+Hrs&9;qާe?SҝpO)xsRqӾi ^wRarqS1 { >u()= IigFjǗxO=aL.B(5h=iV Fxi1%+.GXm@CG5GV.|xDuAM85P/c? w6̩f3L.@}M۞A*}zH'` 5@ja֐gځ2ң{:FW-JsMaߚɨsS\| j :VȈ3Lp'R3FQ? g$b1zO+ѼE@pGk|_)7[I`jӋ8HTfI-{2LH˔oX8n)؁pGJ.5G.)4)J)8 r(3Ҕc;`#hzQL;#+*ǥ(JV ܹ)TsHБGi=R,m r88vB]7S*ҀIʝg]79Tg&zA< Q`iZnOҔGրAFʜ.\^arHx Ұ 4i'"8U"cJ\d!{3NYr}G0rEHMDc/4qqRQ Ozw3;u8>HH҉Yo!ky9nv15΅waVo9k80`G A$=Քѽʊ(:(((({㶫n!A1^<M+5,{2M|r!Ե)[2\JB GUYZ$.l1œbU`}'jslBIvaa$.sҘǰE513~T^OI{qa?{Pe 7 ̹Ǯ?yLw<Ԙ<>1H&gp718PXɭ+kx[]#=Táu*\I#f% ,5[L{JF7sFe8r7' J14x$FR}(MSu43ր#ۚaLOO@siM2:)pH&iP+sQg峏AN M2s֋ ztozFߥF_1j+ӁȤ/M/ɠzÞM0Hi sM2usҚG>ǟozڞtMS c뎔 P<~ ޔėQDyc;{׭ 'cf 0NWnoV*rg>~r u#<"Nq zrkB,6O4IE!97XX4n|ՒO@>IXq?ZBn0ss8>eq3>ngjr8ǭ4t1?>_t4ކ7Zi:eMHTq! sEAs" Oz{Lcdž$.nc0YGN~}T22熌 (3Ws' 4@[s^Xsc70?7I4@ %7o鄷]ߘӛy)pn^PXPcϘo)f!8]ר޹R*"sEtgM/)=W2qL(0B~z17t违;9!83s/M-')s[ځNv9`xPp(-\Օ.54jŹ7z'^|tVM} m5 j)5~/? 2_=748xn*lSsM֞jr)d589ޞ$r1N"$eHDZ9K ӁX=80GjQUsN s&( I!nܓJ .`>P}iu#ޟ8Ku<?Νgj9qQұse<@|gJcǥdCTm12Ȋ2IM#zN>P<9MFi.:K_߶G2SXSA(:X3x}>Sa0=ǽdfmG0r'e>vW)_,!ze_ڡz/voZ˿%*DVq/EU_#4ojQ!cSN9.BS zU?0t+9_4PN{ 4k#<es rO Xyr5ߏUb_(t,N\= \Z|\ S=W5N(99G? BfOzLSQI=PژOs(1Sy#=)QQc3>Q4V;aL(P4ƚHIҚH|aaBzS R(A#֚[bXctRgrĆ9%6}EZ?*4KAZW3]TWVJ#b2ZXQ^C8L ,B f5R}h/2~bkc̲}1S}@zѕ1G$Vȫ2Xc V9o*x=Tӑ] lT"N94c\x3R(F\DZ-d Ob R.9Էż8ԱFF<.+HP} 0`~'k@Z>sEi@{c4Wn:%7 .(lKcd?ox:5'd2`M8Տ}^h~Fs9o1h⥷o;T]x<⥰5h.,uwՖa9jMSD[Pͨ]r9 gz_[{rV"]̧oOnٝ6H.i.7JXƙ,Gϭiv]B!W nm'$ 9vc~=JVm?h@yXq7os.Y;KW휬X9'#+7xZ]N['+3g<{W=eMoaca[mpDm!) ]ޅkuuW[6MWq#Kak*؊SVihP!ig5xD==kv3Ι~ot'8֑0'!N?ƴ hwob_W 犷 vdWzv PB' >cu yQ *dfM4[c?&!'?Ooƭs)MӸj3hڣ5h۞)g>,U;q/IcMmSRܮ!Y~=ϰɢc-c/5n-:GOp#=$v[޴-,$?iy?ATkL2<M^Iᄯ"ee3F%K1ŘZf3zQp Ɲǔh}瑜RS*wS3o\&>j:byV(#ydcD]~SLV3A<3$1|و5[as|ߒpqp⍼pdfڊ}؜TsĜyc'ٱ^ޔbc݇HZmnGji 0N[?Zi}0J<oyC֋79Q,_8G!}:SZU*Jlr9>չl6Ȳ\=֩2$UX2/>hx^[[.}r6ݬ(ӢV["Y*o6ki?]ΉG^ڷN.6)B?wZ0Ƴ5? OZԼ2J]"[93ѣpƧjv`¬b?ֽ,<"ޱNֺV67{gW ZƉ?ins7чmṅ⸊9baGPAcao;$#fK׿ te#'OOtqi>u1E"l<6HEi}Hc;H'ӿRAzd|N[KCGN g`9յC!Do+qR)1/wp~-O[r21z8sIi'x||jF=K͋I:k}M3Zqj;*Aڐx֥6R--G09uDaNxM|O]Ix r;|YǟS6Q?uc8 u,sasZKO]H^B=hk)D }#4j JkCCWPR1FJ6ȍ9>S>OjEs*&21:Eɱk(TKRLs7t c%?/֧ iD{]'R4+ⰰuCMR_jϥEghF)#G&]+uUjA/{4 %lOҏ*brc^}_?ҷ<NiD#ڀ14Eմ 8([9׏ԟgq?[b y@ʪK_ɟ{Ac< qշp>V)prp@j6vGp1?L҉Rၘ! (85(L dP p|eD df-A36r)OR)I'bZ8Ի 贿jil=րIf֓| Oh Oy?IܜbIdU#kGyO|+G ixRH[l|Ĩ9$gM1ۆPekr$AzGjOu]^XcM{}GDs`~ kyQg*6_¶d?O֠xTf?\*.#HuXs_Ҷb(؟Wy\l(:.3,3Oi3I*#+ӸXhhDԟTAVocq#.{5񵢀L=)fYO%,ܶ;W@#ɫD61K[Idt\5Heuڟ<[n8GϽL YC굇߱&O]Fl">?`Ƙ֬7MDqovۣZ(# ~U?^42*#ִнm:q4ω3c8uw'4_dȕRˋ8HJT%oҲiijQ,΋ƒ1R,>&cH踬j,OOe9=dpxh bq-ҏұi?vp=⏉m Xk[<_7*҇?ZY~Ы˖C违Hp ԟ֮Vf]lͿ =>Lp.=ڋ[T?)>*,woLɪjn†0]%=kόhcqd uMJ[Z0DZsf4뙓ЁWQ~i)OͪSVyw'8,$ /فKxΠწlmQv б?}U ^?®jִfcuj-'Tb]"\B;);fp?œ?q¥󟺧ij cFdrx~,–7c7`'o)B jz>('JFUJas-dTfG~t~j,2Eo a8Ď{ #t? !6I:W*Ϙ߀ZF\61U?w9a~tΜ(J(ZG1>Vo``圑5o^UQs.Uav?yvC? |[^BWHEǞ\`[ojɵa*I^[+MFl *L CšQxZLiWd܄= [v9b N?6N85 T]z靠zW?Z<=}ZXiO3vZ? /SWKdb3FF@{ڕ=:SxzHŪ- Á:׸˧Z i2 ;g=WڹH Oƺ]G،q"[ F+̍)OAmmap!dc-QHBO4"cӒ)\6KDԓ@B-dMF1O)§>g4$89ߓ@QR7d+?LOX:1´VٙLcRP0Wǩl +I?¬ rWG?ZXIR7CP2E:HS%oZICDv[Rkgˏ,ߐ c" 1??jMvZgo7mz}~oh9[?oGy9g8u? Advr:<d>mǹǁ-3̇( nK1 G"9T?5_=">ncghc V(yVƘ9ջ-mBcu}.}xoi7;?:1sOZq6T,*FbvjI"!;#)*)&R> ʙ%YP|>sUy$i:f)V1JK~M"sǟ}T2@H&l*sU佘_ƚ oγ亙1L竃S0^qùfm*nQG+ 8-W|L}K}Y.]Ȋhi;dzTL3?W"S~c57*(~5R~~fURҋC85(~U]cvGNG#$*,]-.V:= ?Q^ay.ʼns^$`ǭ\Qh_NbTcڤEY>UxS{T#t=AEƵd?u:tc*W[VR @+?P8g_F5hEsPP;R؎J^ʜø5H[\w kԮ!SUoq=Z\V48Ecjm>#ʻwҩ"7&' *lRH:*ep rp:_E i K;0~҉,neSָH4qiĺx}?ƎV:7mrj[F:6>>Һ~0X<.=vW+4uH+҇[?ƎW9描ZD1 zI?uxB1EӯWIwI}TGe#9P0x%p'3b*K:S,硦uLdש!p3^p|ab hM$8xOf[(l8M}{WDiلӲGLu(Ҏf#_Q5MR#XX ЮU/2hZ3wtB>+_:hV'?Oo~1KSkheJ/2ƚTQ۪ǧ8_ c?r(7W/QU—=jsߣ:Q>IR<~ԥW 1q~SWZJ?Zsx5lj NJ?J5iuK f+)h-t i-䳓NbR\6ۺcVU˷yWV!H Gwqڽ,-bn}Jh8!eE?3 q=9G9/x_9m*I,P[m6ͷ'Ugው>5"y `0;P>{1ռgŭZr#ldub6ӁUk5 =m" Ǟ$LV~fӵpx\ּ9imd`ߧzEw[%-ī49oѾ M/guk"Hz2 gv:=]W1]ԓ@}5-mr}Jv; ^sWOgq W6Ͼ T:6Cs?>1U~*zw r2S ?iˌT;g\IS֢hWP~F;ƀ39?9Ƣd$#hzTe9H &i a7 N4žK"LƘe<}o^)M3KK3 /gIjI{Q`WݢՋ kZ =J%cV?;%H[_ Rr}MfAXS* >!}khUҴ_̵Hc6>Q׭yEO*R@3ǯzYƔ}XQJ\52|Gy>VX(P?CYj3KsmŒf5.s@ǔ]͒Ed]،KRY/CuR_g[J߀Ҹz͞.r)- rx$5VOGԲڎp8Yg=AewoT}vSɈx-жZv,.ޙ*vDϫ~fX}JD]콍ЅC#?z&Ϳ!5iuTodr8JvDK%̼NZM *QZN8i14=i9~{`K*})r'_KO3L,$cwuI#IiUB/R4y~զmN:SVГ4SRIqLK}n+me.2  KG4>VeR Js>6U?g>j8?{5֭"'֦tX\A"lWУr#"9 ?S]?М?#\_ B'ȵbgA{Ws[S;=7&</BU钡KAEr0*uj֎S? յ;Ӆ@`}ӎ-Gi[mPrhQj08ǽN-4 !ksU ,eWZ5] o(ob z:]@-=:m#X9X z Tsog.[)\f."*}Mw9Sd@9DY]·}G^O-9+|+m^H#ΗooKeSg~O'k8-$YV zk x> 1yQ"+wۯYv@OGZE]^ŨFwVN>N5b]upnr3ʹ-e7ι+6j卤PHR3ۑ?#r? iwk: %,$dذ.UBO:=4Ey# q드Gծ3_5|r-'h$Y :MUŮflbR8Q6g[+e`D{WirW1ܨlcGԋqn39Ԑ?ƽi7xc*Dͭ*#Ɩ8󄑔veiumɒ9X>3^t[+k]* t{8q‹P4 ;HeRQa?ei2T:{צxGFJ 7ix/CiQL?֟ZNQIDpu_Q??hĚo<e^~yM_` )FcNt~=O Ug5^({%Ǩ/?JroQ93.~Ux?v _*l=cS[wDO+$ZgInd0[5xwK(l|xAWe`*, 仌gfWmf+x]v;|HdTd~{VG'Y\{_*JQSvMm:U??in<\/|7k78\ܫ7 N妀$R[ {W." rcqz(J)+0@BF/ȫR\gXڐ_Au fF0ğZ.m:EQ05vMԃ}꜕yoh? ]{ǻW)aנż8CMo/?Ǹ,N.᷌MSlUsK2t:(ZZ;$!kq{E3X]v@.$V 6k%:Z@ׂ"@Wb1T -yH'J_JmFZzSpNQՒkl@)u۽.ncW$WsR'9m.luIՆ[vT.*\u$ԡT?·_ZsJ|"Je$/ӅzZ-z r9Tg=&p;SVpCE˅bJj$2clc}z~6W#ڟ%. SACqVbSEU i7[בS_ >$k{ee|)-mqZA>Z2&pV E  l t%wa7er]>)"QN 23NSPK{d.׳[6bݹ9-9gvl爛91$=I'nv1cEma<M!Tg"ϑx=w/ٮk.lEHlmRf, ?s'Kjzuš/!ϸ^IOxnMvTK xLiU T2n2@`q]W{m:2-a/a^ ]NI `ի|m2[U$F _i)cd PrG,p{Zاbٻ\bWv+F '6Qq2,*טPe=NBdG\/%4 BHXI2\cQLiߕ0(VE*6ҴLqpߕ4ƞR ?QgZ%#bϧ),gF{UgQ}Jw)D/ZvrE[BM*5J6qN)t[mߕ@F[bCok)V$@p7b1T +rNX܊3DtkcVchu.=&8PYy mK7dVuyyFk{!gHR4aSR'2Qk>1} g8$;wu}WX|A8ϭ;>լ[4bF]Hӏ*Ȟ#8 #5y~Ub-q@tAW]ѭ_s?Ns~JZjAonVW }kk6ǥ@ .L) 8qSTY2hv234 kFay#,qҷxCςO^kz(?cJIpymR[IS!6o'?zeSӛI>&%q):jwV8Odn+׀T_[ 1cr EYǁ5Mc_4:}vc7grTvg\t-`"Dy6;N H$\$~k ^h/n}*mIrfy);*zğoR~,m\/ NbS=" d3?|YA$h5oxJ=LjLm63g;Wy{ r~WT@@}OQm já |NxvծiKN~Ŀx?&fفkOdr2iE`&ބ?-m}4C;={P7CU.hn?•)xG7P:q'F0:}WbH׏Wkwv}[TN=+Vo?O_Mq? c/&qwB{Tc:q|g[ gk=\gl^q y.n:=bvC?SOLyag!>(+VC?XA-l\?.3`?ƹ7W$:d>ޫK[ĥ֟$??!1?\I97(bQ*[["޻~L\['M' w,tj ?Kui/]]s{I{;.ZJIIX5aQ^:mѷ&P PnlQ'E`?Uczj:&qi|Z2N T֘uÁK;Qʊ=GF~ž&[GO:-t9?.r`os+G IrW69Rq]'esj-e)WY}$+Jf'PG9Ho2~xIs>1ּ'z,U,0>9HO^ 5uҊ̜_H{s 2hf2}''p=/IRt|E>O?߭;7y~WH0-4']j~'-lH즐叭xhҺ߅>'OկW&[q 9e :|5/A%'OW4fC>I6Mug[i|IUh~B~ kо1^\h{hJZD=I'5aoԘbT*U3<Oq<.Y%v_)̢V)˗PL7ZMk[Hp@UPH "#9"ե(m D`sN➵:dA422" ~:;;O_]z۹W>r,sDc1%䊪LKexmAj]3‰jZy2ݾ]'qْ 9 q^H>.귧PL_P}㡈,cb>_ԓO\ipy{l3B;Cu}pis׷gNNo里匟i$P~O.BQ޵^SC49 'ۥxIw}& C@kqv/Tɫ%֭#MCnLFG^;TbtQ-:|w"㇋𯃧8V@$8'# Wo;k8q{?.S mgאW(eSgoEo#?I<}kj%N7ќ`hO%"H9x4֐ t. m#ӥp/إgi'2Fq.:gҹQT0ҙHOt\Y!3 VN=2>+ha'Q^1TiNVgj~.kg˓?:_*-:y%dvSGI4~e׷ŭs|I{kǠ[l~nq=@5OHѯ?\NcX֧Qy?w-mgt'\)Y0 PGO*6ܿ-` 4%4iBsRo^Aק|w4eF \ s|Wi|C&xml4)s]@c_z|Fؙ4=GEźqJ%шr?Q?vCeI^/휞Ix]Cj0aCEq"b(RvUeR:JƵ?ܟ]4UO?_'\xG^R:eT^»>[ ~m-md߹?}h rO.߰I :vG?K5_װֶ̎xiO.޹>:_'\D|Tˤ\2+m >s~ޓ벼zn댏z_םiZI3l׭~QPu;"uEqI^QqҨNW5ml>%\`Fz1i*ПU$uCM+7'=;׻lB&OW7Jї#cX2յ]_ķ',\秥ZƱB8{A 1\}z{Ug A_Uv*xi08Ҕr=(Hoz?g'Q7}{YO.2r}@L-w5o@i-YV_E{ Enۉ"'߂ja_>`6h.( 3dm]~ΐϦ cY6oйxJi:g."G %X#dXW>q)GjJuʯb'V?O09LO+^azo.N} 5eo:Gh1zcӿtx :t~*)-'deMhfqM*5\qȱſ𮳪2m@Nrj0U'hGPs0.҈8=LR)+JZ)-^BCc`QT R|V7o:\^]W#+#I]T^m"1N8̪GS΍s wjb)OYI s1#(g?g֬i^Lw9 ?5&rDj\ʋ&xVhAp0s~g]OLo"$S~UL)у*E}Rjӥ'gkIPO+º[8?XN !8o~}zuZZ5X\@&&>W2 5IKE_.jM뵬W3\ ֭k:XsPWooRN`0 spWsڝ+nvL/rʬĜcViؓ$1 g5 f<$nZxtN ާV \dVRA]U%pƾռ9v".Uq5M*`קԨexu ؇?S?էƦrB֤UP[O-^98*-Tnb\]4%g$17?ƺc汸X*'҈?5SiYRǺK)siI9C_O!ɉ~va %[ R(G=NNN:?.#iԟu7"⎝3NV#UnGaw΋Y:r}ӾxqG-Fn=v+8_ȥE{]j{Wn%R; $U\ۨE5MccCeuZo*#"xpqu{W|:Sj5-_J-.'Prc21#9`9zom{M|>0֛T+2A9dwcJ,#ű㰭cRJJ7tƵm:B A֩.F>jy (u e@''NjQ&q6xˈFoltۛ{1.$k]ymi)=n_ H.`^D!Z-H\6+nd÷Yf'ޯVexGL\vU0?|qT&y8E)Z zIu>fm6,H,YMRi[M}Ntmɦtn:(F`y$^KqNOE* KxBDg.8Xmuʌ:Zo11\x.:΂B8\v'^"M;γ~-NYnUr?YO_{ݣt{;Y3>EdG"]2r>&}CK ޟpeŻP @U .REhfƘWt{ORw#>dr0rmFK&{T1B ~ ծ-{m:d lt=vwJ,6+˜Fyُ#0e'H#eB:TX6#r~ԥ)|NO1}#0>Pss+?vCT B8LjƱ@gli[? 0篃Z~&EqTKɕGp+<jϊeźcU-݉Z ȃAF0լs?T/Y kӥ[,+~%)np"ʪ;ֵ?RV0_Bo- kKRFT$=M{Me6xYGڣ7R> 1׎|H|[G>lᣛ|ªuǭ}E[x@F1VX*S^ӹ8/5_ʐĒ aFӟlΰ~"j׭/_ Z98#Wd?s?~ d=E%f||8&%`\}stOW|H@'w#VOĹÎ4qw9T'",zQTQuQ43%m&,`Pq*VtXgZQؽ8`T?;Qda=*}ES)k]s'<ǍK[')qq<%Rݱr2dq >Gء8Kw֧ +7bԱ+nl*{rnUD>^0>1+y£VlR]фR,J[+WL{BScZ-ߐIbH.YuZ)Sm3Jueٝ.r-v?iX&bs q.-eFz v#zڼWMĭkǭX9/?;NN1m(Bw`< %)&֪1}EwTI$FTdM{g3O?{7G^'FLxkY'Q`gW7B94Sƶ 4 TL3kI[VeV'gξLv u l?U%6dgN)O4>K>Y%qWQ\ )y¼J:tj%`(2ſWS|h|+Ӌj_}i6]m3 bP_>Յ 9WeFp*oj$h,rH85sv>ԢraW6&Hۼ[xE W`:q'8/Z$^QUy-Pi$^?|{yW^#S^!ԼAWf!R-t-U3p.qex{?iˢ`K<ӼW\?<)ܽDqbŝ k=s]f&Mpu7zPds&wZI= vdnDeo[%f *H< .>'QLTdX9c`1;OS\GÛu|s 7cd:o'n:6t?u('#&9|/h;Wl3-r9ޥ|qk^KH#8fڽߋ!3qe+&o?JM$Ռs:cdtǨq !IK<<*vz_άyO[k>$oML x23'}kY¾eA!c|L=VėQ$H ]c]_gI$$yT;V/uLT}鿖b߅5+-ctNzș!?Ky,p[ǽu`9Q 9Qګ?Wr:3 }=dq<#e}D8w̖ O $'ƦpNj,CGÒدo)Zա`GyɬTq 9 MGym"i4٢`A킾LgƥŤ]2, #KԮV]8lcJs$_sJppK2!Sᘦ|t.cx,޸ZS'Y#=r #L@)('qC5$ I-Km_>8O]"9eВSFw|#| >OxGϵYœzW|09 \yұ>iG"OJ>k1KGO;P+֧|go[-JDf(um,@dS EQ {t7RYiw9)EG *q<%j$i-ğ ]kŚw_K8E2<@ztiZ$,V<Ě4)9:Ʋ)nǼR[78=i1kS~-v1 iEyGkQ;Ȍ 3 $;ww;bN1[TM[V󆽧Z%IR !~mLo#؁_bYİΫ _<|bӒ5Xe*zx?u+ŕOrcR󿮇VYI~.r/?F99<տ1%O9SoDvz?]9WM?#=p:N>(MfNOOzMj;kH{W|7g/#O\J^Iй)iB_8VJlWОM|㧾tx<3`233^u?ꉹEB榜BG8[ثQ\SkG 43emBGrx;@7g}έj-6c;'`qsb ;վ Vq%IۤH tǽ}Oup3t˿ll/G]ԑaUncܑ}\V#6b3Z=SPRYeE<\d=+ GsJ/䂾i.GMO/OOģ%+/-)>_y:+~x, tџnM d~'V_<]a5LFF=Wk;:^ b`q)̼'_Mu!-CѯEdx`ykXHR{jS+8cBP־}:ܸXۘT |ᘚ[˔!E\@_|{Z)JOf.bLAf ί*`dΧvk>\j6ZwlF; yKxמdגɼ9vf3sF~Oi;TSor攱[1JOm 6 H @1GhccOMy[MI$9/J1M'%_QB3 㞱x}K_C5W쩂wc8l3gk_Ç/G|mֳJ]_l.8c^oms\ ][|Wy`a-|)u2Ŀ|<=jI?\閍ӆʼA8#e D׬'z$2$}8R'p-הt]Boia|iڏrSvKO|0d/ٔJzgWx^gN#('tb|y)? z~\)n(mPgɹ纎:p|hڣ=OE0+Hcޕ EYɁ@$3Ydȍ$?*,3c}JDW3fAMp5g8'xZ6W^9k$ Y0y?q' sM^}6)UIT!q߫dn >yIy3Q1~kS!cLbθ9jKE98^Ն3?b׸[m6HI?&nꞇϖ]O_cǞ%ѭ_^hOa~ǏJ'?jr؏-&#I5Û‹`Hdrs_,[ Moч\M/ý-a' H z8I/36Q6NZb.e Vmci,ZqCvߗZºY'}0tnwn?J5r'A8ޚ~>UI:OΎ{{fF+̒:zp?nzl.g%IYz}Aoih5$0D, ;?,`qg*n:ƢD~<h2Eg3|-$: ޻s/]tw011μnmiGg]]7#Ӭ,eH#%QyvBɦy5 g >5s]t,q`O:݇z:Md*;+QZKHṛ)~Fv8K!6vG\7xlI{ivRGuu*>nf=U&sØQstFRBbG :[Z[?H 󬱴6Ydo'Q-kN2잽o+es*̫PH,0yǿcӼMnCȾq 8R|鑕($r3'|2ky2}zָvzoZrlKD"-p'^dc JTޞԳ_AR2Xlx,F`4YMR[O72>HxN>z @{ǖr˴.r;ڔۦ[5niYO+q>I^ğSm<{p=-WB6+^>';^IIu3*͈a)vj 8$3LK1 R[;B!ZW3sg/i-UeeXBkm5; [c=\Iy!Nc_ځ0沝v7?Rߕ;pS|NǙ?rTp=yGbxr:- =7 ꏏ¹^[Ҭ_8Au?m]֒1 3` z?@5-zx$i#7ۢVQrr?퉮9d}e&YYtrk \F1A*~KWbi#8=>9ڳ5_hBΉ7a5[CQ2GĒ f'4/ O9m$!Fkj[g t4̶[xp^b=:O՞JTJs̕zcxv1T?(#2HTC%cySi&]N|AtLMo=ӺIܬ AݎLLgcԠYHH uz?MGHNy*$XX nxL՘+-k=VNk ?pO;^f}-gj:&}p%: '<_hKg;]W-"峢 v3_=^4 e`l$cɯ?kX,"H$ӇlP{{8/wgh?.K]#OA6 c;\S%Ɲ=ir^8; W[ݿS `pe "|מEw,$$zG)2 5|1f֖HQV+qF&v%T$g<9K;G{vӧ[*1Mo.˗: (  nnj82iB7BΘxwBn.s hv89QXauL} :-y?SѤv#LOҜ$=͈yF#=tō0FH_.ÄR3} t@=dlE&+EMoOt:6|/p-aȕ!>[W13*̛rOϧ}8*0=5y׹7>pOεGbQ/>*H}oKQ>+3;j32wLX:4Pʰ9tQq M-Ptsξ8ͷfzeq# }ӼS]iGmq 0xFOsuiZܜ\GlQ"^E}?g_glnE#xy?EɾBUKLz&V+!Y~xUGZJ h Xc^F:?k듧a8nh? |7kַZR}עkcUI8;IKFa^ZɱYdAoXڃ}'IQAy:um~r=M'kb$IwFV>4Z G [EIҼ]Xm.n- ;#W+Oi[Z% Jz޺r)`O>qɎ澐@W<~voP=!im&OOH-b;4vN޾jmbAcĒfF+!f4븚9+ >+Zā\(\ GV"tdϜ$Hu}Z8V9Xq] V֎aUZ?+gjh_-KD^>$Az38G+u;[oV_RACGqD((B G q]*zul1mȐ#ɛ]L?U'\7Nv oi59Up5R԰J6(}V~Hdo^;ƺ?ZSs uy)ch)4wyW~ wK=$HI)VgLv;i^.U w\d>:v_C.[F.J!pۏƽ_[/Lt/:v@0}ȭinM5tm\YZ3.E$w9EQ*,dS=R|C#xSBJxBNݫ|D.tI$pKPr\m;_N#@*̈́}Mk320th`TGOJ=},K}vIod\3y,02G= 5΋z)ky>€J7 cWܵIR Z]/-(z*MkIN epO%(@e>3=kgRg}$=j`.UV(S0MQPVQsTZ/ص/40B̢G\NMΙs yUdG,T0 y*Xt,ȊtƖ{nIe[T ]xjI[NjZ swT~OÙ.bsjunל&2`RQ.L z' g\%S"cاA"Za1׊|+ .)8C-q>St'f:LVEM{?>VlԢhpc)Ա_Iw=W,I5| 7݈6q0!Jg9Z/psҲqG#}v|~{GZ7q2O$ӦTd!ۓ- RBy:õesO7w`mOP7S/{6Ij?_$q)aݚX'᭹Su ƒϩk4ג^c8Ԝhumq#|&;NWp:%d%+U S\2?EZ; BiBcSQs}>Z_xVk>Uvqӟt<-b6Tݱ6VcbXgZeߙh]ċQw]iv1ۛPH%"A=Vj0V胓N:Q^_'#F$umEn"B1%YUel)ݖVSIni7lcҚs#&x5|.fv,JH j@(ɪ4Uj>Ԃ ݋s\qXW bp׆txcdPI)t?g]y1>A*jŬb'QO"sT,mj'99?!0\?zBj9|%8x0|XTg}i ;PRI̭_ʠkͣqvxiU/F~ٽu&Y]q8H~qX@y{ReοɽoZϿ$9b}K1qoӏ$idMKor1,q!y(k>!/|eK#;2` Q\b$s#ym&0d=~-,#?%pp+SڢnXTf9eqqHVmbX5cJW#_Ң}G5R?։= ✃9bm;!/+]ixDW{oƴW_WÜ٘!c&f߆i~ + oj5ȐU?72G*R)-l6N)Ǡ l=k5=-~ ^Un湑K  ybװmff zN:;ӆMi:~)Ӭ]-3QvLyomH&$fB?4&v :Yh,js֧c߬#9j_j6~ ėC(r)Foمχԧo+2|1`u)a[sHU\h$Uo>yr;G tlէ#T08>U‰L;vfӬoHb2k١.hZ隅,R跗-1OmN2)#nC_c+UqY$9J?0dV"ԯ0-Ab@\#^>zޝ}yyddnv:v8\6uࠪw]rמx7^Ӵx-n|SlinYV0!#20kY!IS5-+P&ԓD)M!b44 nO1A84 ~"h?TTVXKfJJrFc?jqGs zgp;q+hI-]shY~9Ǹ"~MeZ;?cxBQi+_J//#ܬF|)!>P vlzD?b[x*66B>WOԣ܏h϶/l6wvR+#Vq_ 䪤 /ʢI܌Wp#w`Gt=7Nҥψdoئ̏i냂Wnsg_{R{e=7WJшaz+񏇵biڽvcy>?:?[LxɅ#O#sXB<ЩFPvEAw#㕴aԓrSRۗL3 ^_fq8H7>e`pO[F.|1&F^H\Hb?Z,*^ jٍo8?Vx\wVՌp4!`HoUPF-Tl{ؙ`]o=^@r ~~? i Յq n\64=qO]1/6X.?%@[nnOU;Ѕ,Ӂfv<" RlJq+F?Κ1|l>;xB[4?AWj7bzH~oμd .';YzlI>٫%q-#5x9Ikr3)E{;NiEJfR*D8f`zOjhxn]vQȻӤ17f~<]пhqZ[sU %tQ/QV͜җQ]gMz(WXZC䂹xۘc`n%vA\( }Qϰz;5xQPMK*i'4ݢF*@h}g js趗cORp=25F?,;nѫRekXpoto]y{m?iF`BBʅO[n3^ש9KC#l`qS5okcx-|:e긒E&.3=͔^n.,YT#7q22+z_ .Am߼~P { RLp6ԂTA#aI'nDrNhэ2 =OA܊<ŠF ?OJ摰b%=}VGRLc VKD.݉*^TzrZcgf4g&P?ݶc%zUK _ '`\.|P9?$Vҵlc%3V nO222QG(]1.?O./#brI9ɭJZܙ \QG9ǿ=,{ HI1.Z~Mqzh^ނ6#m='&mHl3a k>3ΗʎC_^&k~9}\ g 2NWdj$M&G%j>45iʽ8<{wOr޽Z|qizk^i-%1c}9ǥtğKocj$\<@6e\n¹O+p4 h$ [<Ӟ*36J&VxKŏZ%[ϲnUPG gwy,+XEx2*Kc`tǠMwݴJd9N?gUe⏄+&kP2N}Um\'{O$ESۍ}q"=fVరZr;ՉbH漈2BHb8t 561ktϳRXl:)x%xV#Tb_V0'>CVuOBm|s3Fe]VQI'TxcQyG]@`kcd;Aӊ- ׏0A8T-eᏅ{1ky71sW EtQ&hnlP` z<ʼAi܅}o·čkr!R>^6li)+/4Ìyb⻭5$uK a/#UC>sW:)XZT*f|I@мq^p#888V+o77 \eycT!CjTynZX߄}2m<:τ=S>tIU`͟΢Xڒ[MIJ~Z57.b;~Bw,#y9I\V^Cj1X ǸݏƳq>)_)Ht6Mg* ܽx:?JvElu8I}BqXۙ?7wFqۚߍOS=)]G5g֠w>Gҩf&)lb!.@'4队^3Wsr8@|l?Jo֔޶&Gw15ݘM廽FVL).v'+Ce`Qf]HCy {w~Zj~7n-|GeJGɇIt`5>xbReF #xN8&ZNK$>9!lT$X) =+uz>0N%tsC Pz0!#}^*a+q 3 GZ[m>f>dM p0ż@`; {ԩN\n%+lw]kYx9K^'n <׏Zi>;j ,nI M*/r`%`Վ 0[?xni|N|fʾo)H}j%\VVY]Y[Z8tFújaizr?ReQXIGa%*׈M7W:3mmj}Úƶ|cc|̑; G51;*6OZhew8NIՖJ4I_&5c’yz*x~<6"6J?X2yK[r- Jx9N%hxΣqPTv=3-,Y6?%y9l'?ψ]>TfuTxݨ[hΡ5kI]ڝ(د뻃Ƴץ\;br|?. }zVL.0>{oj*BzJqM π7agC^//^?ӏ>edW[3[v_]L2{(`sNSJ:3g;p>퍌'k5{w^1ɖg̚߂x𧎵s`CۉBrsGQu49鱞s?Ы^#&zΗinxě OWyF?|D]99T5f0(N/j?jW4r$:gb,p1R,F;zwa*go̾*C"Pܛer :jmᛃڨZY]>x5}&^S" d 5_IMyin_jJ=nVD{9} ,d>~7W' W|@!#;;*?u9_]d6GՍbFr*nYjm݆=3ZCsl,ң4 Gu(nc;h@dc@[H#\6ҹgw! JIO\z~tkΟj+Pkvk[IWޭ/P0E&;ϧ|F̨nUaBGrzנlw4H5*Sik4/|O8M?oD@=Fg| iЎ;HXC[~(p=XkOus z"oMikWG/)ODYHzOK{yn(>g3Ds I _úwk,3Wڞ/qiz*f)՝)^hOc+\0$eAhҷ$tkϸ.3Yׅ0uڤMolqjEPoNy}|7h=pGR[uȘ^j UAo*9SuM*zZN41J w/S&zeq5Avd1# y8C[$(iz#=ep>?8:>+-͑ԙc3ĿrE;H=Xk[#U< k& $`4g%;>?ޫ,?_Y3&v)1x֦sZWO$ީT1͏z=L)9M/< `\9@O%?4 cHt:4ۡql?QYDqZj| 51MOGH5\{a76?@+·8D~˦_LkF*3}8NsCRڒ`cTs*拕1S͹9.}ةܽ%Mb[Oj1ʼ{1Ԟ]lk2| z-bJSc{|4{4gXMz["T/e^RORIt,~W-$ sGx$kl!HNԁk&5p5N|/'8 8qN)qEkYq)Vx1R%C:2x)>!?-Q`6~lF<\}*›e1R?ֺ/Ʊj~,TiALgV|T%fVυoaKlqȬbKq$Q߭9G"o>і &pyZ-qV߂qxwVUÜ$wQgr׋O"Ix> +訜}1I!U{ιBVF0?EulCX`A?{J`q U")~΂BȝsV5 eA{A;VT;#շԚ[u,vR`~ML]Kx#AAz}Ċs:`<[ |ώG,FQv"w8\7\|w\ f+H+uoRp˜|R'dI)ȱ^7~̷{/^ڽ'|A`OZ\ Mj )?'ZO9ABaⓞֲ5AsgF?+|E$ZuF)OZ6BJڽ+.x<6aߧ,iSnK{TGA&#-Zr>k':W!VgP8})1i˷#95[U槓''.?D?:3*pQ ju8FEB=B?]S= _ O٧c\߁1<^u&/jOI^t+Dh{CV/ &q\9??e{4/!OW'֦A o>owUK<;3Ջ1KsZ8W'-.$5E"\iwy6z!r%t7xkb1uKftq^9 7qI"C(G; W=ȼAO i Դg?2 x]O"S<>Rn-K"R9ѣsA%>3__)`ᶒx&1]Q3kS_$6NxϙD[b-N98bPB"Y`q(1ʅgo 3 RޡulH**oKEׄn-`f~fE>cZmwxJ^eSYP䌶qʺj\#G^4א3̡yv]ٮJ)4"Z/?֏W\RRtxdˬpAh_GU$KL}D3~uٚn~DǨxהC|WDt;XJ$F˴0$rHګ^1|;Q`tX-mEy@dBßީQm+=AFﯭ,{\t,ʰol4g+/Mwٓ}}=j[_H d Ǡk>;f ~SVS4U]l"7cyDf2g(OܔUOSdYOod@0$*YwEXkbkP=*Q 1x=np*r7XG;ⳖB>Y#q܊[L4 yVqO:dJpQо~̀M,VM=Wҭ٩ZZLdRyza낦~ى~ i+!-0[c 11\@Z3g5)6?+'.sIqWt"EQ#]l/OL\݅G|ԃ'c\z'Y `VFu98ԥƷz?驪>է5ۮޏ .u~#A8JZ_e8k')|Gyg/x@8(#MRL #f#v|?Y2)%qLݟt03Bkc>:š9~Ǧ}^X?oK1W:b=#]3obgⶴ[Vo,In5@8MANE98₺AIAy~@^Q5fABބD4ʻpk.Ċ}$kI(״|b]J[uߨy7C*%O)ħ:6e'<]@^)+R-a\qλŊA#ڑ2rWeSV$AIpqjĜ}*4%Rz sTH*D!p Z!'k߀t/F->7Ϣ@ݔf8nv ?mWkB^ uoҼk~1z^xn# r?yfBq@Suu[ v!5o *zq7hcVVI$`|NjikW٤Uf?q8z4=Q_5LQF~^ƿh*鰾E6#s q5uJ@ zR;Pm7]6zō\:ޯM;jcOu 2m>P "U m+n4]jǕf}O@A#ߊ!E\j;xL0x;$h&%M7<嘂IIiXq0TFo` b!Z>*/-nl _{ğHk N覍dCd~cU`~\I'l'li&. SZoOԞ1BZh&M+S\z|Dco6T׹)p+F+{e+~zV4 ;(V y-lMԊ]0 <$<\A߷KmeѝGDkm"R vIQf]z+l8c_Ro% n>**x_i^}ߥÛ,<x$~xAZgpHVQ)bUޣΈa~ieTsڵm4 4R!wkXV4 ɯKw [<' ~5cYʪe'g_S״Q{ϙSꇾ[qj:Kd`CǞĩ }]յ6ۋ_(9(D)VP?Y-i贶U*yEg.͎#⁆m5$F,aH²gɯدm9 $c ;I #B*b-2C@}G"%AJ:9hDŽs;V_60uVczDRAun=+q%f2k-yjG0L*υ.q\Vo|@cZQՉKܱ#*& 2}u$^!޽i?!!]-!Qfw0}|;qQ$E,nx+ijl23xn`>W$+To*qJo})4]r/i$(aG'TWӮE2ĩ+ݻA¸FΣ1[yv\/XwZlm!v;gp4i0.#VȊ^<2Q{̈u(gWěWqOj12 -\u U]tyܻ]DեQ(_tGN ! IKL 7 *7`zqw8`iel-XFq$.?Gz=i8KX%QKE@њSHiFsT9@3LcI?4b(0\e$M--pq R^o'Jgb[~q7OIQ$"n@9#;Tm|iiZuVɶ8r$ N䂽&t$9o}{7ֱu%dbIUqX1K: u=]EbHˬ_]15H f*׈:? -#\gY˜7S*r6D g3sR n8ԙȤnL84ޙj%EمX@ erx+կޟs`JP%cy|%9ht{~2 `5rce(n'm(̠=\ԭ":Z~ W)iV!KAlYd, ۞ϧz9g̐Ɂ75h%Սȇo}Dj:2-]#WTid6?W4V\ 4v6y4ID k670S$t&z&oyf=,b]Yb8`N2:K)-IRL2 %\Žž<>멩4h/2FpW(cZ?5gT(Y鮫ĺ]|1i/aC|m$sV+xBT#·NeuE>[MIYx61⦛9df?N> nZ6Sx|u•;#|?iٙ ı #+:_|W{6"R=s E7j'<e<:{9.E֩u0?{bC--8 X^]&9:# 4gTEhbu-[BXo'xq_>Ѽh0j- Xl|Ayu{y 1"g8 gҵG&27OO9\#kd t+Z?3 ?mYxBڵ _`6촛H? nڗM? [ ͆?;].x_!dm(~5Nox_Mu_d)454VGqpBpK1/nN[_COgtQ YPZ7֘?Ɯ&qK IOaTqq͸+]0ܱW| 6r3BQO ~z04ԛbfT 9O0 n?]|hU $s~?cScdҿ>xo8"N͸˱=x*VyJF7cұu)VCή E^WfQ$Y88j*]rޱ{#aFGlH*0qƬBwN!I4_g99Laqr?`RƤOwn~]VעInUebڣ5{]cI&W.@=jĻ/t[ϱN6("L`#^s euM@OO;г?Z7fwүËքHB2Fz/] #70֫5..r끞WuAC$zv2KlTgѵxXs8S佽RNxa)X٘U|ҹjѬa9#q45u Jd,vT?tl";ĎN0pqۚmQV ^ɬ-&sUe>>Uc70rpz]ߺsY ie$*1u+ް5_)K|c Q}2!>_̀NN? ~'isj^ a 0JwُOjm[хijg%ưU> e*OKWM-ơ,wc?JmcǩZxuyo`*ϙؒ{l{yEC$M!ܤ`p{VݎX`&d픇O³<&;R= Vk-sTv{mp5 j*#+ӼsNuּ@ ٜQ\\ˏ";l㈩2ts1%(0IھǺ|eZ)t[?3T+jeӏFiy;Ws7JG^=/]iͥ L3cWccK??cGCNl^tJƐ|S~wiK֣D=GSLc?jZYo3$LGng iO(ix&1Ǩw;JѪ@g{h.foc\N2Jhcmg>v gj529 zo%m'2 q"Ty 1U'韡ᇕ>{6[~T^Z@3&$WOOVXdBy#9¦Xڊ^ClgbI`PH{ų ,2KƸfcߜ`z֮H ؎(qIyJНj]pD  ,vܠzJ[ۈź~Uc8 SUR$G{l!AY4; o'Ў^sE"PcV?@jKN{ q#O3gE1>vH<р: ?2_3lyP?1ǰ^{Y.baG?呮,|?O^!8MOy=9$ 9 ,FL?OM@=\o TU[i@1 d`sϧӞ'-nۋ yw\mSKU ?,3XRW_~+¡$@hňhSϭ5zDg v.v{|S9 01n.H@\-0+q!#QSŶ ?}x`{3j 5~+XKEg7;>7ד0F p5zx'n:gTMiȻZUrXYIְFiMgY{ԶOB1 s#YuAjgzajMڦPɴ`~K㻹Ge{s[\Ƚy`y(l kR+-vd"T.eV@$j-OOc4m +9=ǽaB̤qy&xQz^'RH}GFTȤc>᫂B RJ_ _U xI\ ;_;s.4Qr8#gOR$ц@ӧ==Zj+wAkvsŴdOۀY rTeoߥtIt~=2~%UAmKPM zCy_E?7PjSĠ6z?\>VKp!!(Usߓ׹b}4|ۈϬj7i%rGRs o\ޥsTCM +2zr?Z5R3I+g?jMe;#Pw.{ջ1oQ8VidOl ~03SVz-̏he<Wu; ɻo? ”uj#<?$,*'qK+q[-vlxSHleԜ*'ƥf$Q2ɂU# y*S cgu8`{ji Ry%EIX!~kw[wO2 C?1~1@<{ӯ-Z;dGِ 0kIqZe݊r[T\Ȁgs S[3I%,w3v7sO$^Pxٕ8u' Bvz۟^&P,7*6̶pOq"HvWG5)!+.:a 'sZyL`89pl`r55GY$L/t?\煬lpvB[xwV&$4r} igOBJq|E{cR'BGc LW:0#>É+}}8S Av$ .t3¯~]= I*\.¼ը1ඛ30>rUW?Hd=^`1^OslM‘QUwf ?ƛ@4bc2jcH&g ?QT̲l㧥sֆ=VL8U j\y( 9?T.YF2;$9]Wɢ6 h{!ONՇ_H&%IZiq56>`\{GjԎMU{%#=ǹs7N AzImWi=?2}6l݃ d$tuJ,_h!a ?ON{ sF8UbwubpOsH;.ފVVijgP;T*{uӯAުʸ=Tri;:} \7ɾD*pBdp~(I!nTYYLXX8hO/,|zzin9aqqHzn]ghG}>Jzy.ka,k};cy!I9$+m>) 1A9I=t4d/x#d0#О7-@=`9meO>1ǧҢ跳nsO)ijwpy z89.ɪxKgKjXg^j6eDز`$ *[i~#'VBH=1ۮYŋw3-4 x$6sN7PʤPȬ3gsdhnɆAߟFHȸwNyq-qWKe osx8QyEs 0`*]1!3x>z),A.〼phH9UL*x-›vBFgXԪc1 {r 9v>hvAvϒD,oEY`~UB#,$UFOn~~C;>v\ 8 QO-Wʆ5xE}OPpVF%esөױEU7TOȦ0r~ELsס$n석4H2d@IXkhtMѹu,F2H=`  F|B篻_ҤMY.f%c|3gRj*kWQ.Q3@|'Pٖ^f\4*qX۝9=CbLY77aU@͐p8?+Y(,I>ޟ~oJ}:=jk kRp?^ `kjG%_+8!V4a,S~199_P{ݢlH;tQhݖDzU`F yciYTz%cKb-|F?ʤZ"x{k/H௯ҹ\MT8%0_C?* KD}&-߄!M1($5k R(&يp3:/wKa8#鶱$X'@*~n}q۟3p:+)I"T'w_֒;%)-3֫:iF?SP}lz+.D0D#[9rP|_d~^Z'yrjդeI.#qn֨1.Kalv_scˑ[fAEUlӚ<ņFWp>RE%7:'w.YU2&szmgI.MYR;I!7\m_ӜxYjq[e$9O,)sn 5i#P#?O6[hòtr1\V;x$[kV9ZcxOV5]#j3fsZ>lܻBY䃓M/A^&r\JĜs<k"NdZ9lEv*]BE47F<=C:Ƒ=$]&2eQcc59Cxu?Ҿ4olVhe\ьPk :y-ܼy*J>X*=ם+]YEĖLRK2~m=B̚2\LGa 6:=Xlf\x cyJ`c 5ݾ?oڜDQ옹lRH1¦yNzb?Ҿl7Nԝؖj=sCMҳ&㔞T/tI}58]0Fh\ǷGgi&r=[?ҒK{vNlxylc|ۿ?H&9ff{L۠8V{Hgd@zl^]E}Qj|W0 _sʷq_5y+lRwp=k8<qq%Y RgQ\%,N9{W2^=b5mϲ,Bg+OJm4K#d S=ϸSD9sUXN?O VY2K$ߗ֦ͅeHmDm6R5`tPp7'89=k8Keu dm.IW~Kla;->\m'\d>=0FZ GpI7#ӏ]7yS-YBdFwc$Qt\/'nosr#O\ 8ev8E %c#<^y ],Gsz7|[Ϯ}I~K 1lWnGrP8>ؤ,"e$prsYC{>yz7ǧ>d ϮZwۼyO=>LNg1pF<ܒ }.+pyP1zsӸa`?.~8iꅗ"U$D<~{Z\z`T*4p|}UM*4$18S$}#S#?Υ̂M;T9hBY _\q./@htI9Hn[h $fBZF 3#8盵:a'?xKu X"QXF3yΣq򎞝9ϸds2`rIg#1+ E>ﳢ2Ǹ䷫fqZۖm&eAE~U?1#N(.P>R03?,ʄ'9v|0;}*ȳ&~H s? zӭbP<@\R?0ڧ2؈ yOmOv?öӁz]2,P 3ӧ Ermz؛Ƿ\>( B` III#Lxh>|74h|ѷMOEw p@ qn~jRH4m(H-]¥{ jvFabyYqZB٧K\`9_ʜ$ldz=N?UfĒ̌2I E+rΰۆC lr#9Qq_ʿ2hm7T3>ܑ=7ƉF M~154jHr2Qh4t͟4I'Fp?kmS+"d;E]:v!ݷ_'sj6*&1%ha*=ϯ[ew,#Uz*Ihh3DE ņeSR3/ZJ GU Ĩ @##fro8`kOWd9yʍ"՚T!!H?eO-mlX`p? r;s^",*7a#UENӃZca}({'>j)E#x"'=I4.`ҤEs}ե }MئSZܞ*JaU:zsL,e3Sqܧik :̓SY$he|A 2Y \4Hk_捲(`r2z7~FI{^y 7(I6Iz-JLf ȸ%XWJ;>Nϳ>t-˄ wDNF3觯B6Zw$]K[oFh{j;%Y*<)9?JCcvWrI;FAЅ\HxcDl1PT 4[ R4 2)bsWFU&5a?SVvuJ8by?+J]NUXnͲ~lw.KW2Wzԍu}@Rn 3}1N1o1yͺTzQp7*ˌ<Þ>@;mȔ HN}~í2r/^z׆QQ\XW,0;A8(/#5E 8#SC(BI8V=xi!^9Xj$ѯr ͅ 7܎;shJ$ш{V"--iXpϹzӣmAD%m8ț[Tsz*ڳLkK]6 *uB Cq7έeN/Ꞛ,Z>‹ (yW>?y_e/6dž=o, vB17i_7WhnPmj 4)[}?EtUtC_jƕ]7_5:OM=_+Hϩxn\=cmُtyδn4+g0U$F:CICؓx솝)з3!W?_kit<}hz<tY=?籩U& 3q@ gR-㛘sF㷧OYزO6˜:;p2l,.`- #`>d,?OEzڗpNsǿ慰9InOP/?~v8e'ө,@.l \tڸzVkxw,7f qxbzMcJ(?489}Ks[ [%h9$K.zc@h4Z'pc"Y渕8Iss671Un 3jxTyؒ@8\u?JqB@-&|7NuWx*p}xG%8llry/V*̧8ʦF`O-ؑu R K hF.'-瀣^:?JksBi<;tw;#]2Đ{dvyJy&nAb'bIԖvR$j|;g׹*EoiŰ}.@`@fAY|rNN8Q,oX3K8 'sѨyeuz:Sfg(7x8tNz =F ߼mN;=j$G-.ss9~~3!]y6Fs3[\yݝn}GuVuc\<9BCh61pOAԞs͌2l!īaHGN{gǵt Ȇ6`8_p{{wSy;6bXnq^w+`]Sp,~?y&LQEqoAiEorn,N?d}ϩ#ҝͬCI`/9ϼ\9װ˺|!ĜODS]C0 wc` ~ gꂮl$ \d=iq>ȣd`Lq`y_/N(ZB7iDi2*IA`5aD@3?Pzҽܒ-d#8wZiRܠ 56,CgM[V1Y-v;m\&1o\?R=)ZasPUo8-RiahK93YA12ܶPcc=d8!+ES=U^ݙ"qIYiV15ݬs)?w Fϸ\VnbjC6#ec G#y;[B>H {==dLQ!Q$)M.ij6IcfPvcXo.c i%pVPW4EL1؜Tv7!Ahα 8NNsN>m Yd$2 ?PqUYkFpvCn/ﭓt[1 ORVY sL(7yh>0?J$ӵI#VLl\qj]u;`4Vb?OJmKo_3d;ua `6=r٩Z9i&6TǨ=j nU 1o[Lׅs۩|#,Vs[<0Q]ȭϲkPO*Yrq?ZIɭs 51Q(̱HTa&V?kLol9Xo'Wׯ@jڢG,cXtW .6{*q={dzyyGFT 0FV\9AֻxTX682A; ~lʢmNFeKTg8˄ۛV8 $Ƀ7*nbBI*&ףZnR[yNA 6;A9IAfgڃ=І{tǚAa μL@\O`jzX p?0Wkgf{06#ztmr),g~=l9N5e7H;]Ո"I߁gH5iAq,b#gXR1lʝi0MQT 'NJW D42GSI `_X#[4 B GOV떯c p?t>?R.M R PTcOH :掚|FeY v01³5yB9#]>edӮ fNr ;|˴}s-.8HYǃ>嵁)=9#SY[ڳ5(1oے~e|'@M` (c!N 5#!l Xa{ekyt<d 2VY71h$Q*C`~@k.'NFQ}ƲpwZɏS c|mv?JhdiK /b?cwN (]n A'Gp$Լe2#O֒ͥ 91,jAoPßLwAS!5Ag򜂯ס lrji94ԅ+Fr̎;㱨1i-eA~\>NF~[q{g+<#+K`ӀM jj'c3r89Жf Ht]m 䞼{?˽*gʪto]2QvEB0j0pzϹ=Jhn\Ns*XA^rvO_fRz1gu ,d+O!5@T@fnEQ#pŌkg,iy&wQ+mc ns??[%QYF=j_p $ ǻ{{~<p]uh![)[3^ #8#n ep;g5zrp{NQQ ϫ9eKitHM0A(hi >J($2;XEUѱ~12ΐ)dc'?Z馍T>6}*[/+Hcq%t+8t $ @g=MRY伍1>}(LAHrQEAbC$,0ږlpP"91*ԶKD,%C;|8$TQE MM%%_\?ɪ)e~]/_钊qBz"ⅎ?66&]gUk)epBuE%뛈t#UNO9Ͽ$y+.]7#NI袠S'/+,HV@1?(ew!%˞gCXUprya]Tc(ܐQCݵR L*:){%ć Ź,{gEFw0H#( %'?:}j#mGǘT;sGRhq s)z`2iGe~v[񓎹ϩQG3X<,peX$w(nbyZS\#(##RTVd K 8Uv)*KTf6uܱ#s5~X(ONh2GATD?4-"&4]"`7uTփ)j+p+acCW֧mUme盁lC?E7$CzE+#07;mEPxKE 03MG>(K[8܏-l}9-=O2KeGf*cV2A؃{p>1nm-U,<ҌQrcWkh%yegh%D]^;RaRb ! HY7(lG@$v0,l(Uܨ!YVرxTCzS1EkA[*3.\e?b^$q#Y9 1'?Z(F=m{H1$u4.P8O +EN#q>\1W;M?_fH89\;aQE41oa[1z4y9؄V??U)!+ji+ A`3ЀH>Z7"k7UOȞSQNсزQd>AVڤ##"mܤ>(iS="& uRGw+>؊Fo#?QsE&^kgjYԞcn÷<Y|m l?SEҰv-N;th?O1ہ*1}q2ꀹ*zQE+j;Oynemݴ78bYbN@+ݑOU8?Z(%"ePH)4QL C4QLC|G(.YTrd E&4?I!{dYs3?Ie26;\nh*';^QQ)Z v@\n#@.2)'О~QR-2PDK:L@FEHLtoAn܊]X Ɗ(B㙅<(
Warning: fopen(https://newsweekme.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/10_28_VotingScience_02-780x439.jpg): failed to open stream: HTTP wrapper does not support writeable connections in /home/newsweekme/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-image-editor.php on line 428

FROM CHAD TO WORSE: Letting people rank their choices might have kept Trump from winning the Republican nomination.

No voting scheme can ever be entirely fair. But the system in the U.S. is among the worst

By Paul Raeburn
From time to time during this turbulent election season, it has seemed that the Republican standard-bearer might tell his staff they’re fired and return to New York real estate. It’s a world Donald Trump understands—a world where losing a billion dollars can be a good thing. Suppose he’d done that. Or suppose he had become sick or disabled. (There were risks on the other side too; pneumonia could have taken out Hillary Clinton).

If a candidate disappears midway through an election, what is the fairest way to replace him or her? You might argue that the voters’ second choice should take over.

But we have no way of knowing who the second choice in a given election would be—an inevitable consequence of our single-vote system.

Game theorists—researchers whose specialty is the study of strategic thinking—say there would be no fair way to replace Trump under our electoral system. But that’s only one of the things that’s wrong with how Americans vote in political elections. In some other systems, elections could have pared down the Republican primary field of 17 candidates to a more manageable number much sooner, giving voters a simpler and clearer set of choices.

Among game theorists, “everybody has their favorite version of voting,” says Kevin Zollman, a game theorist and associate professor of philosophy at Carnegie Mellon University. “But it’s fair to say that almost everybody agrees that the current way we do it is the worst.”

We’re not talking about hanging chads here, or stuffed ballot boxes. Those are the mechanics. We’re also not talking about the baseless Republican allegations of voter fraud that have prompted legislation making it difficult for some poor and minority voters to exercise their franchise. The problem with voting in the U.S. goes far deeper than that. “The big problem with the way we do elections now is we don’t ask people for their second choice,” Zollman says.

That failure to inquire about second choices could partly explain why Trump secured the nomination, even though he was not most people’s first choice. Here’s how:

According to the website RealClearPolitics, Trump received more than 13 million votes in the Republican primary. But PolitiFact reports that his top three challengers—Ted Cruz, John Kasich and Marco Rubio—received more than 15 million votes combined.

The trio of challengers split a total vote that topped Trump. And many of those 15 million voters might have preferred one of the other top-tier candidates to Trump as their second choice. But there is no way of knowing, because they were able to choose only one candidate.

In a New York Times op-ed in early October, former Democratic presidential candidate Howard Dean proposed the adoption of what game theorists call instant-runoff elections. Voters rank the candidates from first to last. If one candidate wins a majority of first-place votes, the election is over. The result is the same as what happens now.

If no candidate gets a majority, the candidate with the fewest first-place votes is eliminated. Those who made that choice no longer have a first-place choice, so their second choice is now bumped up to first. That changes all the tallies. It could give one of the remaining candidates a majority. If it does, the election is over. If not, the process repeats until one candidate attains a majority.

That system would have allowed a primary-­state voter to choose Trump first—perhaps as a protest vote—and say, Cruz second. If enough voters did that, Cruz could have received a majority and knocked off Trump. Dean argues that this is “a solution to the problem of how to uphold majority rule and give more voice to voters by presenting them with more than two options.”

The nonprofit, nonpartisan group FairVote—chaired by former Nirvana bassist Krist Novoselic—says on its website that ranked-choice voting “has improved elections in cities and states across the United States” and “has majority support in every U.S. city that uses it.” Those cities include Berkeley, California; Cambridge, Massachusetts; San Francisco; St. Paul, Minnesota; and Portland, Maine. In November, Maine voters will decide whether to adopt Question Five, which would establish ranked-choice voting for the state’s 2018 primary and elections for governor, House, the Senate and the state Legislature.

Game theorists argue that a ranked system could have advantages in the presidential election too. Voters who favored Democratic primary challenger Bernie Sanders but who feared Trump could have ranked Sanders first and Clinton second, reducing the likelihood that a vote for Sanders would tip the election to Trump. Democrats who believe that Ralph Nader’s insurgent candidacy in 2000 tipped the election away from Al Gore to George W. Bush might find this interesting. Nader voters had no opportunity to rank Gore second, as many of them might have done.

And what if, through some yet unimagined plot twist, Trump did make an early exit from the presidential race? With ranked voting, the second choice would be immediately clear. Many voters might consider that alternative a fairer outcome than what would likely happen now: Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus would gather with political operatives in a smoke-free room to take the choice out of the voters’ hands. A likely pick would be Republican vice presidential candidate Mike Pence, the governor of Indiana. The merits of that choice aside, Pence was not anybody’s first choice or even 17th choice in the Republican primaries, in part because he wasn’t a candidate. Voters might accept the expediency of such a choice, but few would consider it fair.

As elegant as other voting systems might be, none solves all the problems. Indeed, game theorists have proved it. In the 1950s, Nobel Prize-winning economist Kenneth Arrow devised what is called Arrow’s impossibility theorem, which shows—with irrefutable mathematics, for those who understand it—that no election can be entirely fair. It’s not possible. But as Zollman points out, we could do much better. Ask the mirror on the wall: The U.S. is far from being the fairest of them all.

Social Streams

Comments

comments

Facebook Comments

Post a comment